4 ms·
I don't understand why this is a problem. It might sound silly, but isn't it like asking why blue is blue? If Gravity is a fundamental force, isn't it like a
by wodenokoto 11y ago
I don't understand why this is a problem.
It might sound silly, but isn't it like asking why blue is blue?
If Gravity is a fundamental force, isn't it like a mathematical axiom? We can't really prove or explain it, it's just the basis for all the other rules.
- chriswarbo 11y agoElectricity and magnetism used to be considered separate phenomena, but then they were found to be two aspects of a single electromagnetic force. Electromagnetism and the weak force used to be considered separate phenomena, but then they were found to be two aspects of a single electroweak force. Progress can't be made if we just accept everything as-is and don't investigate more deeply.
- noir_lord 11y agoAgreed, and the interesting fundamental thing we discover this year sometimes has practical applications 30 years down the line. The semi-conductor wouldn't have existed except for such fundamental work in prior decades. I dislike the "well, that's just the way it is" response to our not understanding something (as do fortunately the smarter people than me scientists!).
- riffraff 11y agoI think what grandparent means is that the question in the title is odd, I thought the same thing, maybe the article explains it bit bit otherwise this seems based on a perception and thus noto really more interesting than, say, why is 3 larger than 2.
- leereeves 11y agoEven mathematical axioms are fertile ground for further research. Non-Euclidean geometry, for example, was born when mathematicians asked why Euclid's fifth postulate (the parallel postulate) is true.
- venomsnake 11y agoIt is not silly. The only reason life exists is because gravity is so weak. So it is better if we are able to know more about it. My favorite pet theory - was watching some of the superstructures of the universe - and was thinking how much the light matter represents the protein structure of a foam or a gel. The question is what is the filling since there is the vast bulk of the space in the universe.
- dwc 11y agoIt's suboptimal that you get down votes for asking an honest question hoping to understand better. I think replies to your question will give a fair number of people a better understanding of the issues.
- rdancer 11y agoThe question is valid, but it is phrased the way a two-year-old would ask it. Better phrasing would be: is there some reason to gravity being so weak compared to the other forces? It turns out if you start with "sky is blue", and keep looking up answers to all the ensuing "but why?" questions, soon you will learn a lot about (in no particular order): Rayleigh scattering, tri- and tetra-chromatism, phenomenology of perception, blindsight, electromagnetic radiation, black body radiation, nuclear fusion, etc. etc, the rabbit hole goes deep. Sometimes stupid questions have really profound and unobvious answers.
- mikeash 11y ago"Blue" is just a name for a particular range of wavelengths of light. Those are "blue" by definition. The "why" is because we declared it so. The gravitational constant is not set by definition. The reason for its value, and the reason why this value is such that the force is so weak, is not known. It could just be arbitrary, but nobody knows. And even if it is arbitrary, it's a completely different arbitrary from how "blue" is arbitrary.
- tim333 11y agoIt's not that it's a problem but it's "The Greatest Unsolved Problem" in the article words or an interesting one at any rate. We understand why the sky is blue - diffraction of the shorter wavelengths. If that was unsolved it would be a cool unsolved problem too.