3 ms·
Though I wouldn't have guessed it earlier this year, this seems like a bygone conclusion. Last night I tried out the iPad Pro for the first time while killing t
by danso 11y ago
Though I wouldn't have guessed it earlier this year, this seems like a bygone conclusion. Last night I tried out the iPad Pro for the first time while killing time at an Apple Store...I liked it, though I've had an iPad since it first came out so there's much less of that revelatory experience with each iteration. The store had the iPad Pros set up with the keyboard cases and I've never used my iPads with a keyboard so I was delightfully surprised that my favorite OS X shortcut -- Cmd-Tab -- worked for application switching. Unfortunately, none of the other shortcuts I'm used to worked, such as Cmd-T to open a new tab in the browser, and so forth.
In a way, the iPad Pro felt like tablet's version of the uncanny valley...close to "real" computing but not annoyingly not quite enough...unless major overhauls are made to iOS, and every application built on it thus far, I couldn't imagine using the iPad for anything more than media consumption. And when I think about it, I hardly ever use the iPad for any app that is iPad-only -- I use it mostly for web browsing, reading, and Netflix-watching -- things I can switch effortlessly to on my Macbook.
I had thought the Surface was doomed to fail, in trying to serve both as a tablet and as a regular computer and screwing up both...but in retrospect, it seems like the intuitive strategy. Most tablet functionality is purely a subset of what a regular laptop can do...and attempts to port OSX apps to iOS have rarely resulted in something that was better as a native tablet app. Adding to this, the majority of the computing world is already entrenched in Windows applications...even as someone who has been almost exclusively OS X for the last 10 years, my next tablet purchase will probably be a Surface...doing productive work on Excel and Windows-versions of Sublime Text is better than attempting it on iOS by far.
edit: And maybe familiarity breeds contempt -- and/or I'm entering in my tech-curmudgeon phase...but besides the initial iterations on multi-touch -- two fingers to scroll, pinching, stretching, rotation -- I've been less than inspired by iOS's innovations in touch gestures. In fact, I find myself frequently fighting against accidental actions, such as how dragging my fingers a little lazily to the left while reading a webpage triggers the browser's Back action. And how I'm frequently accidentally activating my Slack app (because it's the only one I have that has multitasking?) when my fingers do something on the right side of the browser. I feel we've reached the limits of what we can intuitively express via finger-motion gestures and if Surface's tablet functionality had far fewer of them...that would actually be a net positive for me.
- mhurron 11y ago> I had thought the Surface was doomed to fail I just bought one, so it probably will soon.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- AJ007 11y agoI had the Surface 2 & 3 as primary mobile computer devices. The 2 I used a year, the 3 less than a month due to a problem which may or may not have been a defect. There should be some historical posts on hn where I was wrote that I was shocked how great the 2 was. Now I'm 100% iPhone - iPad Pro - 2015 Macbook. Anything that requires heavy processor power is done through remote servers. From a security and privacy standpoint I feel a little bit better with Apple than Google/Android. Microsoft I don't know enough about at this current point in time to make a judgement call on. With an iOS or Android device you can remote in to a Windows, Linux, or OSX desktop. Every year things have become visibly better and easier to use. Much of the biggest stuff is cross platform. If you use Adobe Creative Cloud you can jump from Windows to OS X with no license switching issues. Many other companies have followed. Years back I attempted to go ultra mobile with a Fujitsu U810 (convertible where the whole computer was about the size of your hand.) Watching the transitions since then, today things feel very mature. Back then if I tried using that thing I could work at about 1/20th speed. Now I'm desktop speed (my last desktop had 3x 27" screens.) The high DPI mobile screens help a massive amount. You have to tweak your workflows and find the right apps. Sometimes small things can be a big problem, such as a keyboard shortcut not working right when you are remoted in through a tablet. Te device matters less and less. It is now much more about weight, battery life, heat output, and stability (not crashing when you pick it up weird, which the Surface did to me often.)
- e28eta 11y agocmd-t does open a new tab in Safari, and the other major shortcuts I'm used to from desktop Safari also work: reload (r), location bar (l), back/forward ([/]), previous/next tab ({/}), find (f), close (w). I do agree it's frustrating that there isn't parity (yet?), but I've been working my way through the Advent of Code with my iPad Pro and Coda, and have been reasonably happy with the experience.