5 ms·
Awhile back, I tried to find the actual studies that determined that sugar has 4 kcal/g and fat has 9. I failed. I couldn't even find a clear definition of wh
by amluto 11y ago
Awhile back, I tried to find the actual studies that determined that sugar has 4 kcal/g and fat has 9. I failed. I couldn't even find a clear definition of what a kcal means. (Is it mechanical work you can do after eating it? ATP produced?)
Given recent results, I wouldn't be at all surprised to learn that fat, in general, has less than 9 kcal/g or that sugar has more than 4.
- InclinedPlane 11y agoOne calorie is the energy required to raise the temperature of one gram of water at 1 atm pressure by one degree Celsius, it is equal to about 4.2 Joules. A kilocalorie, or a dietary Calorie, is one thousand calories, or 4200 Joules. All of this is readily available from an innumerable number of sources. The calorie content of food is determined experimentally by burning the food in a calorimeter and measuring how much heat is produced (by, for example, measuring how much it raises the temperature of a water bath). This measures the energy content of the food, but does not measure the amount of energy your body can make use of as that is a very complex problem that would have a different answer in every individual due to variations in body size, metabolism, digestion, muscle mass, insulin activity, the ambient temperature, and about a zillion other factors.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- NikolaeVarius 11y agoWe haven't done that since the 1990's. Calorie content is calculated by measuring the amount of fat, protein, carbs in a food and extrapolating from that. It's pretty damn close.
- niccaluim 11y agoExcept, apparently, for walnuts. :)
- InclinedPlane 11y agoPerhaps I wasn't clear, I said that's how calories are determined experimentally, I did not say that's how all calorie counts are generated.
- pharrington 11y agoWell, in this study the calories were measured by the difference of energy released by calorimetry between the walnuts and the subjects' waste. The definition of calory in this case is obvious (and infinitely more useful than simply measuring only the energy released from igniting the food).
- Aloisius 11y agoThe numbers the US uses for calories in fat, protein, carbohydrates and alcohol come originally from a man named Wilbur Atwater who around the turn of the 20th century calculated them by measuring how many calories someone was consuming and measuring the calories in their feces. They've been modified over the years for specific ingredients, but we still use the Atwater system today because it is very easy for food manufacturers to use. Europe and elsewhere use Rubner factors which are slightly different.
- et2o 11y agoKcal = 1000 calories calorie = amount of energy required to heat 1g of H2O 1 degree Celsius This is defined in chemistry 101. This entire thread sort of makes me want to face palm.
- pharrington 11y agoUse chemistry to explain to me how a human body converts a walnut into energy. Hey downvoters, if Im wrong in thinking that the chemical processes involved in digestion are too complex to be coherently applied to a high level model of a human diet, then explain how Im wrong. Or am I just dumb for feeding the troll?
- et2o 11y agoI'm not sure if this is me misreading your comment, but this has been extensively worked out. We have really excellent knowledge of how metabolism works compared to a lot of other processes in biology. You learn this as the major, significant component of any introductory biochemistry class. I don't even know where to start here. It's quite a jump to label me as a troll.
- SilasX 11y agoIn the context of their post, the parent (as I read it) meant the operational, nutritional definition of a calorie, not the thermodynamic one. That is, when it's claimed on a label, does it mean "this is what you get from burning it in a lab" or "this is how much usable energy as ATP it becomes" or "this is the ignition delta between mouth and feces"? The thermodynamic definition doesn't tell us that.
- iopq 11y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atwater_system https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atwater_system protein is counted as 4 because it's harder to digest, even though it's more than 5 calories when burned carbs and fats are easy to digest so they're counted as-is