13 ms·
U.S. states pass laws backing Uber's view of drivers as contractors
- gergles 11y agoI don't really understand how a state law declaring something as so can have any relevant effect on federal determinations of employee/contractor status, which is far more dangerous to the TNCs business model. This mostly seems like feel-good legislation purchased by Uber to try to delay the inevitable, but the drivers are employees by any sort of logical duck test, and it's only a matter of time before the courts come to that conclusion too.
- geogra4 11y agoYeah -- I see this not going very far as the states don't really have control over this.
- fweespeech 11y ago> I don't really understand how a state law declaring something as so can have any relevant effect on federal determinations of employee/contractor status 1) It causes the state tax boards to go along with it so Uber can focus its legal resources on when it gets dragged into Federal court. 2) If it becomes "usual and customary" in enough states a Republican congress might be willing to pass a bill to back it.
- shams93 11y agoYeah if you think of it from the perspective of the federal IRS I bet they are getting nervous about so much of the economy going freelance.As an employee Im a sitting duck for the tax man, as a contractor with my own business my income is far less preductabke however the IRS inevitably and legally gets a much smaller piece of my pie.
- asift 11y agoHow do they legally get less of your money? Unless you are engaging in some type of tax fraud, this really isn't true.
- gozur88 11y agoI think he's assuming the government will have a much harder time proving undeclared income. Probably not true in Uber's case, but contractors are pretty notorious for giving generous cash discounts.
- dangrossman 11y agoFor the same job making the same income, you'll typically pay more taxes as a contractor than as an employee. You'll pay 100% of your SS/medicare taxes via the self-employment tax, where previously your employer was paying 50% of it for you. The income tax brackets are the same. You can deduct business expenses, but so could your employer, so the IRS isn't missing out on anything.
- 15155 11y agoSure, but it's substantially more expensive to administer and enforce tax on a company than an individual filing a simple 1040. The withholdings system exists to make it easier to collect.
- morgante 11y ago> the drivers are employees by any sort of logical duck test I strongly disagree and think this is very open for debate. Drivers set their own hours and use their own equipment. They can even simultaneously use another app (ex. Lyft). I really don't see how it constitutes an employment relationship. In fact, it seems to match all the typical characteristics of contractors.
- venomsnake 11y agoA good test - if the contracts are negotiated individually for all drivers - they are contractors. If it is take or leave with 1000s more like you - you are employee. If you have no bargaining power - you are not a contractor IMO.
- sageikosa 11y agoOr...more likely...you are a contractor offering a commodity service in a market with ample supply. There's no requirement to go into lengthy or customized negotiations to offer, accept or reject a contract.
- jsprogrammer 11y agoUber drivers don't even have the opportunity to negotiate a contract. The situations are not even comparable.
- sageikosa 11y agoHuh? I can negotiate a salary, that doesn't make me a contractor. A separate haggling phase of a contract is not necessary for a contract to have legal force. It's the agreement to the letter of the contract.
- jsprogrammer 11y agoYes, you can still have a "contract", but the driver and rider either accept or reject a prewritten, third-party contract. The driver cannot negotiate directly with the rider as you would expect an independent contractor to be able to do.
- ahallock 11y agoWhat if I don't want to be an employee? What if I like setting my own hours? Seems like there's a lack of empathy on some accounts to force everyone into one category.
- benten10 11y agoA lot of workplaces do allow you to be an employee and have your own hours.
- pc86 11y agoSince being an employee v. a contractor is largely a tax concern, it's not necessarily your decision.
- gutnor 11y agoI guess it is a question of power. An IT Contractor for example, may be tied to a specific client and the client may have strict requirement, but actually enjoy the same flexibility as the company as he can leave and reasonably assume he can be contracted somewhere else, or work on its own. On the other hand, if McDo was to label all its employee contractor, most of them are tied to that specific employment and don't have actual flexibility. I guess the contractor / employee law is meant to protect #2, but can catch #1 as a side effect. So whenever you say "I don't want to be an employee" you most likely in position #1, while people in the other group simply would say "I can't be an employee". That said, I have no idea what status Uber driver really should have. As taxi driver, I guess they have a variety of option for revenues and are only tied to Uber because Uber is a good source of work rather than being dominated by Uber ?
- SilasX 11y agoBut what is the relevant "duck" here? What actual dynamic is the law trying to enforce? Any good law tries to align individual incentives with a social optimum, and I don't see how it's doing that here. As best I can tell, employment law is trying to achieve the goal of "to the extent that you make a person economically dependent on you in the short term, you must provide that person some benefits that make up for that dependence". Hence why contractors get treated one way and employees another. But then the law goes about it the wrong way by having a sharp discontinuity that encourages employers to make the relationship such that they get all of the advantages of such dependence, but stay just on the side of "you're still a contractor". For example, as it stands now, employers strengthen their case by making the worker bring their own tools. A sane law would be more continuous: as you introduce more dependence of the worker on you, you most provide increasingly more benefits to cancel the problem that introduces. Though I admit that would involve a huge refactoring. Trying to resolve whether someone "is" a contractor is (in the grander scheme) asking the wrong question, like debating whether alcoholism "is" a disease (cf Scott Alexander's "non central fallacy" or "worst argument in the world").
- hwstar 11y agoYes, and this will only get passed by the legislatures of red states.
- forrestthewoods 11y agoDrivers are like employees in someways and contractors in someways. We currently have square holes and round holes. Drivers are hexagons and don't match either. Forcing them into either hole will have negative consequences.
- pkaye 11y agoI never understood why Uber didn't make all their employees (developers, marketing, sales) become contractors so they can save of all the additional costs.
- jsprogrammer 11y agoWhat would Uber be then? Just a holding company that everyone dumps their money in to? Why would anyone do that?
- pkaye 11y agoThen a bulk of the value will go to the investors.
- jsprogrammer 11y agoBulk of whatever value exists. My point is that there probably will be no value for the investors to extract as none of the people who do the actual work would stand for such a structure for long. It would be trivial to introduce an organization that performs the same function, but which distributes all accumulated value to those performing the actions of the organization. Such an organization would have no use for investors who exist solely to take value out of the organization.
- dalke 11y agoBecause they might be liable for fines if the IRS determines that is a misclassification. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Misclassification_of_employees_as_independent_contractors https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Misclassification_of_employees... with the misclassification at Microsoft ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Permatemp#IRS_tax_rulings https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Permatemp#IRS_tax_rulings ) as a well-known example.
- pkaye 11y agoThey can just get the state to pass laws to allow it...
- xixi77 11y agoSimilar schemes have been used in e.g. trucking for years; I am not sure what you think is the substantial difference between an Uber driver and a truck owner-operator, but it's far from obvious and very far from inevitable.
- awqrre 11y agoDo you have any disclosure to make? are you involved with the taxi industry for example?
- untog 11y agoAnother reason for Uber to delay going public - so they don't have to show the world how much they spend on lobbyists.
- whoiskevin 11y agoExactly. "At one point, Uber sent five representatives to a meeting with members of the insurance industry to negotiate language in the bill" Just makes you feel warm and fuzzy doesn't it?
- e28eta 11y agoI think it's interesting watching Uber become politically savvy. When the company started, it simply ignored regulations that weren't convenient. Now they seem to lean on lobbying, as well as campaigns to drive the public to contact local politicians. But that only works because they're large enough now.
- cm2012 11y agoLobbyist spending is generally just lumped into Other, I don't think I've ever seen it split out on an S-1.
- debacle 11y agoUber is paving the way for another company to make a ton of money in their space.
- nobody_nowhere 11y agoNot just their space
- masklinn 11y agoAnd they're mostly paving the way for companies already doing that not having to fudge it as much or be as careful.
- brainflake 11y agoExactly. Uber is doing all of the work on the regulation front, which benefits any company wanting to do the same thing. And I would imagine the barrier to entry is already fairly low.
- kuschku 11y agoNot really. Uber is behaving extremely anti-competitive, as far as directly calling Lyft rides and then cancelling as soon as the car arrives during important days (like Christmas) hundreds of times. Uber has been fighting against other competitors, too, with predatory pricing, or by directly trying to use the regulations (that uber itself breaks) against competitors. The barrier to entry for uber competitors is only going up since uber exists in several countries.
- morgante 11y ago> Uber is behaving extremely anti-competitive, as far as directly calling Lyft rides and then cancelling as soon as the car arrives during important days (like Christmas) hundreds of times. I heard about the recruitment tactics, but I've never heard about holiday cancellations. Do you have any evidence of this?
- rem7 11y agoIf I remember correctly, wasn't one of the main reasons they weren't considered contractors is because they don't set their rates? How would this affect other industries... Like the tech industry... I mean I guess the contractor can always just say no if they don't like the rate being set.
- panzagl 11y agoAs much as I can see the need for disruption in the taxi industry, I can't help but feel like we're going to relearn some lesson from a hundred years ago as to why the regulations formed in the first place.
- mseebach 11y agoPerhaps the world is sufficiently different from a hundred years ago that we don't need the regulations anymore.
- kuschku 11y agoIt took Uber 2 years to acknowledge the fact that, yes, you need insurance when you drive a car commercially. It will take another few until they’ll acknowledge that their drivers are employees, not contractors, and can demand medical insurance, retirement funds, etc. All these things used to be provided thanks to regulation, and we’re seeing now how removing the regulation leads to uninsured cars on the roads driven by people earning below minimum wage without any social security.
- icebraining 11y agoAll these things used to be provided thanks to regulation No, most taxi drivers were already contractors, those things were not being provided before Uber came around.
- SilasX 11y agoI agree that Uber is flouting some reasonable, still-relevant regulations[1]. However, the insistence on "Uber needs to provide medical insurance, retirement funds, etc" is ... well, it comes off as a bit quixotic. If you did "lay down the law" one day, does that mean workers magically have all kinds of freebies? No, it would be paid for out of the same revenues that Ubers drivers are currently being paid with. Instead of "$1/mile", it'll be "$0.30/mile, minimum mile requirement, and you get health insurance". Out of one pocket, into the other. [1] "If someone is driving for your service, you must verify, not just trust, that they're insured, whether or not you provide that insurance yourself."
- godzillabrennus 11y agoThe federal government derives 89% of its funding from income tax and payroll tax. https://www.nationalpriorities.org/budget-basics/federal-budget-101/revenues/ https://www.nationalpriorities.org/budget-basics/federal-bud... With contractors instead of employees the onus of paying taxes shifts to the unreliable individual. There is no way that this continues to grow unabated by legislation. Either these people will end up employees or they have to pay taxes using some kind of automated system special for the sharing economy.
- Bud 11y agoSince the article chose to not cover this important detail about the 5 states in question, allow me: all five have Republican governors and extremely large Republican majorities in the state legislature. To not cover this detail is to gloss over the real story here. To wit: Ohio: Republican governor, Republican state House (65-34), Republican state Senate (23-10). Florida: Republican governor, Republican state House (81-39), Republican state Senate (26-14). North Carolina: Republican governor, Republican state House (74-45), Republican state Senate (34-16). Arkansas: Republican governor, Republican state House (64-35), Republican state Senate (24-11). Indiana: Republican governor, Republican state House (71-29), Republican state senate (40-10). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_United_States_state_legislatures https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_United_States_state_le...
- us0r 11y agoand?
- s73v3r 11y agoWhy on earth would a state do this? It makes absolutely no sense.
- littletimmy 11y agoIt is weird to see that despite all the lessons from the past century and the financial crisis, some people in this thread still argue that the market is going to regulate itself and the government should just stay out of it. What's it going to take before you accept that public accountability is important? An end of civilization?
- xenihn 11y agoUber is eventually going to be fully automated. Lots of people ITT seem to be ignoring the fact that Uber will eventually have no need for human drivers. I can't help but feel that the parties driving legislation that harms Uber as a company have this in mind.
- Futurebot 11y agoThis is one reason some have called for a third category of worker: http://nymag.com/daily/intelligencer/2015/07/uber-economy-requires-a-new-category-of-worker.html http://nymag.com/daily/intelligencer/2015/07/uber-economy-re... Germany has one already: http://www.npr.org/2015/06/26/417675866/service-jobs-like-uber-driver-blur-lines-between-old-job-categories http://www.npr.org/2015/06/26/417675866/service-jobs-like-ub... Of course, this would be much less of an issue if we had a guaranteed income, or even a lesser version of it for being between jobs; something like unemployment insurance, but only for people in this new category (which would have much less stringent requirements.) A universal health care system would also lessen their burden; ACA / Freelancer Union rates are still bananas expensive. If we accepted that modern workers that flit from job to job and project to project are here to stay and gave them a real safety net without all the nasty ideological baggage, we could come closer to achieving the dream of the fluid, frictionless, task-oriented labor force that some economists have thought we should have for decades. Instead we have the Precariat.
- losteric 11y ago> If we accepted that modern workers that flit from job to job and project to project are here to stay and gave them a real safety net without all the nasty ideological baggage, we could come closer to achieving the dream of the fluid, frictionless, task-oriented labor force that some economists have thought we should have for decades. Instead we have the Precariat.' In many cases, a student's chosen major dictates their career options for the rest of their employed lives. The costs of switching knowledge-based jobs is hurting job market responsiveness and driving social inequality. Fundamentally, the model of "learn as a kid - do as an adult" is obsolete. The world is far too complicated and moving far too fast. We need to strip down basic childhood education and publicly support adults learning throughout life. It doesn't have to be easy... it will still take years to switch domains. But that's a lag of 1-2 years for adults to retrain vs encouraging a new generation in highschool and waiting for them to pass through college.
- Futurebot 11y agoI agree completely. Tuition free higher education with living stipends a la Denmark is a way to get there.