4 ms·
Whenever a statistical report uses averages (and no medians anywhere), I always look for a sample size, since it gives an indicator on the potential variation f
by minimaxir 11y ago
Whenever a statistical report uses averages (and no medians anywhere), I always look for a sample size, since it gives an indicator on the potential variation for the true average. (Error is inversely proportional to square root of sample size)
So I checked the methodology and found something odd.
> The salaries included reflect more than 80,000 interview requests and job offers from the past year
Why are interview requests and job offers lumped together? Wouldn't there be disproportionally more interviews by definition? As a result, it's very hard to gauge the sample size of the salary data.
- avitzurel 11y agoI also believe it's skewed by the fact that it's only using the Hired platform and not including focused head-hunting of more senior people. The numbers are more or less the same anywhere when you look at averages, if you look at glassdoor for bay area it's likely the same.
- jonny_eh 11y agoThe way Hired works, an "interview request" is sent once by an employer to a potential candidate (along with a potential salary). If the candidate accepts, then they may interview many times with the employer and eventually get a final offer. (I work at Hired)
- YokoZar 11y agoWe're only interested in the salaries of the jobs we actually take. Final offers will be negotiated upward from the interview request. Interview requests where the candidate (or company) don't proceed won't. So why use interview requests in the data at all? The fact that some joker company offered me 90k on hired when everyone else was offering 130+ shouldn't pull the average down.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- berkeleyjess 11y agoHi my name is Jessica and I am the data scientist at Hired who pulled the numbers for this report. The way the Hired platform works is that companies must submit an initial salary offer when they start the interview process, and so all interview requests have salaries attached to them. Of course these offers can be negotiated later, but for the vast majority of our hires on the platform, the final base salary is equal to or higher than the initial offer given at the interview stage. Therefore we feel confident that this salary data is representative (if not a slight underestimate) on 2015 salaries for software engineers.
- fapjacks 11y agoGive me a break. I have been using Hired for almost two years and everybody knows that number is made-up bullshit. It means nothing and everybody knows it!! You're slanting the numbers to make Hired more attractive. I love Hired. The company has totally changed my life for the better, and I could not be happier using it, but this is BS, and anybody that's used the platform knows this number that accompanies interview requests is almost nonsequitur to what actually happens.
- pc86 11y agoUnnecessarily rude and combative. Flagged.
- fapjacks 11y agoWell, sometimes the truth hurts.
- berkeleyjess 11y agoThis is Jessica, Data Scientist at Hired again... I'm glad you've had a great experience on Hired and that it has changed your life for the better. I'm surprised that your experience is that the initial salary offers (at the interview request stage) are significantly different than your final salary offer, because I can tell you that this is not the experience of most people on our platform. The majority of the final salary offers are equal to or greater than the offer given at the interview request stage. On average the final salary offers are slightly higher than the interview request offers across all Software Engineering Hires on the Hired platform.
- sytelus 11y agoActually median also a not good metric when power laws are involved. For example, if half of the country is living below poverty line then you being above median still doesn't mean you have comfortable lifestyle. Tech people are often told that they have top 10% of salaries in the country but when you look at most of their lifestyles (i.e. below 1%), they are living in cramped apartments, doing 2+ hour commutes, reluctantly sending kids to schools they don't like etc etc. When most of the people in country have minimum wage below $10, even median would be pulled too low and that is one reason poverty line is defined such a way that these people don't come under it.