4 ms·
The last time I saw the topic of drones and aircraft collisions on the front page (maybe a week ago), the entire comment thread was filled with people downplayi
by mikeash 11y ago
The last time I saw the topic of drones and aircraft collisions on the front page (maybe a week ago), the entire comment thread was filled with people downplaying the dangers, casting doubt on whether it even mattered, saying a three-pound (!) drone wouldn't do any actual damage on impact, etc.
I find the community attitude here to be completely insane. Regulation isn't necessarily the answer, but the general theme here seems to be "regulation isn't the answer, because there's no risk of collision, and a small aircraft colliding with a 3lb drone at 150MPH won't suffer any damage anyway."
- kayfox 11y agoI don't think the dangers need to be downplayed. The incidence does need to be looked at. I think we blame drones for all sorts of things that are not drones these days.
- bdamm 11y agoThere are already many cases on the books of drones flying into approach paths of airliners in many airports, including several into JFK. Just last week there was a case of a police helicopter that had a very close call with a drone (the helicopter pilot did execute collision avoidance, and police on the ground tracked the drone operator.) Incidence is there and rising.
- mizchief2 11y agoSo what difference would registration make in that case? I have no problem with prosecuting people who do stupid and dangerous things with drones, but making everyone who buys a toy to fly on their own property under 100ft is over reaching and treats everyone like a criminal.
- mikeash 11y agoWhat do drones get blamed for that aren't drones, exactly?
- ubernostrum 11y agoRegulation isn't necessarily the answer, but the general theme here seems to be "regulation isn't the answer, because there's no risk of collision, and a small aircraft colliding with a 3lb drone at 150MPH won't suffer any damage anyway." This being HN, more likely it's "all regulation is morally evil".
- mikeash 11y agoIt goes beyond that, there seems to be a need to show that the purported problem doesn't even exist, not just that regulation would be wrong.
- ubernostrum 11y agoHand-in-hand, culturally: if there is a problem, it means an unregulated market didn't solve the problem. Since by definition unregulated markets can't have unsolved problems, the problem must exist and protecting the dogma requires demonstrating that the problem is a lie made up by sensationalist media.