11 ms·
I wouldn't describe 3rd parties as "ripping off the design and protocol" when bulb <-> hub communication is done using the ZigBee Light Link protocol. Philips d
by wlesieutre 11y ago
I wouldn't describe 3rd parties as "ripping off the design and protocol" when bulb <-> hub communication is done using the ZigBee Light Link protocol. Philips didn't develop that.
Standard here: http://www.zigbee.org/?wpdmdl=2132 http://www.zigbee.org/?wpdmdl=2132 [pdf warning]
And no, lights from other manufacturers (I have several from GE) no longer work via the Hue app or any of the 3rd party alternatives. I made the mistake of accepting Hue's "update your bridge" prompt already, not realizing it would break them. Until I saw this headline I assumed it was a matter of unpair/repair to get the working again, but it looks like no luck. They're no longer in my list of paired bulbs, and (I'll try when I get home) it doesn't sound like they can be paired anymore.
For an example of the now-useless bulbs I have: http://www.homedepot.com/p/GE-Link-60W-Equivalent-Soft-White-2700K-A19-Connected-Home-LED-Light-Bulb-PSB19-SW27/205404345 http://www.homedepot.com/p/GE-Link-60W-Equivalent-Soft-White...
GE isn't even selling these saying "get our cheaper bulbs and use them with Hue," they're marketed as being compatible with the Wink hub. But since it all works over the same open standard, you can use them on whichever base you like.
This is like Apple saying "Laptops from other brands are no longer supported on Airport wireless networks so that we can ensure devices are fully compatible." It's a huge dick move on Philips's part.
- TeMPOraL 11y ago> This is like Apple saying "Laptops from other brands are no longer supported on Airport wireless networks so that we can ensure devices are fully compatible." Didn't Apple do that with Bluetooth once? I recall reading that at least one iteration of iPhones could not send files via Bluetooth to non-Apple devices.
- TD-Linux 11y agoThey still do it. For some Bluetooth device classes, you must get your device signed by Apple and use certain chips. One product I worked on had a dual Bluetooth and BLE stack - Bluetooth for Android, and BLE to circumvent the Apple limitations (BLE devices don't need to be signed).
- odbol 11y agoiPhones can't even send files to other iPhones or Mac or anything over Bluetooth. In fact iPhone doesn't even HAVE files. It's 2015 and still the only way to share files from your iPhone is to plug it in.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- daveguy 11y ago"This is like Apple saying "Laptops from other brands are no longer supported on Airport wireless networks so that we can ensure devices are fully compatible." It's a huge dick move on Philips's part." And in their faq about this (http://www.developers.meethue.com/documentation/friends-hue-update http://www.developers.meethue.com/documentation/friends-hue-...) they have the nerve to say things like: "If the lights are not deleted, nor the bridge reset they will continue to function under no guarantees from Philips that future updates may not expose new bugs and compatibility issues." and "We want Philips Hue to be open but also offer a great experience for our customers. To that end, last week, we launched the 'Friends of Hue' program where we will certify and test 3rd party products to guarantee a consistent and long term interoperable experience also for these products." AKA We want third party manufacturers to pay for a sticker to use our product because we have market dominance. and "These changes do not affect Philips commitment towards an open system and ZigBee Light Link as the best standard for residential lighting control. Our lights continue to be fully standards compatible with differentiated features built on top of the standard and exposed via our bridge." AKA Embrace, extend, extinguish.