6 ms·
> Terrorists attack unarmed civilians. One of the most striking stories my grandmother always told about WWII (she was born in '34) was how, when she walked to
by kuschku 11y ago
> Terrorists attack unarmed civilians.
One of the most striking stories my grandmother always told about WWII (she was born in '34) was how, when she walked to school, very often US fighters shot at the children walking there. There was no way this was a mistake – they were still children, the road only led to the school, no one else was walking there at the time. And still, every few days fighters shot at them, and they had to jump in a drainage canal, or similar to hide.
Seeing your friends from school being shot by fighters in front of your eyes can hurt a child a lot.
Many old people here still hold a grudge towards the allies, despite all the amazing things they did after the war to rebuild.
But if attacking civilians is the measure, then the US is a terrorist state. And has been for decades.
----------------
EDIT: I’m not saying the US is bad, or good, I’m trying to say there is no "good" side in a war. No one in a war is innocent.
There is a side that gasses jews, and a side that nukes civilians. There is a side that bombs hospitals, and a side that blows themselves up at a concert in Paris. There’s a side that massacres disabled people, and a side that shoots children.
We can’t compare, or even weigh up the sides against each other, and doing so would miss the point. But we can’t say "only terrorists kill civilians".
- jules 11y agoDo you have a public source for that?
- kuschku 11y agoSadly, no. My grandmother never published it, because it was nothing special – most people from that time had similar stories. And, as she died in 2000, the possibility to publish anything is long over, too. You can surely find many similar statements from old people from the war, though.
- Aqueous 11y agoIf true, those soldiers were criminals and terrorists and they were acting against orders, at least the orders of the high command. The US has accidentally killed plenty of civilians, of course. In the past (in World War II, for instance) they've also killed civilians deliberately. I'm not arguing that the US's hands are clean. But the US also recognizes (now, at least) that it is extremely counter-productive to kill civilians. That's why they order soldiers not to and why it is officially against the law of the United States as well as international law, and a war crime, to target civilians. It is not part of the official US strategy to target civilians - in fact it is part of the official US strategy to not target civilians. On the other hand, it is part of the official, stated strategy of ISIS, Al Qaeda, Al Shabaab, Boko Haram, and other terrorist organizations, to intentionally murder civilians in the most visible way possible. *Edited to acknowledge current reality vs our past
- opinali 11y agoWe also accidentally dropped two nukes in Japan, and accidentally made Napalm and Agent Orange rain into the Vietnamese, with enormously high and vastly-civilian casualties in both cases. And these are just easy cases where direct responsibility can be tracked all way up to the commander-in-chief, so please no BS about no official strategy. And then of course, the military chain of command is exceedingly good at diluting responsibility -- generals will demand results implying but not writing down how far commanders can go; soldiers and commanders will cross many lines which no colleagues will report() and no immediate superiors will punish; the press will be strictly managed to not see anything that "national security" doesn't need us to see so our own civilian population will be morally appeased that we're being righteous, everyone is happy. () A few will do, and then they're jailed for life as traitors.
- masklinn 11y ago> We also accidentally dropped two nukes in Japan, and accidentally made Napalm and Agent Orange rain into the Vietnamese, with enormously high and vastly-civilian casualties in both cases. Don't forget the extensive firebombings of numerous cities including Dresden or Tokyo (casualties estimates for the latter are in the same 100000~200000 range as the two nuclear strikes combined)
- kuschku 11y agoWhich has still issues today – every few weeks whole districts in German cities are evacuated, because they found another WWII bomb with chemical timer that hasn’t exploded yet.
- Aqueous 11y agoYep, and in more recent years, we've lead the way in nuclear disarmament. We haven't firebombed entire cities in decades . In the past 8 years we've (to my great relief) de-escalated our military actions in both Afghanistan and Iraq. Our military leaders take pains to make sure drone attacks and military incursions are as precise as possible. We've done this because we've recognized, unlike terrorists, that civilian deaths are extremely unhelpful to our foreign policy. Again I'm not saying the US's hands are clean. I wholly disagree with many of the foreign military actions we've taken - especially between 2000 and 2008. What am I saying is that our policy - along with international law - have evolved considerably in the past 60 years. And I also sincerely believe that most of our armed forces in present day are doing their very best to avoid killing civilians. I also think a lot of this is hand-waving away of the critical differences between terrorists who think it is acceptable to walk into a concert hall and gun down hundreds of people, and the militaries who are fighting those terrorists. Nothing is simple, but there are meaningful moral differences here.
- johnchristopher 11y agoOut of curiosity: Is your grand mother from the Netherlands ?
- kuschku 11y agoSadly, no. She was born in Hamburg and went to school (thanks to Kinderlandverschickung) in Tolk in Schleswig-Holstein. She died in December 2000 due to an untreated infection of her lungs. If you have a similar story, though, go on and share!
- johnchristopher 11y agoThank you. Sorry, I don't have similar stories (although my grandmother saw two women being shot by the local Belgian police at the end of the war because the two were somehow walking around when the village was supposed to be in lock-down).
- stefantalpalaru 11y ago> when she walked to school, very often US fighters shot at the children walking there. Here's a documentary shot in 1944 that proudly and joyfully tells the story of an air squadron based in Corsica that was bombing civilian targets in northern Italy: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thunderbolt https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thunderbolt! They bombed and shot at houses, farms, trains, people in the fields, etc. The narrator is having fun around the 26:00 mark - "Somebody in that field. Wonder who they are... No friends of mine!": https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0erLVkqvPb0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0erLVkqvPb0 This would not fall under terrorism, but under war crimes. But war crimes only matter if you lose the war, right?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- dTal 11y agoShooting at people in fields is irresponsible, but as the train and one of the houses blew up with terrific explosions I would hesitate to deem them "civilian targets". Fantastic link.
- stefantalpalaru 11y agoI think they knew exactly what they were doing. Shooting the civilian population behind the front line creates problems for the enemy who will now have to divert resources to hospitalize the wounded, deal with a lower agricultural production, a weaker public transportation, a drop in morale, etc.
- kuschku 11y agoIn fact, the concept used in WWII became known as "morale bombing"