7 ms·
How the Universal Symbols for Escalators, Restrooms, and Transport Were Designed
- epmatsw 11y agoLink to the full set of symbols, if anyone else is interested: http://www.aiga.org/symbol-signs/ http://www.aiga.org/symbol-signs/
- ggchappell 11y agoThanks! Note, FTA: > They changed one of the three male figures riding in an elevator to a female figure. In the link you posted, the three figures in the elevator are all Helvetica Man. OTOH, the "nursery" symbol is a baby, not a bottle. So it's not the original symbol set, but it might not be the most up-to-date, either. EDIT. The "exit" symbol is interesting. It's a circle split vertically. I don't recall ever seeing that before. (Or perhaps I saw it, but had no idea what it meant.)
- jonsen 11y agoI've seen the Exit symbol. It was green as opposed to the red No Entry.
- wycx 11y agoI guess pipe collecting was big back in the day: http://www.aiga.org/uploadedImages/AIGA/Content/Tools_and_Resources/31_shops.gif http://www.aiga.org/uploadedImages/AIGA/Content/Tools_and_Re...
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- theandrewbailey 11y agoI've been a fan of a webcomic that is nothing but these symbols (and others like them). It looks like XKCD, but with a more machined look. http://www.systemcomic.com/ http://www.systemcomic.com/
- rbrogan 11y agoIt is interesting how the designers were not themselves authoritative.
- rdancer 11y agoGo on?
- Jun8 11y agoWhat would be a good symbol for innovation, other than a lightbulb? For makerspaces?
- WalterBright 11y agoThe icon thing has bugged me since its appearance on the Mac: 1. Companies tend to copyright them, rendering a universal set impossible. At least these universal symbols are not copyrighted. 2. If you don't know what they mean, there's no way to find out. Take the universal symbols (though not in that list) for on and off: | and O. I still cannot remember which is on and which is off. I can't find out, either, without googling for it. With the words "on" and "off", I know what they mean. And more importantly, if I do not know English, I can trivially look up "on" and "off". Why is "|" as a symbol better than "on" as a symbol? Why is "Helvetica Man" inherently better than "men" and "toilet"? Knowing English is not necessary to recognize the words "men" and "toilet" with just as much facility as having enough savvy to remember that a silhouette of a man means "mens toilet". Back in 1985, an Apple salesman showed up at our company to sell us on Macs. Part of his spiel was passing around a sheet of paper with icons on them and asking us what the icons meant. None of us had used a gui before, and he was bitterly annoyed that we guessed wrong on nearly all of them. The one I remember most we decided represented a box of Kleenex. (That one was the 'print' icon.) The air went out of his presentation after that. The idea there was that there was something wrong with using English words, like "print". A phonetic language really is a great advance. Words can be looked up in a dictionary. Where are icons looked up (especially if they are different on every system due to copyrights)? Is learning a dozen standardized English words really harder for someone who knows no English than learning a dozen icons? When I use a gui app, I still have to hover over the icon that somebody got a design award for (sarcasm!) hoping that the coder saw fit to add a tooltip so I know what it does.
- CapitalistCartr 11y agoThe universal symbols for on and off aren't the letters "i and o", they're one and zero.
- WalterBright 11y agoI typed the vertical bar |, not the letter I. But this just goes to my point. I am a college educated man, and have worked in tech for 40 years. Yet I did not know those symbols were supposed to be "1" and "0" until I was told. (None that I've seen looked like "1", which I would have recognized as "one", they all looked like "|".) Even getting past that, how would someone who is illiterate implicitly know that "1" and "0" represent an electrical engineer's view of digital circuitry? I don't grok the thought process behind these symbols. Either that, or I'm a retard. (The Apple salesman had no explanation, either, as to why icons were better. He just thought it was trivially obvious, and was baffled that we didn't immediately "get it".)
- unwind 11y agoBeing a fairly recent parent, on a weekend trip abroad I was annoyed to learn that for some users (this was in otherwise-awesome Amsterdam's Schiphol airport), the "baby bottle" icon doesn't imply that facilities to actually heat baby food are present. I felt like all it meant was that a baby-changing table was installed, which really has very little to do with feeding the baby. The two uses are temporally separated (most times). We ended up going to a café and asking them instead, which of course worked fine but was more costly since it guilted us into having something too. :)
- marknadal 11y agoI've been to 25ish countries and the bathroom symbol is not universal.
- ape4 11y agoThese symbols are so successful. I'd like to to see sets of symbols for some other areas.
- TazeTSchnitzel 11y agoThe AIGA symbols are interesting in the biases they encode. The symbol for "man" is the outline of an adult human. The symbol for "woman" is the outline of an adult human, but wearing a dress. So, male is considered the default. Masculinity is the absence of femininity. The symbol for "toilets" is the symbol for "woman" (an adult human with a dress) next to the symbol for "man" (an human), with a dividing line between them. We heavily associate toilets with sex segregation, apparently. They also show their age: the symbol for currency conversion lacks the Euro and instead has a French franc!
- tetromino_ 11y ago> The symbol for "man" is the outline of an adult human. To me, it shows the outline of an adult, physically fit male human. Observe the narrow hips and wide, square shoulders. Compare with the shoulders on the "woman" symbol. > The symbol for "toilets" is the symbol for "woman" (an adult human with a dress) next to the symbol for "man" (an human), with a dividing line between them. We heavily associate toilets with sex segregation, apparently. It shows a pair of adjacent doors, one labeled "men", the other labeled "women". It doesn't mean sex segregation - quite the opposite, it means that in this building, toilets for both sexes are located right next to each other! (As opposed to on different ends of the floor or on different floors altogether, which was common in older architecture.)
- TazeTSchnitzel 11y ago> To me, it shows the outline of an adult, physically fit male human. Observe the narrow hips and wide, square shoulders. Compare with the shoulders on the "woman" symbol. You have a point there. > It doesn't mean sex segregation - quite the opposite, it means that in this building, toilets for both sexes are located right next to each other! The notion of "toilets for [...] sexes" is inherently sex segregation. It's not "separate but equal" (in the ironic sense), but it's still segregation. Unisex toilets, on the other hand, are not sex-segregated.
- crummy 11y ago
- wodenokoto 11y agoWhat was the problem with the baby bottle?
- rdancer 11y agoIf you go to a feeding room, you're going to breastfeed, not bottle-feed. If the DoT don't want have tits in the pictogram, that's fine, but a bottle is not representative of the activity. Babies are normally breast-fed, and should be breast-fed. Breastfeeding is one of the most important activities of motherhood. The bottle represents an unnatural and less-than-ideal replacement, and insults and cheapens mothers. That's my take on the contemporary arguments. Modern arguments would have a slightly different feminist spin ;-)
- x1798DE 11y agoThis is a kind of weird objection. No one thinks about anything other than feeding a baby if you show them a baby bottle. No one would know what you were going for if you just had a glyph of tits, and anything more precise would be needlessly complicated.
- rdancer 11y agoTits are nude beach; this would be a baby feeding on a teat, something like this[1]. [1] http://imgur.com/QOwxiHp http://imgur.com/QOwxiHp