3 ms·
I'm kind of suspicious that according to the article the same factory is making 'bad' pens for China and 'good' pens for export. I'm no expert on process impro
by ZeroGravitas 11y ago
I'm kind of suspicious that according to the article the same factory is making 'bad' pens for China and 'good' pens for export.
I'm no expert on process improvements, but it would generally seem that once the cost to create the good pens has been spent, it would be relatively cheap to apply them to both product lines.
Which suggests either they intentionally use cheaper parts (cheaper ink?) on one line, or they have a sophisticated binning system and can identify the borderline pens and remove them from the flow going to export and instead send them to the less demanding domestic market.
- mabcat 11y agoThe example in the article is that export pens get twice as much QA time (two test clicks instead of one test click) which involves twice the QA labour cost as for domestic-market pens. Same components, different process. More generally I've had products manufactured in China for sale in Australia, and they certainly had more expensive parts than products assembled on the same line for sale into China. Never in a million years would the domestic units have passed certification for sale in Australia. So you just keep slotting in more expensive, higher-spec parts until the unit's safe and saleable.
- ZeroGravitas 11y agoAs I said, I'm no expert, but an extra click in the QA process doesn't seem to account for domestic pens being of famously bad quality. They're coming off the same production line, so if an unusual amount of pens were failing after the second click, then either they bin lots of pens intended for export and allow lots of broken pens to ship domestically, or they fix the problem on the line, and both sets of pens get better as a result.
- nibnib 11y agoTheir sophisticated binning is clicking the pens to make sure they work. Export markets get an extra click. Presumably some factories don't do any testing or binning and just let the defects through (for the domestic product). This is a great insight into labour costs in China for manufacturing at these kind of scales: http://www.bunniestudios.com/blog/?p=4364 http://www.bunniestudios.com/blog/?p=4364