6 ms·
For the first time, less than 10% of the world is living in extreme poverty
- RobertoG 11y agoChina is what makes most of the difference. Even taking into account the democratic and freedom deficits, we have to admit that the achievements of the Chinese are impressive.
- briantakita 11y agoIs this really an improvement, or are more people plugged into our global economic system? Here's a hypothetical story. All names & circumstances are fiction. Take Tan Bao, who lived in a pastoral barter system in his homeland in north-western China. Tan's family had the same trade over many generations. Their flock consisted of 63 sheep, 3 horses, 28 geese, 6 ducks. Tan Bao made $0, yet was able to support his family. Everybody pitched in to subsist. Now developers bought the land that Tan Bao's family has lived on. Tan Bao & his family are evicted. They move to Xi'an. Now, Tan Bao makes $2 a day working in a shoe factory. Hooray! Tan Bao is no longer living in extreme poverty. Yet he & his family miss their ancestral homeland & old way of life.
- Asbostos 11y agoIn real life, Tan Bao wouldn't have been evicted, he would have preferred the opportunity to accumulate money instead of not accumulating money, despite the temporary lower quality of life working in the factory. I'd say he has less poverty now. He can still survive but can also save.
- SapphireSun 11y agoThat's an interesting point. I think that maybe what you're asking for is supplemental indicators such as number of people regularly getting the correct number of calories, have shelter, access to medical care and education. However, those supplemental indicators themselves don't tell you much about how much opportunity people have, of which economic indicators are a proxy for.
- mgraczyk 11y agoSituations like these are an inescapable consequence of population growth. As the number of humans increases, there will inevitably be less space allocated to inefficient activity, where efficiency is determined by an activity's contribution toward sustaining the larger population. Herding 63 sheep is not as efficient as housing 5000 people or stockyarding 500 pigs. Growth is not 100% to blame, but growth is a sufficient cause for your story. It's worth tracking how well humanity copes with these inevitable changes.
- funkyy 11y agoWhen I was young I remember most of my country was considered extreme poverty, but to be honest I was never really hungry, there was no people dying of hunger, people were happy and they appreciated little things. I would not like to see those times come back, but while it was difficult for everyone, it was easily survivable by just doing some jobs.
- industriousthou 11y agoI'm not sure where you're from, but my understanding is that "extreme poverty" literally means that people are dying of hunger. So, if you are able to consistently secure food, you're not living in extreme poverty, but of course, you may still be very, very poor.
- pratyushag 11y agoYes, but how much has the price risen since then? Back then $2 could get you a lot more than today right?
- tim333 11y agoI think they try to take in to account the income from farming to avoid that sort of miscalculation. Obviously there's a lot of leeway as to how to account for that stuff but anecdotally I think things have improved a lot. Especially in China. I was there around 1982 and people were living on gruel and breaking rocks with hammers to make a living, a bit like you'd imagine a prison gang. Now it's quite like the west in terms of living conditions for most.
- vessenes 11y agoYou raise another angle on wealth and income, and one that savvy researchers do look at. I don't know if development economists have a word for it, but I think of it as stability, or a non-monetary safety net. I first was exposed to this idea in Kenya; a friend was losing his job, and I asked what his plan was, knowing that wages are low, and so on. He said worst case, he and his wife would move back to the family farm (un-mortgaged) and build out their cash crops. Although his PPP-adjusted income was lower, lower middle class by American standards, he had something almost nobody under 50 in the 97th percentile has in America; a food and shelter safety net that was fairly resilient, and at the very least, not debt-ridden.
- tomlock 11y agoDoes this take into account inflation? If not, isn't it a pretty unfair graph?
- jpatokal 11y agoYes, it does: the graph says all figures are at 2011 PPP.
- pratyushag 11y agoIn all seriousness, can somebody please help me understand what can be bought for $1.9 and how they came up with this arbitrary number?! I don't know if anybody can even get (or cook) one full meal a day for that... maybe I'm missing something? Why even have such a measure unless it's going to be at least $10/day as one likely needs at least that much just to feed themselves the cheapest possible food they can find.
- industriousthou 11y agoI guess I could get by on $1.90 per day for food in the US if I had to, but it would really suck. But the article is about extreme poverty. People who don't know if they're going to survive the next week or month. In the developing world, $1.90 per day provides just enough security that you're pretty sure you won't starve next week. It's pretty damn bleak, but the fact is that a lot of people live in conditions where they know they may starve in the near future, and if fewer people live in those conditions, that's important.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- shalmanese 11y agoThe reason why it's $1.90 is because extreme poverty was pegged at a dollar per day by the World Bank in 1993 which has risen due to inflation to $1.90. There's nothing magical about the number, it simply provides a convenient baseline for comparisons to be made.
- aaron695 11y agoYou'll have to google it for the different sides to the story and opinions on whether it should have been raised to $1.90, but here's a start - http://blogs.worldbank.org/developmenttalk/international-poverty-line-has-just-been-raised-190-day-global-poverty-basically-unchanged-how-even http://blogs.worldbank.org/developmenttalk/international-pov... PS You need to do the shopping, or learn to cook, $1.90 is very easy to feed people. But obviously it also about other things like food security and important stuff like happiness.
- 11y ago
- tim333 11y agoGood stuff. I was brought up with images Africans starving on the TV and Live Aid. Horrible stuff. Glad to see progress.
- littletimmy 11y agoReally? Because I don't think I've read hunter-gatherers being exceptionally poor.
- PeerGunthard 11y agoA good example why people are leaving hackernews ...
- ForHackernews 11y agoBecause they're now wealthy enough to afford better sites?
- coderdude 11y agoWith pay walls to keep out the riff-raff.
- roflchoppa 11y agothx bill gates u did it.
- ciscoheat 11y agoAhem, money == interest-bearing debt created in a computer by private, non-democratic institutions for maximum profit, in case someone missed that little glitch in the system.
- pierotofy 11y agoThat would be currency, not money.
- ZenoArrow 11y agoI've heard people making this distinction before, but can't say I understand the difference, can you explain it to me?
- ciscoheat 11y agoAs I said, banks are creating money, digital debt credits, in their computers. That money is largely regarded as equal to currency in the prevailing global financial system, since everyone uses the banks transaction system (SWIFT, Visa, etc) and trusts the value of the debt credits. The real currency are the notes and coins, the "legal tender" printed by the government, which comprises less than 3% of the money supply.
- ciscoheat 11y agoI used the equality operator, not identity. I explained below, please inform yourself.
- antman 11y agoHow come nobody has ever heard the term "extreme poverty" as a sensible metric before? Even forgetting the fact that defining extreme poverty as an absolute number is completely meaningless, they had to change the metric numerous times to show a positive result. http://www.aljazeera.com/indepth/opinion/2014/08/exposing-great-poverty-reductio-201481211590729809.html http://www.aljazeera.com/indepth/opinion/2014/08/exposing-gr... Also a country is awarded money if it displays good metrics even if they don't make any sense. https://books.google.gr/books?id=rH5UCAAAQBAJ&pg=PT178&lpg=PT178&dq=world+bank+financing+stopped+after&source=bl&ots=0dpWPwlG7T&sig=uUUqm1zDzxd_0B6ZKF_q39_IyBE&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0ahUKEwjNmNnRgeDJAhUFCBoKHXV-BocQ6AEIOTAF#v=onepage&q=world%20bank%20financing%20stopped%20after&f=false https://books.google.gr/books?id=rH5UCAAAQBAJ&pg=PT178&lpg=P...
- DHJSH 11y agoWe did it, reddit!