3 ms·
It's not a brilliant article. Software is not like milk. That analogy is facile and stupid. Software should be more like civil engineering, where it's normal
by TheOtherHobbes 11y ago
It's not a brilliant article.
Software is not like milk. That analogy is facile and stupid.
Software should be more like civil engineering, where it's normal to unleash a big team on a big infrastructure project and still have some hope that costs and deadlines stay under control. Or maybe like movie making where there's a cast of thousands, the time is huge, and the costs are epic, but some projects stay under control - while others don't.
It's maybe more interesting to wonder what's different about software than to look for enlightenment on supermarket shelves. Because the problems stated - multiple communication channels, mistakes in modelling and testing - are handled just fine in other industries.
The crippling issues are that you can't model software, and there's not much of a culture of formal specification.
So you can't test software until you build it, requirements may change iteratively, the latest technical "solutions" often turn out to be short-lived fads, and you're always balancing between Shiny New Thing and Tarpit of Technical Debt. That's why it's hard to build. You have to build your cathedral to see if it stays up when it rains. You can't simulate it first. And even if it stays up it may be the wrong shape, or in the wrong place.
It doesn't help that management often sees software as a cost centre instead of an engine room, and doesn't want to pay a realistic rate for quality, maintainability, and good internal documentation.
Having too many people on a project is not the problem. The problem is more usually having no idea what you're doing, why you're doing it, or how you want it done - but believing that you can throw Agile or Six Sigma (etc) at it to make it work anyway, because Management Theory.
- humanrebar 11y ago> Software should be more like civil engineering, where it's normal to unleash a big team on a big infrastructure project and still have some hope that costs and deadlines stay under control. Since when do giant infrastructure projects meet their budget and calendar goals?
- bryanlarsen 11y agoThere are examples of it happening. The Gotthard base tunnel, the largest in the world, opened ahead of schedule and under budget.
- dragonwriter 11y agoThere are examples of it with software, too. It doesn't seem to be the norm in either domain, however, so I'm not sure that there is a good case to be made that they should be similar in this regard but are not.
- crpatino 11y agoThe Software industry is what Construction would be like if architects were allowed to dream up whatever contrieved designes they would fancy that week, without those pesky engineers telling them that: No, no matter how much they wanted, steel and concrete and stone do not behave that way and Nature does not feel any obligation to comply with the customer's requirements.
- marssaxman 11y ago"Software is not like milk" is exactly the point: the author's observation is that (some) people treat software as though it had scaling economies like a commodity product, when in fact it does not. Software engineering would be like civil engineering if civil engineers had teleporters, matter-replicators, and armies of construction robots capable of building anything from a set of blueprints, without supervision. Software engineering is its own practice and the fact that it is unlike other forms of engineering is a feature, not a bug.