5 ms·
As a rock climber I see this entire 'ropes breaking' discussion very odd. Ropes carrying people shouldn't break. Full stop. There shouldn't be any sharp edge
by sandworm101 11y ago
As a rock climber I see this entire 'ropes breaking' discussion very odd. Ropes carrying people shouldn't break. Full stop. There shouldn't be any sharp edges. Weight, even impact forces, shouldn't come anywhere near thinking about breaks. A rope should never be able to slip off a pulley. If it can, then the pulley needs to be redesigned. If it has any sharp edge then it is not to be trusted. Look at the equipment in at any climbing store. You won't find anything even remotely sharp.
Climbing ropes (rock climbing, not mountaineering) basically do not break. An entire system of standards mean that no matter how one falls, no matter the angle and accidental nature, the rope is expected to survive. To see actors hung off systems with sharp-edged pulleys and unconstrained rope movements with little regards for accidental or unexpected forces terrifies me.
- jacquesm 11y agoI was hoping for a mountaineer to speak up. Thank you for this comment. I have zero knowledge of mountaineering other than that I used some mountaineering gear to do roofing work and the whole 'sharp edge' and 'rope jumped pulley' thing as well as the fact that there is no automatic shut-off should a line get caught (they hint in the article that the winches would keep running if a line gets caught) is troubling to me. The problem with such thinking is that it leads you to go 'why don't they' and that's not a very productive path for a lay-person in the field. OHSA presumably has been over this with a microscope and it is strange that none of those issues deserved a mention. Personally - if I were inclined to put my life at stake in a circus - I would have wanted to know exactly how all of this gear that my body is suspended from is working and how it is rated (and if such information would not be shared then I'd leave). It's got to be pretty safe though because with all the cycles it has gone through there have not been more accidents.
- sandworm101 11y agoOHSA should, but they are not experts in the field. Nobody is. Circus is a constantly evolving practice. Everything is new. EveryONE is new. The stages are all temp installs. And there are only ever a couple hundred people in the country doing this sort of act at any one time. There are some old hats, but there isn;t that large community needed to establish was are and aren't statistically safe practices. OSHA does well with factories where thousands of people perform the same actions thousands of time. They do not do well with one-off jobs. Imagine being an OHSA inspector, an expert in fall arrest, and walking into a scene where an acrobat was hanging by a single wire rope (no backup device or soft spot) over a tank of water, in total darkness, while on fire ... and the tank is full of live killer whales. And the whole rig was build last month and will probably be torn down in a couple months. Such a scenario isn't much of an exaggeration.
- jacquesm 11y agoThat's an excellent point, yes, the temporary nature of the circus business changes everything. Even so 'sharp edges' and 'rope' in close proximity give me the willies.
- js2 11y agoAnother point that surprised me was the reference to the Cirque performers desiring an adrenaline rush, which seems at odds with safety. I've read of rock climbers saying that everything should be calm when they are climbing and that if there's ever an adreniline rush, it means something has gone wrong.
- sandworm101 11y agoYa, um, well, that is the sort of thing climbers say when cameras are around, like a baseball pitcher remaining calm as he throws a perfect game. Adrenaline is always part of climbing.