4 ms·
So, how would a reformed thief go in to buy basic goods once this becomes more widespread? Do we no longer believe that someone can pay off their debt to socie
by falcolas 11y ago
So, how would a reformed thief go in to buy basic goods once this becomes more widespread?
Do we no longer believe that someone can pay off their debt to society and become a useful member of said society?
- ddalex 11y agoNope. Fuck them anyway, and fuck any twins of said thieves. Fuck them doppelgangers, and any person resembling them. And any false positives, for that matter. I, for one, welcome our precog overlords.
- falcolas 11y agoSo, no, you don't believe in someone being able to reform. The rest was not really necessary.
- ddalex 11y agoThe big, black one that breaths heavily, that's his father. The rest was not really necessary.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- PeterisP 11y agoLet's say that 90% people of thieves successfully reform and become honest people. Assuming that 1% or less of general population are thieves, it still would mean that a previously known thief has a 10% chance of being 'unreformed', and that they are a 10 times bigger risk than the average person; and it's not prohibited to use that information to safeguard yourself.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoWe're talking here about thieves that hadn't been caught by the Police. Maybe the way to handle it could be that if you're a thief and had a change of heart, report to the local Police station and agree to serve your time in exchange for getting your face removed from the database.
- Radle 11y agoWait we are talking about, data that could be easily manipulated because "I don't like him" ?
- TeMPOraL 11y agoIs it in the interest of grocery stores to exclude customes without a good reason?
- ogreveins 11y agoYou're missing the largest issue. If the customer is just a dick and did nothing illegal the store owner out of spite might put him or her into the database to be flagged in every other store. Hopefully the significant fines would keep this at bay. In all honesty kicking the store off the system would be the best way to stop it.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoI see your point and you're right, this is a potential problem - mostly because networking this system would make consequences explode out of proportion. Maybe some appeal system could resolve that? As a side note: I support the right of store owner to punish dick customers. I believe society needs to have stronger mechanisms to penalize douchy behaviour.
- pavel_lishin 11y ago> As a side note: I support the right of store owner to punish dick customers. I believe society needs to have stronger mechanisms to penalize douchy behaviour. I agree with this, but I don't believe that a store ought to be able to farm out this punishment to every other retailer that subscribes to this system. If a customer is being a dick, bar him from your establishment; don't subscribe them to be discriminated against and harassed everywhere else.
- 11y ago
- Someone1234 11y agoThe article makes no reference to how the positive result may be used. For all we know it might only be used to allow shop associates to further monitor certain individuals. Although I'm sure some local corner shop will try and "ban" a positive result and make the headlines. That's inevitable. But for the larger shops, I doubt they will make it known that they know.
- legulere 11y agoFrom the article: > "The people who are on the list are not guilty until they've been prosecuted and taken to court, and the system makes that very clear", Simon says - and under the Data Protection Act "if anyone misuses that data there are very significant fines". Probably someone will follow you around the shop or ask you if they can help you instead of you not being let in into the shop. Those are already pretty common tactics. Those tactics also don't feel nice though (I experienced them first hand, when I was in a foreign country and was a bit nervous in shops - not because I was shoplifting but because I wasn't sure wether I would be understood by the cashier).
- falcolas 11y agoSo, they are put on a list and discriminated against _after_ paying for the original crime, on the belief that they are incapable of reforming. Personally, I'm not comfortable with that concept.
- imaginenore 11y agoThe stats are not in the favor of your argument: "Property offenders were the most likely to be rearrested, with 82.1 percent of released property offenders arrested for a new crime compared with 76.9 percent of drug offenders, 73.6 percent of public order offenders and 71.3 percent of violent offenders." http://www.nij.gov/topics/corrections/recidivism/pages/welcome.aspx http://www.nij.gov/topics/corrections/recidivism/pages/welco...
- falcolas 11y agoThe stats don't matter, IMHO. It could be 99% of them who re-offend; to segregate and discriminate against them after they have paid for their crime is a strike against the basic human rights of those people.
- imaginenore 11y agoNo it isn't. If 81% of them are re-arrested (which means much more than 81% commit the crime again), a little inconvenience and suspicion is fully justified.
- MicroBerto 11y agoIf a "reformed thief" is in my store, I would love to know about it and provide him a friendly escort. All the way to checkout. He's of course welcome to never come back again. Seems like a fair trade off. Not my job to feel bad for criminals, it's my job to put food on the table legally.
- ugexe 11y agoThe history of people who enter your store is none of your business. Or are you really suggesting that you support segregation?
- MicroBerto 11y agoEverything in my building is my business. That's why it's called... a business.
- ugexe 11y agoA business does not get a free pass to act however they want in many parts of the first world. The classic examples are discrimination based on religion, disability, or race.
- PeterisP 11y agoThere are a bunch of characteristics based on which we shouldn't discriminate people, and in the first world it is illegal to do so. Your reputation is not like that, everybody should treat you according to your reputation, wether it's good or bad.
- timthorn 11y agoIn the UK, we have the Rehabilitation of Offenders Act to give convicted criminals the ability to reform and reenter society.