4 ms·
I'm not sure why physicists think gravity is a force and Pauling exclusion principle isn't. Gravity is fake "inertial" force caused by shape of the space time.
by scotty79 11y ago
I'm not sure why physicists think gravity is a force and Pauling exclusion principle isn't.
Gravity is fake "inertial" force caused by shape of the space time. Why do they insist that it should have gravitons when everything so far show it doesn't fit quantum field models?
- mrfusion 11y agoAnd how do gravitons escape a black hole? Am I right?
- contravariant 11y ago>I'm not sure why physicists think gravity is a force and Pauling exclusion principle isn't. >Gravity is fake "inertial" force caused by shape of the space time. Because all forces are like that? Electromagnetism is just a force created by the shape of the electromagnetic gauge field. In mathematical terms: it is the curvature of the gauge connection. In exactly the same way that gravity is a force created by the curvature of the metric connection.
- hasenj 11y agoI'm not sure if this comparison holds. Space-time is the environment that matter moves through. Curvatures in spacetime affects how matter moves. What is the electromagnetic gauge field? Why does it only affect charged particles? Why does it affect particles differently depending on the type of charge they hold (positive/negative)? It doesn't seem to be the same thing as spacetime.
- contravariant 11y agoGiven the nature of this subject not all your questions have definitive answers, but I'll try to give it my best shot. You should probably consider these answers a subjective interpretation, rather than objective facts. The most consistent interpretation of QFT I've seen so far views gauge fields as principal bundles. This implies that matter not only propagate through space-time but also through the gauge field, and the way it is 'changed' as it passes through the gauge field is related to the charge. Now technically the electromagnetic gauge field (and others) also affects uncharged particles, mainly because it couples to gravity, but perhaps also in more subtle ways (think of the way light can be affected by simply passing through a piece of matter). Admittedly there are quite a few differences (since the metric has a somewhat special position) but there are also quite a few similarities. Unfortunately nobody has yet found a (testable) theory that either unifies the forces or can treat the separately. I'm placing my bets on the 'unification' side though.
- avian 11y ago> I'm not sure why physicists think gravity is a force and Pauling exclusion principle isn't. http://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/44712/is-pauli-repulsion-a-force-that-is-completely-separate-from-the-4-fundamental http://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/44712/is-pauli-re... http://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/141865/how-does-the-pauli-exclusion-principle-create-a-force-in-degenerate-matter http://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/141865/how-does-t...
- scotty79 11y ago> It is not a force, since at the particle level forces have carriers that are exchanged between particles so that momentum and energy change. In other words, we couldn't fit it to model of quantum fields and carriers and it fits perfectly other model where it's not a force. Gravity could be described with same exact words. Although I agree that exclusion principle superficially looks much less like a force than gravity does. Still, gravity is exactly same as forces that come from choosing accelerating frame of reference ... are there plans to look for carriers of those forces as well? Or should we expect gravitons popping up once we accelerate that don't exist for stationary observer?
- evanb 11y agoGravitons are usually formulated by perturbing the metric around the flat Minkowski metric, but you can do perturbation theory around any metric, include those that describe accelerating frames. So, you might actually get gravitons in an accelerated frame. What you call background metric and what you call gravitons can get mixed together. However, because gravity is formulated in a generally covariant (ie. invariant under diffeomorphisms) the physical predictions must nevertheless agree when formulated in a frame-independent manner, much as they must in special relativity. Maybe the best example of quantum effects being different for accelerating and stationary observers is the Unruh Effect ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unruh_effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unruh_effect ). If an observer accelerates relative to a 0-temperature vacuum, they will see a blackbody background with T ~ a.
- 11y ago
- krastanov 11y agoIt is not true that it does not fit quantum field models. Plenty of meaningful results have been derived from effective QFT (Hawking radiation for instance). The model does break at a certain scale, but that is true for models without gravity too.
- scotty79 11y ago> Plenty of meaningful results have been derived from effective QFT (Hawking radiation for instance). You mean unobservable (yet?) predictions? > The model does break at a certain scale, but that is true for models without gravity too. That's kind of deal breaker when it comes to gravity.
- krastanov 11y ago>> Plenty of meaningful results have been derived from effective QFT (Hawking radiation for instance). > You mean unobservable (yet?) predictions? Unruh effect is observed in accelerators (it warms up the particles in the acceleration rings). Admittedly it has to do more with the principle of equivalence than directly with gravity, but it would be hard to find a physicist that has an issue with this. >> The model does break at a certain scale, but that is true for models without gravity too. > That's kind of deal breaker when it comes to gravity. What do you mean? All our models break at certain energy scales and of course it is a deal breaker for all of them, no matter if we are talking about the Standart Model or an Effective QFT with gravity. Yes, we do not know what happens when curvatures reach the plank scale, but there are plenty of other things that we do not know even if we do not include gravity.
- scotty79 11y ago>>> The model does break at a certain scale, but that is true for models without gravity too. >> That's kind of deal breaker when it comes to gravity. > What do you mean? All our models break at certain energy scales ... I thought that by scale you meant size not energy and that theory breaks at larger distances (larger than typical distance for observable quantum effects). You can see how could I see this as a deal breaker for gravity that only over large distances is strong enough to be measurable).
- joncrocks 11y agoPauli, not Pauling. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pauli_exclusion_principle https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pauli_exclusion_principle
- scotty79 11y agoouch, thank you ... shouldn't have relied on auto correct to guess the right physicist