6 ms·
UN wrongly linked global warming to natural disasters
- tome 17y agoIt looks like the credibility of the IPCC is diminishing by the day. I hope some trustworthy body which is concerned about climate change but strong enough to avoid the kind of bias and shoddy lack of rigour we've seen from the IPCC can come through to take its place.
- gruseom 17y agoPolitically speaking, it won't happen. Global warming is inextricably bound up with the IPCC in people's minds. So much effort was expended on telling everyone that they had to believe the IPCC because it was a consensus of all the scientists in the world (what, you think you're smarter than all the scientists in the world?) that to come along now with "Did we say that consensus? We meant this consensus" can't possibly work. I meant to post this the last time the subject came up, just for the record: it's beginning to look like the IPCC (and with it, perhaps, the entire issue) has hit its peak.
- yummyfajitas 17y agoMy favorite parts of the article: The 2007 study should be seen as a snapshot of what was known then. Science is progressive. If something turns out to be wrong we can fix it next time around. In this case, it turns out the mistakes were fixed the first time around: before the paper was published. A hint: in general, when writing a review article, you don't both to write about stuff that isn't finished. At most, you give it a brief mention in a section "future directions and open problems". You discuss it with superlatives like, "this looks promising". You don't, however, pass it off as part of what is known.
- anamax 17y agoThe 2007 study should be seen as a snapshot of what was known then. We now know that "snapshot" wasn't the intent because the "no glaciers in 2025" claim was included even though they knew that it was wrong because they wanted to influence the politics. http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1245636/Glacier-scientists-says-knew-data-verified.html http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1245636/Glacier-scie... FWIW, while they're trying to distance themselves from the claim, they've kept the immediate author on-payroll. Are they buying him off or protecting their own?
- cwan 17y agoThis looks even worse for Pachauri, the chairman of the IPCC: - The scientist that made the glacier claim now works for Pachauri - http://www.telegraph.co.uk/comment/columnists/christopherbooker/7062667/Pachauri-the-real-story-behind-the-Glaciergate-scandal.html http://www.telegraph.co.uk/comment/columnists/christopherboo... - A possible motive? "Pachauri ... may have raised millions of dollars for his New Delhi institute on the basis of the totally bogus ‘glaciergate’ claim by the IPCC that the Himalayan glaciers would melt by 2035" http://blogs.the-american-interest.com/wrm/2010/01/23/ipcc-head-in-glaciergate-crime/ http://blogs.the-american-interest.com/wrm/2010/01/23/ipcc-h... (Walter Russell Mead)
- anamax 17y agoEven if the claim wasn't bogus, we have yet another example of a supposedly objective scientist/official personally benefiting from pushing AGW. And yet, most of what we hear is that the "deniers" are in it for the money because some of them used to work for the petroleum industry.
- BearOfNH 17y agoScience is progressive. If something turns out to be wrong we can fix it next time around. Good science. But it's kind of difficult to undo mis-spending of taxpayer dollars, not to mention the economic damage caused by policies based on such mistakes.
- lutorm 17y agoI seem to disagree with you about much on this issue, but here I'm with you: They should just say: "Yeah, we f.ed up." instead of trying to spin it.
- chasingsparks 17y agoIf they'd cover it on TV news, it's probably off-topic. I feel like there have been an increasing number of posts like this: posts that straddle relevance. I find the topic of climate change and the associated politics interesting. However, this type of story comes up in my political and more mundane newsreader. (I don't mean that to sound snotty, but I believe many readers are like me in that regard.) I come to HN for very interesting stories that get pushed by a community composed of smart people. They propagate good stories that either are breaking news or could have been missed. I don't think this story qualifies...but I am not sure how to properly disqualify it. However, I think PG's TV news rule is a very good acid test.
- dschobel 17y agoI think a lot of the worth of HN is in the analysis by the intelligent people who roam these virtual halls so even if the story is mundane I often learn a lot from the people who follow climate science and politics much more closely than I. I do agree that the 2nd or 3rd story on <highly regarded panel cooks the climate data> has diminishing returns but I don't think a mundane/popular media story should be grounds for disqualification a priori for the afore mentioned reason.
- chasingsparks 17y agoI agree with your first statement. In fact, the conversations -- especially the arguments -- may exceed the value of the stories themselves. They often do for me. However, the topic of climate change seems to be a lightning rod for bad arguments. Ones that devolve into comment trees that provide good examples of bad arguments that PG can use in a follow up to "How to Disagree." Good arguments on climate change have occurred on this site. There has been a lot of good debates over the limits of science in the face of complexity, the politicization of science, etc. However, as you put it, there are diminishing returns on this story. The good arguments have been exhausted, and now it is becoming a political gotcha style story. Again, I don't know why I was bothered by this post, but it may be because it was the third or fourth thread on this topic, just with a new small piece of information. (P.S. I do not mean to sound like the arbiter of "Good Arguments.")
- nfnaaron 17y ago"Some researchers have argued that it is unfair to attack the IPCC too strongly, pointing out that some errors are inevitable in a report as long and technical as the IPCC's round-up of climate science." Yeah, especially if you willfully ignore them when they're known, in favor of a position. I'm getting the sense that advocacy is playing too high a role in both the science and the policy of climate change. Indeed, advocacy seems to have coupled science and policy into one large system. I'm also wondering if "climate change" shouldn't even be a phrase in common usage, at least not the way we use it to refer to an accepted direction in policy and earth science.
- barrkel 17y agoThe problem is that there are concentrated vested interests in disputing and denying the evidence. It's in this kind of environment that pro climate change advocacy formed, to counteract self-interested lobbies. There isn't a simple solution here. When profit-making corporations have unlimited free political speech, how does science make itself heard, without also seeming to turn into political advocacy?
- tome 17y agoThis is a problem. Indeed "politics has no place in science", but if politics does have a place in business (and it does whether we like it or not) then how are important scientific challenges to entrenched businesses to be approached?
- fauigerzigerk 17y agoI think the notion that profit-making corporations with vested interests are to be found on only one side of this debate is completely false. Companies such as GE, Siemens, the renewables industries and essentially all industries that are users of energy as opposed to producers of energy from fossile fuels have a massive vested interest in driving the current climate panic forward. Even auto makers, who have indeed been lobbying against far reaching regulation, are in a double bind situation. I cannot imagine a greater opportunity for them to make loads of money than governments forcing people to buy expensive electric vehicles and subsidising them massively. Last (and probably even least) there are the climate scientists themselves whose funding and career prospects depend heavily on politics and advocacy.
- brc 17y agoThe issue here is that the IPCC has wielded the 'peer reviewed' phrase like a hammer, and repeatedly knocked anyone on the head with it if they presented something that wasn't peer reviewed. There are many, many quotes from the IPCC brushing off conflicting information with 'it's not peer reviewed, like all of our science'. Now that they've been found to not apply their own standards, others are using that same hammer to hit back with. Even if it's only one or two instances, the damage is done. Now that one error involving a non-peer reviewed (so called 'grey' reference) has been found, people are crawling all over the rest of their reports, finding other instances. The WWF report from 2005 that contained the himalayan glacier melt story is still cited throughout the report - they just removed the offending factoid about 2035. Until they comprehensively go back and apply their own standards more rigourously, they are going to attract more and more scrutiny, more errors will be found (the sheer length of the report almost guarantees that). And their current position of 'it's only one error' is going to look bad. If they are to be effective, there's going to need to be some serious changes put in place. People's support for the IPCC-backed science and policies in Western countries is eroding (if you believe the polls) and while not yet under the 50% mark, it's not in the direction the IPCC wants. Until they make some changes, I don't see their support rising again.
- teeja 17y agoSo what? People do bad science, bad business, bad education all the time, because of unconscious biases, because of pressures to 'succeed', publish, etc. How many people are 'playing the game' in this old world? Not to excuse exaggerations: but just because some people get overzealous, that doesn't change the facts ... e.g. that glaciers worldwide are shrinking, the oceans are becoming more acidic. Many GW deniers are also guilty of being blind in one eye.