5 ms·
Can't help but thinking the Amazon affiliate link to the Kindle is tacky and lame. It's hidden by a URL redirector, and only disclosed at the end (the second ti
by staunch 17y ago
Can't help but thinking the Amazon affiliate link to the Kindle is tacky and lame. It's hidden by a URL redirector, and only disclosed at the end (the second time it's used).
I also can't help but thinking that this is not a friendly warning to others, but simply one more attempt to finally get something out of B&N by causing a public fuss.
Call me Mr. Cynical.
- chaosmachine 17y agoThe link says "buy a kindle". It's pretty obvious where the link goes. Why would you care if he gets commission on it?
- sh1mmer 17y agoHe also refers at the beginning of the article to his Kindle hacking. He's clearly into that.
- kmt 17y agoPrincipally, you care because you might have been manipulated into reading an article with a catchy name just so the author can make some sales. That said, most likely this particular post is a genuine complaint plus an opportunistic idea.
- SwellJoe 17y agoPrincipally, you care because you might have been manipulated into reading an article with a catchy name just so the author can make some sales. If it weren't someone that we all know, then that might be an issue. But Jesse has been around the hacker and entrepreneurial community for a long time, and has a reputation to uphold. If you've been to OSCON, YAPC, etc. you've probably seen him speak and possibly met him. He's not some random dude trying to cash in on this new-fangled Internet thing.
- kmt 17y agoCertainly. In a previous life (10 years ago) I've been a user (and a hacker) of RT. So I know the guy, which is why I said this is most likely genuine.
- chrischen 17y agoBecause in the grand scheme of things people getting commissions will ultimately increase the price of things for me. It's also up to me to decide whether or not he deserves commission. Perhaps I already wanted to buy a Kindle beforehand.
- indiejade 17y agoThere's a big difference between writing that: (A) Calls a company out on poor product or customer service, and writing that: (B) Diverts or directs audience to a specific competitor. The "specific competitor" part is what makes this article reek of something suspicious. [edit] I mean human-generated writing, of course. . .
- spicyj 17y agoWhy do you care whether he gets a commission on the sale of a Kindle? If you want to buy a Kindle, and he influenced you in your choice, shouldn't he get credit for that. Seems to me that everything seems okay, unless you're suggesting that he made up the story in order to get people to buy Kindles, which seems unlikely to me.
- staunch 17y agoI'm not saying I'm right to find it tacky/lame, but nothing requires that he made up the story to sell Kindles. It could be simply that he decided this article might get a lot of attention, and decided to try to capitalize on it.
- obrajesse 17y agostaunch, So, that's my blog post. The "Buy a Kindle!" links were very much a last-minute addition. My thought process was really more one of "It'd be nice to steer more cash away from this vendor who pissed me off." The "Oh. There is delicious irony in getting the $100 I was 'owed' by referring people away from B&N" thought came embarrassingly late. My intent in ranting about B&N's poor customer service was to shame them into fixing it or losing customers. By a strict interpretation of your words, yes, I totally realized that my blog post might get attention and decided to capitalize on it. I don't expect a whole lot, though. The number of Kindles people bought via links from my blog post puts the hourly rate for the time I spent on Savory and the other opensourcy Kindle hacking I did last year at about....what I'd earn working the drive-through line at Wendy's.
- daeken 17y agoThis is largely off-topic, but thank you for the work you've done. Hacking the Kindle is by no means glamorous or easy, and it's good to see someone doing it. Keep up the good work.
- _pius 17y agono offense to you staunch, but I've gotta be honest, I'm starting to get really annoyed about people bitching every time someone puts an affiliate link up. Who cares?? It's clearly marked, nothing deceptive about it at all. Complaining about affiliate links is becoming a cliché, like complaining about dupes.
- staunch 17y agoI just think there's a right way and wrong way to do it. 1) Do disclose it at the time you use the link 2) Don't obscure the URL with a URL redirector. 3) Don't contrive reasons to put put affiliate ads into your content.
- chollida1 17y agoThe link code isn't hidden. You can clearly see the "tag=fsck-20", which means an affiliate link, just by hovering over the link.