4 ms·
That approach has never really done it for me, because what makes it seem impressive is that the magnet is so much smaller than the planet. If you made the plan
by tzs 11y ago
That approach has never really done it for me, because what makes it seem impressive is that the magnet is so much smaller than the planet. If you made the planet more dense, it would be smaller, making the comparison less impressive. Squeeze the planet all the way down to a black hole, and it would be about the size of the magnet.
I think it works better to think of it in terms of the minimum force you can get. Imagine two test masses a fixed distance apart. The minimum non-zero electromagnetic force you can get between those two test masses is the force you get if each test mass has a charge equal to that of an electron.
I'm not sure what the lowest mass particle is that you could reasonably hold near a test point, but since you can reasonably confine an electron to a small region the gravitational force between two electrons is an upper bound on the minimum gravitational force, and that is a ridiculous number of orders of magnitude lower than the minimum electromagnetic force.
- dhimes 11y agoThe ratio of the electric force to the gravitational force for two protons is a good way to get a numerical feel, but the intuitive "aha!" is what the demos are trying to help with. There's a similar demo for showing the strength of atmospheric pressure. You can boil a little water in a soda can, and quickly invert it into a little bowl of water. The water vapor inside quickly condenses causing a startling implosion of the can. It gives an intuitive feel for what 1 atm actually is. You think of astronauts going to where they have to counteract that pressure, and what would happen on failure, and you think "holy shit." Then you think of James Cameron going to where the pressure is 1000 times as great, and what would happen on failure, and you think "holy fucking shit!!"
- bd 11y ago> Then you think of James Cameron going to where the pressure is 1000 times as great, and what would happen on failure, and you think "holy fucking shit!!" Indeed, see Byford Dolphin diving bell accident (very NSFW/NSFL): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Byford_Dolphin https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Byford_Dolphin
- dhimes 11y agoUgh. That's pretty horrible. Thanks for the link- I hadn't seen it.
- beachstartup 11y agoi think the point of the comparison is that the magnet is a few grams, and the earth is trillions upon trillions of kilograms.
- dogma1138 11y agoYou need to squeeze the earth to a much smaller size than that of a fridge magnet to make it into a blackhole and even then you'll get a blackhole with a pull of 1g which would be like a cute puppy.
- tzs 11y agoAn Earth mass black hole would have a radius of about 9 mm. There are many refrigerator magnets around that size. The pull would be 1 g 6400 km away from it. At 1 m it would be over 10^13 g.