5 ms·
Wow, what a sprawling article. At first it seems to just focus on how the popular physics class explanation of why the bridge collapsed was wrong...which is mil
by danso 11y ago
Wow, what a sprawling article. At first it seems to just focus on how the popular physics class explanation of why the bridge collapsed was wrong...which is mildly interesting but I was hoping from the title that we'd get an indepth look at the engineering processes behind the bridge -- as I remember hearing far more about the bridge in my engineering classes than in physics. But the OP delivers some about the engineering, though I'm largely ignorant of the details about the Tacoma Narrows Bridge (based on the film footage, I had assumed it had happened in the 60s, because I didn't think color footage would have been easy to take in the early 40s).
I liked this detail a third-way through:
> To be fair to Moisseiff and his engineers, the phenomenon of aerodynamic instability wasn't well understood at the time. But it wasn't completely unknown either. The last collapse of a suspension bridge due to its reaction to the wind occurred five decades earlier, when the Niagara-Clifton Bridge fell in 1889. (The heavyset design of the Brooklyn Bridge, which opened five years earlier, in 1883, was meant to withstand the sorts of forces that had affected suspension bridges in previous decades.)
> Just four months after Galloping Gertie collapsed, a professor of civil engineering at Columbia University, J. K. Finch, summarized suspension bridge failures in an article in Engineering News Record. "These long-forgotten difficulties with early suspension bridges, clearly show that while to modern engineers, the gyrations of the Tacoma bridge constituted something entirely new and strange, they were not new—they had simply been forgotten."
The most recent example of a similar failure was 50 years earlier. No doubt the information would propagate to some degree through engineering libraries...but given how much we today forget about engineering failures and case studies (in the software engineering context, some would argue that the memory hole cycle seems to be about 6 months long) despite vastly improved information pipelines, I've always wondered how difficult it was to learn and maintain best practices in the engineering disciplines before the past few decades.
- CWuestefeld 11y agoWow, what a sprawling article. At first it seems Yes. I HATE reporting like this. I've got things to do with my life. I'd much rather they just get on with the information. If they feel there's some human interest necessary to understand the point, at least give me a summary up front, so I can decide if it's going to be interesting and worth the investment of time.
- AnimalMuppet 11y agoThere was a time when this was the way to write, to give depth to your readers. The New Yorker is a classic example of this writing style. It's for people who want to read, and have time to do it. Maybe 150 years ago, people had more time than they had material to read, so this style was perfect. But now there's so much more to read then there is time to read it in, and this style is a royal pain. Times have changed, and (some) writers haven't noticed. They're still writing like we have more time than we have stuff to read.
- hguant 11y agoBuzzfeed called; they've got a list for you. In all seriousness, this type of writing - sprawling as you call it - is important. It lets the reader come away with a sense of the nuances of the situation, instead of a bullet point abstract that leads to misunderstandings and overlooked issues. This type of writing - commonly called "the essay" - is important precisely because it does take time to read it. Its meant to teach you something, not just give you a little factoid you can regurgitate throughout the day.
- ghaff 11y agoYes, you're very important and don't have time to read long articles. If you don't want to read long-form writing, then don't do so but don't complain about it being available to people who like it. I rather like the New Yorker.
- AnimalMuppet 11y agoIt's not that "I'm very important". It's not even that I don't have time to read a long article. I don't have time to read nearly as many long articles as there are out there, though. And to me, it feels like the shoe's on the other foot. To me, a long form article is the author deciding that he/she's so important (or the content is) that I will find it worth the time to read the whole thing, and that it's therefore fine to hide the main point somewhere in the length, because I'll get the point so much better if I go through all the rest of it as well. That's fine for those who like that kind of thing, but, well, let's just say that it's unattractive to more and more readers as we have more and more things that we want to read. For it to be worth my while, this article has to be worth more than whatever I didn't have time to read because I took the time to read this one. The longer the article is, the higher that bar is, because the more I could have read with the same time.
- OldSchoolJohnny 11y agoWhen you get paid by the word....