4 ms·
I originally wanted to reply to a reply to your comment, but it was deleted. The reply said that he disagrees with your logic, as we as society decided that ca
by kuschku 11y ago
I originally wanted to reply to a reply to your comment, but it was deleted.
The reply said that he disagrees with your logic, as we as society decided that capital accumulation is productivity.
My comment to that was:
> > We have defined productivity with capital accumulation in society.
> We have not.
> People get capital for being lucky, and from privileged backgrounds. Zuckerberg is not an exception, nor are most of us here on HN.
> You don’t get rich because you are doing the best work. In fact, the most productive researchers usually end up on minimal grants having to save money, and never actually make much money themselves.
> The money ends up with the people who have luck, connections, are at the right place at the right time.
> This is why society has decided to publicly fund research based on productivity with tax money, as obviously the free market is unable to do so.
> The free market isn’t funding Wendelstein 7-X, nor the LHC. The free market isn’t funding the E-ELT. The free market isn’t giving any of the involved researchers billions.
> The people who invented the computer died poor, but a person who just happened to do what MySpace did before, at the right place, right time, happened to become billionaire.
> No, capital accumulation is not even correlated to productivity.