6 ms·
Pretty cool. One of the more interesting things about fusion research is how the expansion of the ability to do complex fluid dynamics has helped design plasma
by ChuckMcM 11y ago
Pretty cool. One of the more interesting things about fusion research is how the expansion of the ability to do complex fluid dynamics has helped design plasma flows. Such designs were computationally infeasible before. The inter-related requirement of computation and understanding on the delivery of viable fusion solutions has been, in my opinion, the unseen anchor of fusion.
- noobermin 11y agoI think people know this, they just don't want to admit it. As someone who works with people who used to work with ICF, I've been told the reason that NIF flunked is that it was designed with 1D simulation codes because back then, that's all they could manage. One of the issues they inevitably ran into were plasma instabilities similar to Rayleigh-Taylor instabilities[0] that one only sees in two (or more) dimensional systems, but not 1D. These instabilities reduce the efficacy of heating and compression needed to achieve ignition, and were an unpleasant surprise when they actually performed the experiments. Even to this day, 2D simulations are fairly common and littered throughout the literature, and their justification (arguments of approximate symmetry) are suspect, at least to me. 3D sims are coming on the scene, but they often have to sacrifice things like spatial resolution that hurt's the simulation's physics in other way. Computational feasibility is one of the things physicists in that field need to admit is holding them back, and may be a little humility in seeking out advice from computer scientists is warranted in my opinion[1]. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rayleigh%E2%80%93Taylor_instability https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rayleigh%E2%80%93Taylor_instab... [1] this statement won't give me much criticism here, but it wouldn't go down well in a room of my peers.
- jessriedel 11y agoHonest question: do you really think talking much with computer scientists would help? My impression is that most of the improvements (besides Moore's law) in the power of simulation of physical systems has come from either new physical insights, or computational insights developed by physicists who were mostly self-taught numerical techniques. It seems very plausible to me that there are honest-to-goodness CS insights that remain unexploited, such as better parallelizing physical simulations, but the track record hasn't been good. Why aren't CS people coming in and showing everyone how it should be done? (For what it's worth, I'm a physicist, but not one who does anything numerical, and I'm happy to admit arrogance by physicists could be a problem here.)
- Retric 11y agoIt's not all about algorithms. Unless current simulations are running on Asics or even GPU's there are probably 10-1,000+x speedups possible.
- bsder 11y agoWhy do you assume that the computational fluid dynamics folks are dumb and haven't done this? CFD is a very vibrant field with applications across the entire spectrum of engineering. In fact, modern supercomputers are MOSTLY running CFD codes (weather prediction is effectively a gigantic CFD simulation). Nothing else really demands that level of power.
- Retric 11y agoI know some CFD is still run on CPU's and some is run on GPU's. But, I don't know what the fusion tradeoffs are.
- xixi77 11y agoI'm quite sure a good number of these are running partly on GPU's. People are quite aware of them; their practical use in research applications is still a bit limited because of how often the code needs to be modified -- but in industry where the same basic model is run over and over they (as well as FPGA's) are pretty common. Not every computational application is the same :)
- rickycook 11y agowell, it's not the job of a physicist to understand the many many different sorting algorithms, how to optimise loops so they are cached in the cpu, and plenty more. I guarantee that most CS professionals (CS; not necessarily developers) are able to write much more efficient code than most professional physicists, because they spent the same amount of time understanding software and hardware that these guys spent building a fusion reactor. that said, considering the billions that have been spent on fusion research, I doubt they did it in a bubble. it would seem strange if they didn't enlist the help of some CS
- PhasmaFelis 11y ago> Even to this day, 2D simulations are fairly common and littered throughout the literature, and their justification (arguments of approximate symmetry) are suspect, at least to me. 3D sims are coming on the scene, but they often have to sacrifice things like spatial resolution that hurt's the simulation's physics in other way. Sounds like the joke about the guy who dropped his keys in the bushes but is looking for them under the streetlamp, because there's light there so they should be easier to find.