4 ms·
That will change when Chip & Pin are common. Instead of just swiping, yes, yes, done, it will be inserting the card into the reader, the reader fails to read th
by Someone1234 11y ago
That will change when Chip & Pin are common. Instead of just swiping, yes, yes, done, it will be inserting the card into the reader, the reader fails to read the chip, spitting on it, then trying again, and finally entering the pin and yes, yes, done.
Don't misunderstand, chip & pin is something the US has long since needed. But the chips are unreliable and entering a pin on some terminals is annoying. A phone with NFC might be easier than that, just fingerprint to unlock, and then press a single button on the phone.
- riffraff 11y agoAs a european who has always had chip cards, it has never happened to me[0] that the reader failed to read the chip. Granted, I don't use the card very often, but I would say in the last 10 ten years I have probably used it a few hundred times. Chip & signature, is usually slower. OTOH, NFC credit cards are now also becoming more common in europe too, i.e. https://www.visa.co.uk/products/visa-contactless/ https://www.visa.co.uk/products/visa-contactless/ http://www.mastercard.com/contactless/ http://www.mastercard.com/contactless/ [0] EDIT: it might have happened and I can't remember it, which is effectively the same thing in context.
- Someone1234 11y agoYou assume too much. I am from the UK, and the chip failing to read is a common occurrence, and some readers are well known bad (e.g. the cashier will be like "yeah it has been doing that all day" as you spit and polish the chip contacts). But I do use my card(s) a great deal. So much so that the contacts on the chip are changing from gold to brown.
- amyjess 11y agoYeah, thanks to your post, I'm not looking forward to chips becoming more popular in the US. I've never had a problem with a card reader not properly reading swipes or the magnetic strip wearing down. Only times I've had a swipe fail has been when I mis-swiped the card, and that's entirely on my own klutziness, not any kind of mechanical failure. The future shouldn't be worse than the present, but it looks like that's the road we're going down...
- jessaustin 11y agoI've never had a problem with a card reader not properly reading swipes or the magnetic strip wearing down. Although it seems less common over the last several years (perhaps because now physical cards are often replaced several times before they nominally expire?), this used to be a serious problem. The most common fix for a read failure was to put the card inside a plastic grocery bag, pull the bag tight, and then reswipe it. I have no idea how this fixed anything, but I witnessed it working many times.
- asherkin 11y agoOnce you've worn the contacts away you can hardly call them contacts any more (and it's unsurprising they fail regularly). Cashiers will also say that even if they've never seen another card fail to read :P it's to make you feel better.
- Someone1234 11y ago> Cashiers will also say that even if they've never seen another card fail to read :P it's to make you feel better. My mum is a cachier. It is a constant headache where she works. Some tills the staff avoid using until last because the reader sucks so bad. But, to you, C&P is an infallible technology that doesn't comfort to our normal rules of physics, so I'm sure nothing will convince you.
- diegomsana 11y agoA gentle lady on the cashier once took card out of my hands and rubbed on her hair. It worked lol.
- michaelcampbell 11y agoIf you can find them anymore (and care enough), the pink pencil erasers are good too; they are very slightly abrasive, but not so much as to remove a layer of metal.
- pbreit 11y agoYou might be right. Chip & sign is pretty bad. Chip & PIN is awful.
- asib 11y agoSwipe is very rare in the UK - Chip & Pin is the norm, at least it used to be. Contactless cards were introduced relatively recently, where you just tap and go - no verification required (as such there's a limit on the amount you can pay using contactless). These are very speedy, I think more so than Apple pay, and are becoming increasingly popular. In London (and possibly other places in the UK, I'm unsure) they have actually integrated contactless card readers into public transport, meaning you can hop on a bus/tube and pay for the journey with your card. Essentially, you can carry around a single card to commute, buy your lunch, go shopping and everything else.
- jaddison 11y agoChip & Pin and Contactless are commonplace in Canada as well at stores. Not all have it, but most get it as they upgrade their systems.
- Nullabillity 11y agoHonestly, contactless cards, and this push to merge a few of the cards, kind of terrify me. I already carry around my driver's license. I already carry around the access card to my school. I already carry around my student ID. I already carry around 3 different library cards. I already carry around my public transport card. I already carry around my debit card. I already carry around cash. Even if you remove a few of those I still need to carry my wallet with me, so what difference does it make? I mean, other than the loss of separation of identities that comes with the territory. It's fine that my public transport card has low security, because you can't cash it out easily, and it only carries a very limited value anyway. Neither of those apply to my debit card.
- davnicwil 11y agoBut with a pretty low limit on daily spend with the contactless card, it effectively has limited value too - assuming you'd cancel it within 24 hours of it being lost or stolen in most cases - and is therefore difficult to 'cash out' on for a thief. So actually both do apply to your contactless debit card, really. Actually there's likely more incentive to pickpocket a wallet for its cash contents, rather than the contactless card(s), given in a lot of wallets this will be both greater and, by definition of course, easier to cash out on! So it seems like carrying contactless cards doesn't add any particular incentive for theft above what has existed forever with carrying cash. Also, any other security vulnerabilities with the debit card, unrelated to contactless, still exist exactly as they do today. So, it seems to me that merging cards, i.e. adding contactless and the ability to use it for transport, and other things, seems to just add marginal convenience with essentially no added risk of theft or fraud[1]. So yes, it's not a life-changing technology and it won't mean you no longer have to carry a wallet, but it represents a small win and certainly a step improvement for everyday convenience, so that's good right? I for one simply think the fewer cards I have to carry, the better, to be honest. [1] though I have, to be fair, heard about the issue of thieves 'skimming' contactless cards in people's pockets, I don't know if that was always just a scare story or if it's actually a real exploitable vulnerability - but this seems likely to be a pretty far-flung edge case anyway.
- Nullabillity 11y agoIn the 5 years I've had a C&P card I've had it fail approximately once.
- Someone1234 11y agoI've had it for 8-9 years in the UK and I've had it failed many many times. More than I can count on both hands. The chips wear out, the readers wear out, the two get dirty, etc. it is a common nuisance, just ask any cashier.
- Nullabillity 11y agoSounds like your card is about to expire then, anyway.
- Someone1234 11y agoI am talking about multiple cards. I had at least four in that time.
- amyjess 11y ago> That will change when Chip & Pin are common. Chip & PIN is not coming to the US. Chip & sign, yes, but no PINs.
- smackfu 11y agoThe readers I've seen in the US are a bit slow. And sometimes you run into ones where you insert your card and then the clerk says "that's not turned on yet", but that will shake itself out. Haven't seen any issues with bad reads.
- patmcc 11y agoCanada has transitioned mostly to chip and pin (anecdotally, 95% of debit transactions I've done lately), and I've seen a really low failure rate on my cards. I can think of once in the last year I got chip errors on the reader.
- jholman 11y agoI'm Canadian. I've never had a mechanical failure on chip&pin. A friend of mine seems to have failures constantly at a certain liquor store; dunno if it's the debit card she's using, or the store's reader, or both. But back when we used mag stripes, I used to see failures all the time. The anecdata in my life says chip&pin is FAR more reliable.
- ersii 11y agoI use my bank/credit card often, which is Chip&PIN/EMV. I have never had a problem with any of my cards in that way, ie. the reader being clunky and failing to contact the card. I have however worn out a card that has been in use for a couple of years. I would beg to differ that the chips are unreliable. Other solutions might be easier, don't know about that though.