3 ms·
In my opinion, any regulatory scheme which starts with "anyone can drive a cab if they have insurance + driver's license" is going to be worse than Uber. One o
by mikeash 11y ago
In my opinion, any regulatory scheme which starts with "anyone can drive a cab if they have insurance + driver's license" is going to be worse than Uber.
One of the major advantages of Uber is the rating system. A bad Uber driver typically won't last long in the job. There isn't much that will get a bad taxi driver to stop driving. Eventually complaints might filter up to their boss or regulators, but it's a much weaker mechanism.
I think the existing regulations were mostly put in place to compensate for information asymmetry. People get into a taxi unfamiliar with the driver, the car, reasonable costs, and the area. To ensure a minimum level of competence, drivers are regulated. To ensure people don't get ripped off, fares are regulated. To ensure people don't get driven on artificially expensive routes... well, that doesn't seem to have been regulated very well.
Smartphones solve this better, though. Rather than some broad regulatory regime to ensure minimum competence from a random unknown driver, you can use an app to find out about your specific driver. To ensure you don't get ripped off, you can use an app to get a fare estimate to your destination before you book. To ensure you don't get driven on artificially expensive routes, you can just compare the route you take with the route your phone thinks you should take.
I wholeheartedly agree that we need an open market, not just another monopoly. But in doing so, we should take the lessons from Uber, not just the lessons from the past. The present looks a lot different. Any system which looks like traditional taxis and doesn't take advantage of the easy flow of information is going to be inferior.
- asift 11y agoWhy do you suppose Uber created a reputation system and vets their drivers? They certainly weren't required to, but they profit from reducing asymmetry because consumers want to know their ride will be a pleasant experience. Mandating the features Uber voluntarily chose to add will only hold future competitors back when some new type of technology moves beyond our existing capabilities. And good luck removing those regulations once those are in place. You'll have powerful companies like Uber fighting tooth and nail to keep competitors out of the market.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]