5 ms·
Is it fair to characterize Volkswagen's response as "blame the engineer"? For example, from http://www.wsj.com/articles/vw-shares-up-ahead-of-emissions-finding
by leereeves 11y ago
Is it fair to characterize Volkswagen's response as "blame the engineer"?
For example, from http://www.wsj.com/articles/vw-shares-up-ahead-of-emissions-findings-1449740759 http://www.wsj.com/articles/vw-shares-up-ahead-of-emissions-...
> Volkswagen has suspended nine managers suspected of being involved in the fraud
> Volkswagen has replaced six executives since the beginning of the year and has switched leadership of seven of its dozen brands.
> Volkswagen also disclosed in November that employees had tipped management off to another unrelated issue, saying the company had understated greenhouse-gas emissions and fuel consumption on up to 800,000 gasoline-powered cars. After an internal investigation, Volkswagen lowered that figure to fewer than 50,000 cars.
- masklinn 11y agoThe article talk about (and links to) a very specific article reporting what can fairly be seen as "blame the engineer" > Volkswagen investigators have determined that engineers cheated U.S. emissions tests in part because they could not figure out how to meet the standards, the company said today. > Volkswagen Group Chairman Hans-Dieter Potsch told reporters that engineers erred by developing manipulative software to fool regulators because they "quite simply could not find a way to meet the tougher" limits for nitrogen oxide pollutants in the U.S. Deeper in the body, the article all but confirms that it wasn't a few engineers gone rogue with statements like > Peter De Lorenzo, a former auto industry marketing executive and editor of Autoextremist.com, said Volkswagen cultivated a "culture of fear" that nudged engineers to "do whatever they had to do to say that they met the standards."
- nerdy 11y agoCategorizing it as "blame the engineer" is sadly accurate in my opinion. That has been VW's stance from the very beginning. VW's US CEO said, while denying a corporate-level scandal, "software engineers who put this in for whatever reason," to a congressional panel back in October: http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2015/10/volkswagen-pulls-2016-diesel-lineup-from-us-market/ http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2015/10/volkswagen-pulls-... Certainly doesn't get any more "blame the engineer" than that, unless they're supposedly somehow changing their tune now... which is not my impression. With regards to middle management being laid off, it strikes me more as the C-level players insulating themselves from the taint.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- dagw 11y agoDidn't downvote you, but the CEO of VW America has nothing really to do with the company that actually designs and builds VW cars. He basically just sells their cars in US. So as such he probably has no idea about what is actually going on. The executives at the 'real' VW have been much more nuanced in their statements
- ascagnel_ 11y agoI would imagine that a company's national/continental headquarters is also responsible for making sure each car is compliant with their respective localities as part of the process of readying it for sale (especially in the US, where individual states can have their own emissions standards that exceed that of the federal government). Even if VW of America didn't design, build, or request the cheat devices, they're still partially culpable by either unknowingly offering the cars for sale (and not doing their own independent tests in advance of the third-party testing that detected the cheat devices) or knowingly offering cars for sale that didn't meet local emissions standards.
- nerdy 11y agoIf he doesn't know what is happening should he be making assertions to Congress (or anyone) like that?
- dagw 11y agoProbably not. But I guess it's difficult for some people to say "Not my department, so fucked if I know". So they make something up that sounds plausible and hope that it either happens to be correct or that no one ends up calling them up it.
- a3n 11y ago1. Members' questions probably forced a statement like that. 2. I'm certain he consulted with the mothership before testimony, and the message was "be a brand champion."
- jondubois 11y agoI do remember reading an article which made it sound like it was all the fault of a couple of engineers. I wouldn't be surprised if VW had a hand in the publication of these articles. VW probably ended up tweaking their damage-control strategy after realizing that people just wouldn't buy it. That seems to be a pretty common approach for PR damage-control; first you try to lay the blame on the most helpless people possible, if the public doesn't buy it, you have to shift the blame to progressively more senior people until the public is satisfied. That's pretty much what happened with the Watergate scandal.
- usrusr 11y agoBut even those article were mostly about leaders of huge engineering departments. Here on HN (and in the article linked today), there seems to be much uproar about "blame the engineer" because "engineer" is read as the underdog "little guy in the trenches". But that uproar is completely beside the point because in the communication of VW, "engineer" has a very different meaning. There it may apply to anyone in a department that is not strictly manufacturing, marketing or organizational like finance our HR, no matter how high up in the hierarchy and no matter how little actual engineering they still do - provided they actually have the academic grade. In german, you do not get to call yourself "Ingenieur" because you are doing engineering. Academic grades take very strong precedence over job descriptions (and terminologal collisions between those two areas are strictly avoided). The only source for "blame the engineer" in the way it is read here on hacker news are some completely clueless excuses made by the CEO of Volkswagen USA, but that guy is hardly more than a glorified car dealer.
- jacquesm 11y agoEngineer in this context appear to mean: anybody not present in the board room or in the sales and marketing departments.
- dagw 11y agoEngineer in this context appear to mean: anybody not present in the board room Which is kind of ironic since 4 out of 7 of VW's board hold technical or engineering degrees.
- wilsynet 11y agoYes. There is a new story, Volkswagen has issued new statements: http://www.usatoday.com/story/money/cars/2015/12/10/volkswagen-emissions-scandal-investigation/77082362/ http://www.usatoday.com/story/money/cars/2015/12/10/volkswag...