9 ms·
Barnes and Noble is dying, Waterstones in the U.K. is thriving. Why?
- lmm 11y agoAll the books mentioned in the article are links to Amazon. Which is why I ultimately think Waterstones is still doomed; I kept going in until recently, but even when I saw a book I liked, I'd be put off by how heavy the paper edition was. Still, the lesson is a good one. Many people are good at their jobs if you trust their judgement and delegate responsibility.
- Symbiote 11y ago> All the books mentioned in the article are links to Amazon They link to Amazon with referral ids from Slate Magazine, so Slate earn a cut. But Waterstones run an online book shop: https://www.waterstones.com/ https://www.waterstones.com/, and the "Christmas" banner at the top seems to link to a semi-curated collection of titles.
- noir_lord 11y agoI'm in the UK. Most of this article sounds familiar from frequently visiting Waterstones, it really has improved remarkably, the selection of books that people would actually read is excellent, the sci-fi section expanded and they moved it to the second floor (which made sense, ground floor is prime real estate for shifting volume and sci-fi isn't (mostly) volume). They put a Cafe in on the 2nd floor which is nice if you just want to grab a coffee after a browse or buy your book and go read it with a coffee. The staff where always pleasant and helpful so that hasn't really changed.
- Doctor_Fegg 11y agoInsightful, and chimes absolutely with my experience. I live near Oxford, UK, where we have the peerless Blackwells, an academic-biased but broad-based bookshop (http://bookshop.blackwell.co.uk/stores/oxford-bookshop/about-us/ http://bookshop.blackwell.co.uk/stores/oxford-bookshop/about...) where you can literally get lost for an afternoon. I would typically walk straight past Waterstones on the way there. Now, since the Daunt era began, I spend almost as much time in Waterstones as I do in Blackwells. Waterstones is where I go if I want to be surprised with a new book I haven't yet heard of. The 'new titles' displays on the ground floor often showcase books from smaller publishers which I'd never have found myself. "Curated" is an overused word these days, but it's exactly what they're doing, and doing well. What the article doesn't mention is that Waterstones, under previous ownership, took over other good UK bookshop chains - notably Ottakars and Dillons. This was generally met with rending of garments and gnashing of teeth, because Waterstones at the time was the lowest common denominator High Street bookshop. But Waterstones now is better than I remember Ottakars or Dillons ever being.
- irremediable 11y agoI remember when Borders (another bookshop chain) went bankrupt and they closed down the Oxford branch. By the time I reached it, they were desperately trying to sell trash books at any price, just to make back money. They were also begging people to buy the shelving.
- JulianMorrison 11y agoI remember when that place was awesome, and I spent many happy hours there. I was devastated to see it go, but yeah, in the end it had hollowed out to garbage, stationery, and toilet humor. Bleh.
- jamespo 11y agoI'm sure the coffee shop there was put in tourist guides as a good place to sit down all day... rarely did I see a coffee bought, just students with large piles of books in front of them
- JulianMorrison 11y agoHuh, I'd mentally flagged that one as "dead space, ignore". I should clear that flag and re-investigate.
- OJFord 11y agoYour last paragraph is exactly right. I remember the local Ottakar's changing to an at-the-time shabbier, down-market Waterstones. Today, when I go home there's a clean-fronted Waterstones that's warm and pleasant. My memory of Ottakar's is distinctly drabber; dirty even, worn out.
- daemonk 11y agoI guess there is value in the experience of purchasing a book as much as the book's content.
- Someone1234 11y agoTL;DR: Slash costs (i.e. fire tons of people, discontinue unprofitable stock) and target stores better for their demographics. I've spent a lot of time in both B&N and Waterstones. B&N has a lot of problems Waterstones never had even ahead of bankruptcy: - The stores are too big. 1/2 of a B&N store is tat, reference books, niche stock, a Nook display area, and other nonsense. You could cut almost all B&N stores in half and not notice as a customer. - They place them poorly. B&N is perfect for foot traffic. But B&Ns are typically located as drive-up "out of town" shopping. Somewhere you need to go to intentionally. They need to be in malls. - No good Nook tie-in for the stores. My SO often goes into B&N and looks at books, and then says "I'll buy it on my Nook later." They should have made an agreement with the publishers YEARS ago: When you buy a physical book, you get the Nook book included. - The children's area is really nice, but poorly leveraged. No classes, no reading groups, no reason to come in. Stay at home parents WANT a reason to get out of the house, you offer a free reading group for small kids, the parents will buy the books after the group. - Atmosphere in the coffee shop is bad. Waterstones feels like a nice little swanky coffee shop, somewhere you'd go and work on your novel, B&N's coffee shop feels like a generic coffee shop at the airport. - B&Ns has no brand, and keeps making it worse. 3D printers, toys, Nooks, what is it that B&Ns is? They're all over the place, and now when you go into a B&N store you'll never know what they'll be pushing this week. I think B&N will go under. I just don't think the management is very good, and every attempt they make to right the ship makes it worse. The whole business needs to be restructured.
- alistairSH 11y agoB&N's coffee shop is a generic coffee shop. At my (now closed) local B&N, it was a Starbucks. With very little seating. And too loud pop music. It was not a place somebody would ever go to sit and read a chapter of the latest novel.
- enraged_camel 11y agoNot all Starbucks coffee shops are generic. Some of them have really nice layouts with cozy corners and comfortable couches and they play jazz or classical music at reasonable volumes. But those tend to be in high-end areas, and B&N is definitely not high-end.
- zschuessler 11y agoI recently visited a Barnes & Noble for Christmas shopping. I was shocked at the markup! A $13 brand-new hardcover on Amazon is $30+ at Barnes & Noble. All books were 2-3x the price I saw on my phone. I noted a few I wanted, and bought them from Amazon the next day. Same-day delivery, no less! I understand competing can be hard, but the markup they are pushing is unnecessary. I fondly remember in my youth grabbing a book and a drink from their cafe. I would sit down and read an hour or two while my mother shopped around. I'd love to see B&N survive by innovating instead of relying on egregious markup. Perhaps a coffee shop with a book rental service? (Pay by the hour, all you can read, or something along those lines. Additionally, sell new books as they do now) At any rate, B&N needs to get creative. Their current model will be increasingly difficult to perpetuate.
- pjc50 11y agoThe number of unsold books that were returned to publishers fell from about 20 percent before Daunt took over to just 4 percent today. A small but important waste reduction. It seems that by freeing the staff he's created what's effectively a chain of indie bookstores, where each one has its character determined by the staff. This works because people who work in bookstores are far more likely to love books than other kinds of retail workers love their product (except maybe some fashion brands, but they're tightly brand-controlled).
- techterrier 11y agoLots of indie stores with the buying clout of a chain too!
- TheOtherHobbes 11y agoThat's not small - that's huge. Books are stocked sale-or-return. Upgrading your hit-rate from 80% to 96% takes epic customer insight. I suspect the range has shrunk, so there won't be many quirky or indie books. But they're mostly doing okay online. So... >It seems that by freeing the staff he's created what's effectively a chain of indie bookstores. There must be more going on, otherwise staff would make random picks of whatever they're into and fail to sell them - which is what happens to a lot of indies. But I think there's another difference - the UK still has a culture of literacy of sorts, while in the US that's much less obvious. So although the population is much bigger, I wouldn't be surprised if the number of active book buyers - as opposed to the best-seller-a-year crowd - is about the same. Spread those over a much bigger geographical area and there are problems of delivery, stock choice, and logistics that don't apply in the UK. The Waterstones model could possibly work in the US, but B&N would have to kill its warehouses, move its non-book stock online, and rent plenty of smaller city centre shops near business and tourist districts - which would be expensive and risky without some trial runs.
- thaumasiotes 11y ago> Upgrading your hit-rate from 80% to 96% takes epic customer insight. Well, no. If you cut the number of books you ordered down to 1, it wouldn't be very difficult to get 100% hit-rate. (Until your store died, of course). You need more than just the single statistic.
- bonesinger 11y agoI love Barnes and Noble, however, one of my issues with BN is that they are mostly out of the way and not near malls where they'd get a lot of traffic. Another issue I think is absolutely mind boggling is that their online prices are not what's in store; you can't even price match their website with their own in-store pricing, let alone price matching with Amazon. I generally browse BN and then pull up Amazon to check pricing there, and either order the book with same-day delivery/next day or buy the e-book. Its still cheaper to pay for same day/next day than to buy it in store.
- kevin_thibedeau 11y agoThat sort of behavior is what is killing retail. If you're going to browse the showroom it is more than a little backhanded to then buy from an online competitor with less overhead. If I find a product I want to buy in a store I will buy it there. More often than not, though, retailers don't have what I need and I end up forced to buy online anyway.
- MrZongle2 11y ago"If you're going to browse the showroom it is more than a little backhanded to then buy from an online competitor with less overhead." How so? Why is it my responsibility as a consumer to ensure that certain companies stay in business?
- macintux 11y agoIt's only your responsibility to later not gripe about the fact that showrooms no longer exist.
- bonesinger 11y agoI'm in no way obligated to buy something in the store, especially when they have obfuscated policies regarding pricing. How can you justify a higher price in store when you have a lower price online and your competitor has a lower price and same day delivery? I get 25% BN discount from my gf's teacher discount and stuff is still more expensive than their own online pricing. If I find a significant price difference, I'm going to buy it online. However, I will go out of my way to purchase at small business because there are benefits to that.
- alistairSH 11y agoI see parallels in other industries as well. I recently purchased a new camera (Olympus PL6). Normally, I just order my electronics online. However, in this case, the size and feel of the camera was very important to me, as I'll be using it on a cycling trip next year. I wanted something to complement my pocket-sized Canon S-series. I swung by my local Best Buy to see some of the options in person. They didn't have much of a selection. A few full size DSLRs and a bunch of cheap point and shoots. Maybe one Sony mirrorless. This seemed to be true of all the areas. The shop was a bit of a ghost town. Lots of "stuff", but nothing to get excited about (and I'm a gadget geek). So, I went to the local camera specialty shop. It's a bit further away, but it was nice to get all the options spread out on the counter, chat with a knowledgeable salesperson, and end up buying something. Yes, it was full retail, but I got what I wanted, no regrets. Same for my local bicycle shop. I can order most of the stuff online, but for some items, having knowledgeable staff and items I can touch is worth the extra retail markup. But, the items need to be in stock, the salesperson needs to be able to help me, and the atmosphere must be something enjoyable.
- gutnor 11y ago> Yes, it was full retail, but I got what I wanted, no regrets. That's something worth noting. People say you vote with your wallet, but they don't. If you need to see something in person, then by all means, pay the shop the price it asks and do not buy it on Amazon later. If you need to see it, then buy it where you can see it, not send mixed signals: thumbs up for amazon, thumbs down to the local shop while you actually needed the opposite. I have no shame shopping better price on Amazon or others. But once I have needed to put a foot into a physical store, a physical store will get my money.
- jefurii 11y agoThis. You're paying more in the physical store, but you derived benefit from the experience of going in there. If you want to live in a future where you can go to attractive stores and look at physical items, you have to be willing to help support those stores. Real estate and staff are not free.
- hibikir 11y agoB&N is really suffering from a way bigger problem in the US: The death of retail. Other than a few big cities, the cost of going to a store in the US is far higher than in Europe, just because e have to actively go to a store, instead of passing them on the way to work. This is what made American stores into big boxes: Since people had to make specific trips to the store, it paid to make them big, fill them up with lots of inventory, and make them service large areas. But then the internet happened, and as internet retail gets getter and better, the weakest stores suffer, and the weakest of the lot are bookstores and electronics stores. We've seen competition in those areas dwindle already, because the market just couldn't hold: CompUSA, Circuit City, Borders, are gone, but it's not as if the survivors are thriving: Their sales are still getting eaten by Amazon more and more every year. So B&N will probably manage to stay alive until the next economic crisis happens, consumers start buying a bit less, and the internet eats them alive. In more dense urban areas, very efficient book retailers will still have a chance for a while, because it is often more convenient to buy at a local store than to buy online. They'll still have to be afraid of the switch to ebooks though.
- toyg 11y ago> They'll still have to be afraid of the switch to ebooks though. Not if they do it right. I buy ebooks and hardly ever go to a bookshop these days, but I used to love browsing through physical shelves looking for "enticing" items and miss that experience dearly. Would I pay an extra £1 or £5 to get that experience back? In a heartbeat. What they need is an augmented experience where i can show up at the store with my e-reader, go through books, and when i find a nice one, let me "point" the reader at it to download it seamlessly. The reader should figure out I'm in a bookstore and, after fulfilling my request, send a percentage of generated revenue to the store operators. You could do this today, either as an Amazon affiliate or with a custom website API. You don't even need to risk overstocking: get one book for each title, nothing more. You could even open the API to third parties and let indy shops bloom. But you would have to be competent, forward-looking and not afraid of change -- qualities sorely lacking in the whole retail sector, and not particularly valued in publishing either.
- jdmichal 11y ago
- daxfohl 11y agoSeems like there was a move in the 90's to gigantify everything. Bookstores, electronics stores, gyms, etc. It was awesome because they had so much more selection than anything prior. Now with the internet, that's no longer the case. There's absolutely no reason to drive out to a strip mall to find the book / electronics you want. Mega-gyms still succeed. Retailers need to find something else. I wouldn't be surprised if malls start making a comeback in the US. There are lots of times you want to browse through tangible miscellanea, and the internet doesn't give you that. But it'll be different than the 80's, as shops in the mall will have to know better how to cater to a specific local demographic; generic won't cut it anymore. I wouldn't be surprised if they were anchored by fresh markets, the quintessence of "local".
- greedo 11y agoI think the high costs of using a mall location will cripple any boutique business that can't charge Apple-esque margins.
- 7952 11y agoIn the UK we have "garden centres" that feel like an iteration on malls. They tend to target a particular demographic very well (older people) and sell various side lines that are very profitable (like gifts, clothing, toys, and books). The quality of the plants act as very good word of mouth marketing device that brings people in. They don't have to bother trying to appeal to everyone.
- hardlianotion 11y agoSounds like Daunt simply recalled what made Waterstones so attractive as it rose to prominence in the 1980s.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- GregQuinn 11y agoWaterstones also has a click and collect system. You can order books on-line through their website and pick them up at any store. The on-line price is also lower than the store price.
- frisco 11y agoWow, the current B&N CEO's resume reads like a hit list of terrible projects: Sears, Brookstone, Best Buy, Toys R Us. I'd be really curious to know the decision making that goes into hiring someone like that to run B&N. It's sad, because I really like B&N, and feel like there is a strategy to make it relevant in the changed reality - but a generic leader from "retail" with experience mostly in companies that have specifically failed to adapt is not going to get there.
- mcguire 11y agoMy feeling is that that may have more to do with B&N's recent problems than any specific strategy.
- astine 11y agoIt's likely that they believe that even experience running a business into the ground is better than no experience at that level at all. It's possible that they don't even blame him for the failures and just chuck it up to the market.
- dmfdmf 11y agoI used to hang out at the B&N a couple of times a month and bought a number of books per year. They got rid of all the comfy chairs and tables throughout the store and now the only place to sit and read or peruse a book I am thinking about buying is in the noisy, uncomfortable in-store Starbucks. To avoid this customers are sprawled uncomfortably on the floor, sitting in windows sills, etc. amongst the books, its a bad joke. I stopped going and haven't bought a book from them in years.
- eggestad 11y agothe US is just ahead in the curve. The brittish are naturally so onservative, if not outright reactionary, that the new buisness models haven't had the same impact yet. In Scandinavia online shopping has taken on almost as well as in the US, and bookstores there is suffering just as bad a B&N. This is despite actually having done much of the advice offered in this thread. ARK in Norway have outlets in all the Malls (still the most popuar shopping places in Norway) adn outlet in walking market districts in the cities. They cut their inventory to high volume books only. Still struggeling....
- justincormack 11y agoNo the UK is one of the largest online shopping markets per capita in the world.
- ascorbic 11y agoNot just one of the largest: it is the largest, and by a large margin too. http://www.cityam.com/205546/uk-has-most-valuable-online-shopping-market-developed-world http://www.cityam.com/205546/uk-has-most-valuable-online-sho...
- DanBC 11y ago> The brittish are naturally so onservative, if not outright reactionary, that the new buisness models haven't had the same impact yet. Wut? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tesco#Internet_retailing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tesco#Internet_retailing > In May 1984, in Gateshead, England, the world's first recorded online home shopper, Mrs Jane Snowball, purchased groceries from her local Tesco store in the world's first recorded online shopping transaction from the home.[50] Tesco has operated on the internet since 1994 and was the first retailer in the world to offer a robust home shopping service in 1996. Tesco.com was formally launched in 2000. Grocery sales are available within delivery range of selected stores, goods being hand-picked within each store, in contrast to the warehouse model followed by Ocado. > As of November 2006, Tesco was the only food retailer to make online shopping profitable.
- to3m 11y ago
- macjohnmcc 11y agoI went into a B&N store and found a book that I was going to buy. They wanted far more in the store than they did on their own online bookstore and offered no in store pick up on the web. I would have bought the book from them then and there if they had matched the price or met me somewhere in the middle. Instead of buying from BN.com I just went to Amazon.com and got it in two days all this while I was still in the store.
- prostoalex 11y agoDigging into the financials of Barnes & Noble, it's mainly suffering from Nook's underperformance and its inability to command a reasonable share of the ebook market. Here's a news piece on their last quarterly report http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2015-12-03/barnes-noble-posts-loss-as-nook-e-reader-unit-weighs-on-sales http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2015-12-03/barnes-nob... "The company, which spun off its college-bookstore division earlier this year, also has seen store closings eat into revenue." "The bookstore chain said it expects comparable-store sales to be flat this year, with the Nook weighing on results." "Sales decreased 4.5 percent to $894.7 million. But comparable-store sales only fell 0.5 percent when excluding Nook products." "The retailer also has worked to stem losses from the Nook unit by lessening investment and teaming up with Samsung Electronics Co. to produce the devices." So overall the Barnes & Noble brick-and-mortar book+coffee+accessories business is doing relatively okay, what's hurting it is previous investment in e-readers and e-books that's tough to wind down. I remember a similar thesis explored when Borders went bankrupt - comparable-store sales were relatively flat, but the company borrowed immensely to finance expansion, and it was the expansion that didn't pay off. The old school business, if left alone, would've tagged along.
- Apocryphon 11y agoSimilarly, Eslite in Taiwan is flourishing by marketing themselves as a 24-hour source of nightlife, while other large book stores are closing down: http://www.cnn.com/2014/11/23/world/asia/taiwan-bookstores/index.html http://www.cnn.com/2014/11/23/world/asia/taiwan-bookstores/i...
- Elvie 11y agoBack in the day (2000) I worked in a branch of Books, etc. A chain, mostly London based, with some airport branches, soon before their takeover by Borders. When I started working there it worked like the current waterstones in a way, as we, at branch level, saw the publisher's reps and chose the stock for our branch. Only the big 3 for 2 promos came from head office... Then it all changed and we were left with stock that wouldn't shift - 20 copies of a Bjork book in a small branch in the City is an example I remember... Then Borders took over thinking selling books is the same as selling baked beans. By then I was working in the head office getting more and more disillusioned... Honestly, I'm not surprised Borders went down as it tried to follow the B&N system of huge branches in out of town locations...
- tzs 11y agoBarnes and Noble is dying to me because of their idiotic website. When you check to see if a book is available in your local store, you have to enter a zip code. Then when you check another book, you have to enter your zip code again. You have to enter it for every damn book you want to check. Have these people never heard of session cookies? You can login to the site if you have a B&N account (and they remember this...so they DO know about cookies). When logged in you can even set your location, and they remember that...but as far as I can see that is only used to determine what to show you when you ask for upcoming events. It doesn't help with checking to see if a book is available at your local store. B&N as a web seller of books has nothing that tempts me to use them over Amazon (especially since I have Prime). Their sole draw is that they have a big store full of books 15 minutes away from my home, which means that if my store stocks a book I'm waffling about buying online I can go in and take a good look at it. And when I do that there is a good chance that if I decide to buy the book I'll buy right there, both for the convenience of having the book right then and because I do want offline bookstores to stay around. I'm willing to eat the price difference over Amazon for that. They need to have a way on the website to tell it "I'm here because I'm interested in what is in stock in my local store right now...do not show me anything else". If they did that, I'd buy a much larger fraction of my books from my local B&N store.