51 ms·
What surprises me is is the minimum weight requirement: 250 grams. That's well below a weight that could reasonably be considered a danger to aircraft or people
by Someone1234 11y ago
What surprises me is is the minimum weight requirement: 250 grams. That's well below a weight that could reasonably be considered a danger to aircraft or people.
Just for comparison purposes, a McDonald's Big Mac weighs 215-240 grams without wrapper, so with a wrapper if you turned a Big Mac into a drone, it would likely require registration.
The real question is, what is their endgame here? Just send out notifications? It isn't like drones have transponders yet(?).
I like the FAA but this seems misguided and unworkable. Plus $5 is significant when some drones this impacts only costs $30.
Hopefully the FAA has birds 250+ grams register too, just for consistency. In particular as birds kill an order of magnitude more pilots than drones have (have drones ever taken down a plane?).
- pricechild 11y agoA burger wrapper caught on a real helicopter's rotor can induce scary vibrations & some loss of lift. Keep the burger & wrapper please.
- 33W 11y agoTime to register burger wrappers! </s>
- andys627 11y ago250g is large enough to do damage
- loeber 11y agoSuppose a 250g drone fails mid-air, hypothetically at a height of 100m, and falls freely. At terminal velocity, it's a lethal projectile. Have no illusions about the damage that can be done by small things falling from a great height, or travelling at a high speed in general. The 250g weight is entirely reasonable -- I would actually claim that it is quite generous.
- smackfu 11y agoHeh, they actually do that calculation in the task force report, from the max allowed height.
- nqzero 11y agoguess we should start regulating rocks that weigh more than 250g too then ...
- tomswartz07 11y agoOnly if you're flying rocks at over 328 feet in the air.
- afarrell 11y agoI'm pretty sure that regularly throwing half-pound rocks high in the air is already regulated.
- jnbiche 11y agoPerhaps in some urban areas, but I seriously doubt there are federal regulations about throwing rock projectiles into the air with no intent to hit or harm a person.
- bdamm 11y agoFAA says that pilots may drop objects from airplanes, but puts the onus on the pilot to ensure "no hazard is created". And, once the object touches the ground, it becomes subject to local laws. So dropping a rock onto someone's property could be quite a few violations depending on the outcome and the property.
- jnbiche 11y agoThe question was concerning throwing rocks "up into the air", not throwing projectiles from an airplane. If it involves airplanes, you can rest assured that the FAA will regulate it, so no surprise there.
- Someone1234 11y agoTechnically we already do, but indirectly. In order to get a 250g rock up high enough to reach it's terminal velocity before hitting the earth again, you'd need some kind of launcher (e.g. catapult, trebuchet, Slingshot, etc) which are regulated. For example, New York made Slingshot a Class-4 misdemeanor.
- Lawtonfogle 11y ago>At terminal velocity, it's a lethal projectile. So is a bullet. Guess we should require all bullets to be registered.
- DennisP 11y agoTerminal velocity of a 250g aircraft is much slower than terminal velocity of a 250g rock.
- sokoloff 11y agoA 250g helicopter with stopped rotors isn't that different from a rock.
- Bjartr 11y agoDepends on whether or not the rotors autorotate.
- jacquesm 11y agoEven if they don't they might cause the body to rotate.
- thescriptkiddie 11y agoEven in the worst case of a quadrotor - which can't glide or autorotate or fly with a missing rotor - a 250g one is not going to become a lethal projectile at terminal velocity. Even the heavy batteries from larger multirotors seem to survive a 100m fall uneventfully, they just make a soft thud when they land. A softball weighs something like 200g and getting hit in the head with one of those at 85 mph doesn't kill you.
- bigiain 11y agoSuppose a skateboard or bicycle falls freely, hypothetically, from the top of Lombard St... Do we now require registration and quarter million dollar fines for all bicycles and skateboards that weigh more than 250g?
- omni 11y agoI was under the impression that pretty much anything getting sucked into a jet turbine is a major problem, can anyone speak to whether that's true? Birds don't weigh a lot either, but run into one and you could have a major problem on your hands.
- hooo 11y agoNo, that's not true at all. Jet engines can typically handle many birds. The AA flight that landed in the Hudson was unique in that it went through a large flock of Canadian geese, which are very large birds. I sat next to a naval pilot on a plane once and he wasn't scared of drones at all. The jet engine would tear it right up.
- code4tee 11y agoBirds aren't packed full of lithium ion batteries...
- ksherlock 11y agoIt doesn't surprise me that military pilots aren't afraid of drones. They're not even afraid of flying into a 1000 pound airplane. Maybe if his plane didn't have an ejection seat... http://www.theatlantic.com/national/archive/2015/07/an-air-force-veteran-disagrees-about-the-f-16-cessna-crash/399437/ http://www.theatlantic.com/national/archive/2015/07/an-air-f...
- Someone1234 11y ago> I was under the impression that pretty much anything getting sucked into a jet turbine is a major problem, can anyone speak to whether that's true? Definitely untrue. Air, water, and particulates get sucked in all of the time, it doesn't cause a "major problem." It really boils down to mass and in some cases chemical makeup. Smaller birds get sucked in all the time, and often don't even damage the fan blades. Whereas a couple of Canadian Geese could clog up an engine causing it to stop. While the news likes to drum beat about large commercial aircraft, it is "unlikely" that a drone could be a real threat. It is more smaller single engine aircraft and helicopters that are at risk from drones flying into them (in particular during take-off/landing). Larger drones definitely need some kind of moderation. But as I said above 250g is too small, a pigeon weighs over 350g by comparison. How are you going to regulate them?! PS - I actually fully support regulating pigeons, those things need to be taken down a peg or two.
- smackfu 11y agoHere's what the industry task force that came up with the suggested registration requirements said in their report: The Task Force spent considerable time discussing and deliberating about what the appropriate weight threshold should be. While general agreement was ultimately reached on the 250 gram weight, there were Task Force members who believed it was too conservative, as the weight could negatively impact the credibility of the sUAS registration program and thus lessen compliance levels because it would require registration of somes UAS generally considered to be in the “toy” category. Others took the opposite view that there should be no registration exemption for UAS of any size. https://www.faa.gov/uas/publications/media/RTFARCFinalReport_11-21-15.pdf https://www.faa.gov/uas/publications/media/RTFARCFinalReport...
- revelation 11y agoNobody cares what color of a bunch of bureaucrats want to paint the bike shed, this needs to be an evidence-guided process not a wank.
- smackfu 11y agoIf you look at the PDF, there is a surprising amount of calculations on how dangerous a 250 g drone could be.
- strgrd 11y agoI imagine there will be a new interest in the sub-250 gram FPV community. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2sZ-N8YiTs4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2sZ-N8YiTs4 And a new interest in dye cut stickers...
- Bedon292 11y agoI think you are on to something there. I think there will be a whole market around ~240g FPV quads. I want to try and do it now too.
- god_bless_texas 11y agoA half pound is enough to damage something when you're going 150 mph. I have seen bird strikes that were in that weight range and blew out a windshield. I imagine the FAA is going to find out how many people in the United States are unable and unwilling to put up with their more onerous requirements. I think it will begin a real conversation through Congress about whether or not "The FAA has jurisdiction on everything above the surface of the earth". The reason they won't implement rules about flying indoors is not because they are nice guys, but because they cannot have a legislative opinion written that supports this as an area they can control.
- Lawtonfogle 11y ago>I have seen bird strikes that were in that weight range and blew out a windshield. Anyone who owns birds or places bird feeders or bird baths must register.
- god_bless_texas 11y agoDon't give them any ideas!
- paulddraper 11y agoAnd pay $5 per bird.
- bigiain 11y agoAnd yet people are perfectly happy to assume the risk of birdstrike without grounding every aircraft or needing to regulate or sue birds and bird owners. Why the hysteria about drones? Does anybody _really_ think xmas drones are going to outnumber birds? What's the real marginal increase in risk for aviation here? Or is this just a case of "Someone seems to be having fun doing something I don't care for, so I'll invent risk scenarios to justify stopping them from doing it... Because reasons..."?
- god_bless_texas 11y agoIf the FAA could write a FAR that kept birds out of the airspace, it would happen.
- peter303 11y agoForce is porportional is the square of velocity. The standard must anticipate FAST drones, not just their weight.
- bdamm 11y agoOr fast airplanes. Most FAA speed limits where drones are going to be top out at about 200knots, so that's pretty quick.
- paulddraper 11y agoAirplanes have far higher top speeds then drones. Drones are basically birds when it comes down to this.
- soylentcola 11y agoGuess I need to go weigh my cheap little toy quad. Pretty sure it's lighter than that but I'd rather not deal with any fines if somehow I'm playing around with it in the park and the quad-cops get a complaint. Either that or I may just stop flying it and wait until I eventually (someday, dammit!) get around to building that little 250 racer I keep price-shopping parts for.
- asift 11y ago>What surprises me is is the minimum weight requirement: 250 grams Why does this surprise you? If the assumption is that the FAA is altruistic organization that seeks nothing but the public benefit, I suppose I can see how this is surprising. But if we take a more realistic assumption of what the FAA is--a governmental bureaucracy full of self-interested individuals who pursue their own interests (greater authority, promotions, increased budgets, increased compensation, etc.)--it's not very surprising that they reach beyond "reasonable" restrictions and seek additional ways to benefit themselves. Also, governmental regulators have strong incentives to be incredibly risk averse. This is best exemplified by the FDA. If they approve a drug that turns out to have an unknown side effect that harms people, this result is easy to observe and likely carries significant consequences for the FDA employees involved. However, if their delay in approving a drug causes 100,000 unnecessary deaths, this result is difficult to observe and likely carries no consequences. This creates perverse incentives that push regulators towards being excessively cautious.
- pc86 11y agoSerious question: what is the incentive for the FAA to create regulations for the sake of creating them (or to creating overly conservative ones to the point of impacting industry)? I could understand a new or very small regulatory body, but the FAA isn't going anywhere.
- ctdonath 11y agoNew branch, new area of regulation, more personnel & resources needed to administrate & investigate ... typical self-serving bureaucracy growth incentives. Like with firearms, the governing agency is tasked with regulating anything that can, by any stretch of the imagination, be construed as risky.
- falcolas 11y agoThe FAA did not come up with that number. Drone makers and other such organizations did.
- panglott 11y agoYep. Also, most of the cheap quadcopters don't list their weight, although the cheapest nano quadcopters will be well below the limit. This one is less than 12 g: http://www.gizmag.com/review-estes-proto-x-nano-quadcopter/29813/ http://www.gizmag.com/review-estes-proto-x-nano-quadcopter/2... A half-pound is not very big. Edited to note that the FAA FAQ has a PDF about most items in the toy category; they say that most devices under $100 are under the weight limit. https://www.faa.gov/uas/registration/faqs/media/UAS_Weights_Registration.pdf https://www.faa.gov/uas/registration/faqs/media/UAS_Weights_... However, all drones with cameras that it lists do require registration.