6 ms·
I'm not entirely sure I understand the issue with Gentrification, and what is gentrification and what isn't. I live in a pretty nice neighbourhood of Amsterdam
by mcv 11y ago
I'm not entirely sure I understand the issue with Gentrification, and what is gentrification and what isn't.
I live in a pretty nice neighbourhood of Amsterdam. 15 years ago, when I moved here, my uncle (who is a cop) warned me not to live here because of all the crime (though the neighbourhood where he lives has a worse reputation). The population at the time was a decent mix. Lots of ethnic minorities, but also students and probably middle class families along the edges.
During the past 15 years, loads of new restaurants have opened here, there's a small movie theatre, the dodgy-looking call shops and phone shops have disappeared, the snack bar that changed ownership every year has now turned into a fancy wine bar. Some old buildings have been turn down and replaced, others have been renovated. Generally, this seems to me like a great example of gentrification.
And I'm sure housing prices are rising, and I don't doubt the new and renovated buildings are more expensive than the older ones. But the population doesn't seem to have changed all that much. Maybe there are more affluent white people now, but I still see kids from a variety of ethnic backgrounds play in the streets (though I don't see groups of adolescents and young adults hang around the square where that dodgy snack bar used to be), and there are still plenty of Turkish shops (though some have closed, sometimes to be replaced by a new Turkish shop, sometimes not).
I don't know how many people have been forced out due to the gentrification. They include my brother-in-law, who had lived there for ages until his house was to be renovated. But for the most part, the population doesn't seem to have changed much, and the neighbourhood seems to be more vibrant, more stuff to do, less need to go to the center of the city if you want to go out.
So if this is gentrification, my impression of it is pretty positive, though I don't have any stats to back it up. Of course with those people who hung around on that square, I have no idea who they are or where they are now. It feels safer, but that might be subconscious racism talking.
- pdkl95 11y ago> loads of new restaurants Who is going to staff those restaurants (and other low-wage services) when the housing prices are so high that it isn't realistically possible to find a rent (forget a mortgage) low enough to be affordable for someone making those low wages? This is made worse in places like south-bay/SF area where the private busing and 2nd/"weekend" apartments further distort local taxing/etc and drive prices up even further. > I don't know how many people have been forced out due to the gentrification. That depends on a lot, but when money is involved, there are lots of creative ways people can be forced out. Zoning laws and other "fees" are common. If renting is involved, buying out the landlord and raising the rates on the tenants (sometimes to unreasonable levels designed to not be paid) is a popular move. > Generally, this seems to me like a great example of gentrification. From your description, that sounds like an example of how a town or city should be maintained. There is a difference between rising housing prices from normal inflation and gentrification.
- alistairSH 11y agoThe US also has additional "baggage" that comes from it's past racial problems. I live near DC. Gentrification in the city is almost always wealthy whites displacing poor blacks. There is very much an us-vs-them feeling among those that are being displaced. One ridiculous effect of the gentrification... Historically black churches in the downtown areas now have congregations that have been displaced and commute from the suburbs to attend services. This causes all sorts of problems with parking that didn't exist when the congregation lived in the neighborhood. This in turn causes conflict with new residents, who want to add bike lanes. The congregation doesn't like that because it would reduce on-street parking.
- liotier 11y ago> new residents, who want to add bike lanes. The congregation doesn't like that because it would reduce on-street parking. One can easily imagine the bike lanes being used as stealth exclusionary devices, which depresses me as I would rather see them as empowering people through better urban transportation.
- pdkl95 11y ago> displacing poor blacks That would be "redlining", another very despicable tactic used to keep cities segregated. If you haven't read it, Ta-Nehisi Coates impressive essay on the subject is worth a read. http://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2014/06/the-case-for-reparations/361631/ http://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2014/06/the-case...
- forkandwait 11y agoNo, redlining is something different (not loaning money), though very messed up.
- pdkl95 11y agoAs the essay I linked to discusses, there are more aspects to redlining than just loans (though that is where the practice gets its name). In any case, it's all part of the same racist attempts to keep people segregated. At least in the USA, you can't really separate gentrification, redlining, and other housing problems.
- Someone 11y agoAmsterdam has very good rent protection. That slows down gentrification. Also, the Netherlands subsidizes rents for low income people. Without rent protection, landlords would in many cases more than double rents overnight. That would almost immediately drive out the less well-to-do people, even in the presence of subsidies on rents.