5 ms·
Hardware decoding makes h264 usable on low-power devices like phones which Google sees as the future of the internet. It's technically superior and also support
by jonknee 17y ago
Hardware decoding makes h264 usable on low-power devices like phones which Google sees as the future of the internet. It's technically superior and also supported out of the box by 97% of new computers.
It's not a real surprise that Google built in support for h264--they have petabytes of h264 video and sell phones that play h264 with built-in hardware decoding. Oh and it looks better.
- kevingadd 17y agoIf one of Microsoft's video codecs like VC-1 offered even better power efficiency and technical superiority, and "looked better" than h264 (whatever THAT means), would you still be a fan of using the "best available" proprietary codec? Would you be in favor of Google and other companies paying Microsoft license fees to use the codec? Or would you be arguing for the use of the "inferior" h264?
- jonknee 17y agoIf it was already shipping on 97% of computers and had widespread hardware acceleration support in mobile devices, sure why not? I have no allegiance to h264.
- greyfade 17y agoIt does. VC-1 has hardware support in a number of areas and is included in WMP since at least 10, IIRC. h.264 still is not supported on any version of Windows before 7, and is only available in Flash. Supporting h.264, with your logic, makes no sense.
- jrockway 17y agoHardware decoding makes h264 usable on low-power devices like phones which Google sees as the future of the internet. This is true. But, if I had to choose between paying $20 extra for a better processor (that can play Theora) or $20 extra for a patent license (to legally play h.264), I would pick the former. At least I can use the better processor when I'm not watching video; the patent license only works for the 10 minutes a year I feel like looking at Youtube on my phone. It's technically superior and also supported out of the box by 97% of new computers. Nice statistic. What percentage of Internet users have "new computers", though? (I work at a company with 300,000 employees. We still use Windows XP; two versions behind the latest stable version of Windows!) You are right that h.264 is technically superior to Theora. The Space Shuttle is technically superior to my bicycle, but due to cost concerns, I have to ride my bike to work rather than fly there on the space shuttle. Sometimes the best solution is not the one you can afford. (I can't afford an h.264 license. Or rather, I won't afford it. I don't care that much about seeing a cat flushing a toilet on my phone.)
- jonknee 17y ago> Nice statistic. What percentage of Internet users have "new computers", though? (I work at a company with 300,000 employees. We still use Windows XP; two versions behind the latest stable version of Windows!) The same h.264 files can be played with Flash, which is ubiquitous on "old" computers like you have at work. Everyone can watch now and when they upgrade they can watch without needing Flash. Ogg doubles storage requirements for the foreseeable future without any gain.
- elblanco 17y agoI'm just curious, in a number crunching kind of way, what's the per-browser cost for Google for Chrome vs. just buying more hard drives? I'm sure somebody has done the math on this.
- ZeroGravitas 17y agoPart of the problem is that there's a cap on the fees. Google/Youtube and other large conglomerates are already paying that cap ($5 million per year is a figure I've seen thrown around) so they get a pricing advantage compared with smaller startups. This makes sense for those collecting the fees because the big players could move the market by themselves if they switch so there's no use squeezing them for money, when you can use them to lure in large numbers of smaller players.