4 ms·
But you can say this to anything open, "why not .doc support?" for example, there are benefits other than bitrates to open standards. Think video editing and re
by drats 17y ago
But you can say this to anything open, "why not .doc support?" for example, there are benefits other than bitrates to open standards. Think video editing and re-mixing/quoting for academic and news purposes (fair use/fair dealing). Think of the open source voice recognition to subtitling that proprietary audio codecs, over vorbis, would prevent (vorbis actually saves you bandwidth vs a lot of the other audio codecs because it is better: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vorbis#Quality:_Codec_comparisons http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vorbis#Quality:_Codec_compariso...). Think of browser, service and device innovators who will be locked out of competition by the big guys. I thought this was a forum for hackers, dreamers and entrepreneurs, not for videophiles making rather picky distinctions (I really don't see what the big deal is, if you look at the ogg comparison page posted elsewhere on the thread there isn't much difference and it's clear this is mainly about Apple protecting their iTouch/iPhone/Quicktime/iMovie/Finalcut video stack from those who would disrupt the market with Google and MS along with Apple for the ride).
- senko 17y agoYour .doc example is a good one. Mozilla explicitly refusing to support both H264 and Theora (because they want to make a stand) is like OpenOffice refusing to read both doc and odt, because doc is proprietary format. I would prefer to see open, unpatented and free video codec used for the majority of web video. I applaud Mozilla for taking a stance. I don't applaud them taking a stance by limiting their users' freedom, instead of directly talking to Google, Vimeo and others and lobbying for the use of more open formats. Surely, a letter from Mozilla "hey guys, we really think you should support Theora too, let's meet and we'll tell you why we think it's very important" would have more effect than random blog articles & what amounts to blackmail?