5 ms·
>>Such programmes are pricey. In India and Bangladesh they cost more than $1,000 per household at purchasing power parity. I wish there was a way I could send
by gadders 11y ago
>>Such programmes are pricey. In India and Bangladesh they cost more than $1,000 per household at purchasing power parity.
I wish there was a way I could send $1,000 directly to a named individual, rather than the usual charity practise of putting mony in a pot and getting a duplicated letter from your sponsored person.
- thetmkay 11y agoGiveDirectly[0] provide a minimal 'charity layer' of such a service (transferring money directly to the right people). If you feel disillusioned by modern charity, effective altruism might interest you. I recently read "Doing Good Better" by Will Macaskill and I recommend it - it puts forward a very compelling case for how to optimise charity-giving. [0]https://www.givedirectly.org/operating-model.html https://www.givedirectly.org/operating-model.html
- gadders 11y agoI guess what I want to do is help 100% of one person, rather than 0.001% of a thousand.
- morgante 11y agoWhy? Isn't it the same in the end? Money is fungible.
- jdhawk 11y agoSome people like having concrete evidence of where their dollar was spent?
- VikingCoder 11y agoHere's my thinking, along these lines... Everyone's all into Gamification, right? Well... I started to wonder what would happen if you made the ultimate cross between Entertainment and Philanthropy. Wrap it up as a video game you can give to a teenager in the first world, to try to teach them some empathy. I tried to describe what it's like to play this game, as if one teenager was explaining it to another teenager. ... "Save A Kid" It costs $100 to buy the game, and it's $15 per month to play. When you pick a character, you get to pick a Country of origin, and then an age and a sex. Then you get to start customizing, by looking for a character that has a given race or religion, if you care about that. For newbies, I'd definitely recommend picking a character that speaks a language you can speak fluently. And if you're an Expert, you can play a character that has different Disadvantages. It doesn't give you any bonus attributes, but you get bragging rights for playing one of them well. There's like, Orphan and Kid-With-AIDS, and then there are harder ones like "Scarred by War" where the kids have missing limbs, etc. Anyway, newbies should probably avoid those at first. So, anyway, it's kind of like The Sims, or a Tamagotchi, or Farm Town, or something. You log on every day, and depending on the character you picked, you either get an email, or maybe a voice mail or a video mail. The character tells you about how much it appreciates the new computer (http://latptop.org http://latptop.org) and the food (https://www.fmsc.org/home https://www.fmsc.org/home). The first couple levels, it's all about gaining Health Points. You can totally nerf your character by spending some of your monthly allotment of extra gold points on buffing the kid's parents (http://www.kiva.org/ http://www.kiva.org/), if he has them. The parents start generating more gold points on their own, which makes it a lot easier to play. Some people even buy buffs online (http://www.heifer.org/ http://www.heifer.org/), which I think is cheating, but for a newbie, it's an easy way to keep your kid alive. Anyway, you and your friends can make a clan, and all play characters in the same village. I've even heard that some really crazy rich players can buy buffs for the whole village, like a potable water and electricity system (fora.tv/2008/07/03/Dean_Kamen_on_Potable_Water_and_Sustainable_Electricity). There are Events in the game, where like the country the kid is in goes into War. That sucks, because sometimes you lose your character, and the game is perma-death, which is lame. They do a really good job making the game realistic, because sometimes you even see in the news that the real country is in war. Most of the time, they just make stuff up though, because most of the wars never show up on TV, but your character won't shut up about them. Anyway, it's a sandbox game, which some people don't like. But the AI is incredible. Your character will like ask you how they can keep their food from spoiling, and if you look it up online (https://www.ashoka.org/fellow/mohammed-bah-abba https://www.ashoka.org/fellow/mohammed-bah-abba), and explain to them how to do it, they can save some of their food. Or like, how they can build a windmill from scrap metal (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/William_Kamkwamba https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/William_Kamkwamba). Anyway, you play the same character as long as you want to, but most people get bored after the kid has a job and their own family, and they start over at level one. Restarting costs another $100 though. The game developers say if too many people play the game, they might even run out of characters to play. I don't buy it. They'll always make up some new War, or some world-shattering Disaster like a typhoon or something, and then a bunch of new characters will open up. Expansion packs, and all that. A lot of people play this game like 40 hours a week, or something ridiculous. Some people say that playing this game has changed their lives or whatever, and they give up their jobs and play it full time (http://www.peacecorps.gov/ http://www.peacecorps.gov/). ... Anyway, I guess you can already play most of those mini-games in other forms, but until they package it up in a nice box that you can buy at Best Buy, and they set up some dedicated servers, and set up a scoring ladder (good grades in school, etc.) and maybe some achievements ("high school diploma", "got a job," etc.), oh and a nice technical support line to answer questions and give advice, I don't think the game will really take off.
- dragonwriter 11y agoI'm trying to figure out whether I more want to laugh at that -- or invest in it.
- VikingCoder 11y agoAs Zoidberg would say... "Can't it be both?"
- pault 11y agoYou could write a great short story in this form.
- merpnderp 11y agoI have a friend who's been directly supporting a single orphan in Kenya and put him all the way through school making sure he was fed, clothed, and taken care of. Such programs take stable governments and some level of state infrastructure, but seeing him grow up happy, healthy and educated has been worth every penny to her.
- RobertoG 11y agoWatsi is only for medical treatments but works like that. I would like to see something similar for education. https://watsi.org/ https://watsi.org/
- bcks 11y agoCheck out http://www.friendsforeducation.org http://www.friendsforeducation.org They are super small, but do some amazing work paying school fees and scholarships for students from Dalit and marginalized communities in India. 100% of donated funds go to the students and they are completely transparent about every donation.
- RobertoG 11y agoThanks. I will check them.
- adwmayer 11y agohttp://www.heifer.org/gift-catalog/animals-nutrition/index.html http://www.heifer.org/gift-catalog/animals-nutrition/index.h... lets you donate the amount for a specific animal to give to a family. I'm not sure if the money ends up getting spread out or is actually used to buy X goats, but it's pretty close to what you're looking for. They're doing exactly what this article calls for too.
- lhopki01 11y agoJust be careful with these "give an animal schemes" Some of these schemes in Niger have lead to massive over grazing by goats and desertification.
- merpnderp 11y agoHow would you find this individual? You'd need some sort of organization to run a vetting process to find someone who is optimal for your criteria. Just that first step makes the process fairly expensive. Which is why charities exist.
- gadders 11y agoI wasn't arguing against any charities being involved, just a change to the model. I.E a combination of Watsi and the BRAC mentioned in the article.
- cgh 11y agoA good alternative might be to take $1000 worth of food to the local food bank. You don't need to look abroad if you want to make a difference in the lives of the poor.
- gadders 11y agoI would say that the condition of people in a food bank in the UK would be a couple of orders of magnitude better than widowed women in rural India.
- apercu 11y agoSure, but don't discount what he's saying. If you help your community get back on its feet, then fewer tax dollars need to go in to your community to support it. This might lead to additional governmental foreign aid. At least once a year (I wish I did it more often) I donate food to the local food banks.
- rdancer 11y agoThe operative word is "PPP-adjusted". Bangladesh has a PPP exchange rate of 30 cents on a dollar, so you only need to send $300.
- sog777 11y agoI don't know of a way to give directly to an individual, but I know of Zidisha[0] where you can lend directly. [0] https://www.zidisha.org/ https://www.zidisha.org/