4 ms·
How much could they grow? It's not clear to me, unless they suddenly have much more ambitious plans and new categories of product, how big the market is that ca
by azinman2 11y ago
How much could they grow? It's not clear to me, unless they suddenly have much more ambitious plans and new categories of product, how big the market is that can sustain infinite growth over time for them. The market is very specialized for them, and if they try going after non tech their products directly then go up against many other players already entrenched (and it's not like JIRA is some shiny beacon of ease and apple-like perceived simplicity -- if they rebuilt from scratch maybe they'd have a better chance)
- utnick 11y agoHipchat can grow a lot, I really think every organization, tech or not, will eventually start using a tool like hipchat or slack.
- dmihal 11y agoSlack is starting to become popular with student groups at my university. Definitely has a wide range of potential users.
- buro9 11y agoWhen Slack self-hosted is a possibility, Hipchat is dead in the water. That's the only reason to use Hipchat today, and the Slack experience is an order of magnitude better.
- the_mitsuhiko 11y ago> When Slack self-hosted is a possibility, Hipchat is dead in the water. I think Slack put some pressure on the Hipchat team but there is plenty of stuff that is highly problematic for how Slack is set up at the moment. In particular even for small teams it can become incredibly hard to see what's happening and the integrations either spam too much or are too useless once it becomes a bit more crowded in a room.
- el_duderino 11y agoIs it me or is the hosted version of HipChat really unstable the past two or three months?
- joshstrange 11y agoHipchat Connect takes a HUGE step forward in completing with Slack and I prefer integration over a few flashy features. Yes you can integrate with Slack but my company has bought into Atlassian and it's quite wonderful...
- steeef 11y agoYou're forgetting the price: Paid Slack accounts start at $6.67/user, HipChat $2/user. That's a very big difference for even a medium-sized business.
- latj 11y agoIsnt self hosted slack IRC?
- klodolph 11y agoMy impression is that they're after dominance and becoming utterly entrenched, and that they've got a pretty good shot at it. They've had stellar growth over the past couple years. They currently strike a good balance between "creating value" and "extracting value", from a business perspective. Compare to older companies, like Oracle, which are much more focused on extracting value. They're also used both in startups and in established firms, which makes me feel confident about their growth.
- hitekker 11y agoConfluence is used quite a bit internally at Oracle and given the extent of the company's usage, I wouldn't be surprised if they're making a killing off it and other enterprises.
- jozzas 11y agoMy employer (large financial institution, 15000+ employees) uses confluence and jira enterprise-wide, as well as others that are more developer-centric. I'd say we're paying some of their bills on our own.
- shostack 11y agoYou bring up a really good point around adding vs. extracting value. There are definitely a few well-known large enterprise software companies that seem almost entirely focused on the extraction side once they reach a certain scale and level of entrenchment. To me that seems like a sign they are ready for new competition, but I really wonder what the mindset is like internally once an org makes that kind of shift.
- the_mitsuhiko 11y ago> How much could they grow? I don't see that there is a limit to how far they can grow. They are expanding their user base, they are constantly making or buying new products into their portfolio and they know how to sell and support it.
- troycarlson 11y agoThe JIRA integrations with things like HipChat, Bitbucket, Bamboo, etc. are incredibly valuable for their customers from day 1. Competitors can't offer that level of integration right away and chipping away at one product category will be harder when companies like Atlassian offer well integrated products in suites or ala carte.
- dstaheli 11y agoVisual Studio Team Services is just as good at this.
- el_duderino 11y agoThe SSO integration they're currently implementing will be a nice addition.
- sp4rki 11y agoTheir products are general enough to be easily customized by a couple of devs (or even only one) for very specific use cases. They're also easily integrated with market leading erp software. Companies that already use it for development departments might very well use it to manage most of their operations under a single umbrella application by linking multiple instances.
- osivertsson 11y agoDo you, or anyone else, have personal experience with customizing Atlassian's products? The customizations I've seen at rather big companies have required multiple devs, many months, and the end result has had some rough edges. From what I've seen it is also non-trivial to scale their products to say orgs with 500+ active users, granted my experience here is a few years back.
- sp4rki 11y agoYep, we have a junior dev working on customization and integration with SAP. She needs help every once so I sometimes help her out with the more complicated stuff, but in general she comes out with pretty robust code and the integrations and customizations work as they should.
- modoc 11y agoWe have just under 2,000 users in our JIRA, Confluence, Bamboo ecosystem. Customizing things like ticket types and workflows is obviously just point and click. We've also created custom reports, and Jelly based custom event triggers and actions with one untrained person. I guess it depends on the nature of what you're trying to do, but we've found it very easy to customize and integrate.
- serge2k 11y agoYour post seems ridiculous to me. They are a profitable company with a solid portfolio of products and you suggest that they are failures unless they do a complete re-write of one of their biggest products?
- azinman2 11y agoI didn't say they're failures. I said how far can they grow? When you go public, you have a legal obligation to your shareholders to make more money next quarter until the end of time. I'm questioning how big they can get with their current products... when they start trying to get into different industries that are already using Oracle, Salesforce, SAP, etc, how will they compete?
- GFischer 11y agoTheir biggest customers are large companies that DON'T want apple-like perceived simplicity - they want a powerful product that they can customize to their needs. The company I work for has both JIRA and Confluence. It took a lot of work from several team members to get it to the current state where most people are happy about how it works, but the output is very highly valued by higher-ups. It also has a growing ecosystem and good integration. They've also made some underrated acquisitions, like the JITSI team (Blue Jimp), which recently made ENSO and is working on Hipchat https://enso.me/ https://enso.me/
- cm2012 11y agoTheir market is very similar to that of Salesforce, which is showing very few signs of slowing (and had a 52B market cap).
- duaneb 11y ago> apple-like perceived simplicity Jira's a workhorse, not a consumer device. If Atlassian went with "apple-like perceived simplicity" their product would probably be terrible for most of their users (enterprise customers) who want customizability and integrations over prescribed use cases.