9 ms·
‘Serial’ Season 2 Lets Bowe Bergdahl Tell His Side of Afghan Story
- leroy_masochist 11y agoJust listened to the first episode. It's very good and Bergdahl's narrative is fascinating. According to him, he had deep grievances with his battalion leadership, and decided to leave his combat outpost, run 20 miles back to FOB Sharana, thereby creating a Dust 1 (missing servicemember in theater), get everyone's attention that way, then use the debrief as an opportunity to blow the whistle on his chain of command. I'm really looking forward to hearing the rest of the series, especially the exploration of the command culture at his unit.
- jszymborski 11y agohe seems to admit very early on that what he'd done was partly fuelled by a desire to seem like a "super-solider", like Jason Borne. You can tell quickly he's being exceedingly candid and though he maintains that he did what he did on principle, there was misguided thought along the way. If this is just the surface of it all, then this is going to be a fun ride.
- uptown 11y ago"If this is just the surface of it all, then this is going to be a fun ride." Six soldiers were reportedly killed searching for Bergdahl, and five Taliban members were exchanged for him in-trade. None of that is what I'd describe as "fun".
- eric_h 11y agoHe's referring, of course, to the reporting of it in the Serial podcast. Not much of what was described in the first series of Serial was "fun" either. Nevertheless, the podcast was compelling and quite entertaining.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- mr_luc 11y agoA well-researched post elsewhere[1] on this page makes the claims of soldiers being killed out to be pretty suspect. ---- [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10712211 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10712211
- cdcarter 11y agoOf course, we don't know if that Jason Borne conversation happened very early in the tapes or much later, and was just reported in the first episode.
- DarkTree 11y agoJust to clarify (because I had to look it up), it's actually DUSTWUN and stands for 'duty status - whereabouts unknown' https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DUSTWUN https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DUSTWUN
- tokenadult 11y agoAccording to him, he had deep grievances with his battalion leadership, and decided to leave his combat outpost, run 20 miles back to FOB Sharana, thereby creating a Dust 1 (missing servicemember in theater), get everyone's attention that way And that, of course, was very dangerous to his comrades[1] and irresponsible, and doesn't seem to have achieved his objective, since he was captured by the Taliban along the way. It's probably quite difficult being a commander in a combat zone with special snowflake soldiers like this in the unit. [1] "Two soldiers died while searching for Bergdahl." http://www.newsweek.com/serial-season-2-interview-bowe-bergdahl-403429 http://www.newsweek.com/serial-season-2-interview-bowe-bergd...
- thieving_magpie 11y agoReally depends on where you look. Several outlets are stating 6 people died[1], some say just 2, some say nobody died. Fox news sometimes initially claimed it was 2, then later 6. Occasionally they (media outlets, not just Fox) point out that people died while searching for Bergdahl while off-duty... so how that gets attributed to his search I have no idea [2]. In testimony, two officers part of the search testified saying nobody died.[3] It's sad how politicized this has become. Even Fox news concedes "The official said the two soldiers in Bergdahl’s unit who died were in a combat outpost that was attacked. The official said it was impossible to prove a link between their deaths and Bergdahl's disappearance. In addition, investigators have determined that some of the other eight soldiers were killed while driving a logistic delivery to the base, and likely would have been doing so regardless of the search." [2, same source] [1] http://nation.foxnews.com/2015/03/26/these-are-us-soldiers-who-died-searching-bowe-bergdahl http://nation.foxnews.com/2015/03/26/these-are-us-soldiers-w... [2] http://www.foxnews.com/politics/2014/06/06/two-soldiers-from-bergdahl-unit-killed-while-search-was-ongoing-pentagon-finds.html http://www.foxnews.com/politics/2014/06/06/two-soldiers-from... [3] http://www.stripes.com/closing-statements-should-bergdahl-be-court-martialed-or-are-charges-too-harsh-1.368874 http://www.stripes.com/closing-statements-should-bergdahl-be...
- MrZongle2 11y agoEven if no soldiers perished in the search for Bergdahl, it clearly was a dangerous, hostile environment. The planned 20-mile trip back to FOB Sharana wasn't just a day hike, and Bergdahl was either a fool or indifferent to the dangers it posed to both him and the individuals who would come looking for him.
- sigzero 11y ago> I'm really looking forward to hearing the rest of the series, especially the exploration of the command culture at his unit. What you get is probably going to be severely skewed to his point of view.
- mikehearn 11y agoSerial only has one season on which to base its reputation, but thus far it seems exceptionally adept at not picking sides. The case in season one was polarizing, but Serial did an admirable job of presenting all sides and not making overt attempts to push audience opinion in any particular direction. I'm hoping this season has the same balance.
- xsmasher 11y agoI felt like the last half of season one spent its time poking holes in the prosecution's case, and none poking at the defense / defendant. Mileage varies.
- ejstronge 11y agoI think that was the thesis of that season - what was the nature of the evidence used to convict someone to life in prison.
- andrewliebchen 11y agoIt's not the media's job to give equal time to "both sides" on an issue or be "balanced." I trust Serial, based on the exhaustive reporting of their first story, will do a fine job exploring this story.
- xsmasher 11y agoI didn't say serial SHOULD give equal time. I just disagreed with an opinion that they DID give equal time.
- gnud 11y ago
- Falcon9 11y agoI've never been in the military, but my understanding is that you don't get deployed without knowing better. I'll take Bergdahl at his word with regards to his intentions, but it's still an incredible reckless and irresponsible thing to do. He's lucky to be alive.
- EliRivers 11y agoFrom my own military experiences, I would not be at all surprised to find people deployed with deficiencies in equipment, training and oversight.
- BryantD 11y agoSome reporting indicates that Bergdahl's unit was riddled with this kind of problem: http://www.rollingstone.com/politics/news/americas-last-prisoner-of-war-20120607 http://www.rollingstone.com/politics/news/americas-last-pris...
- stvswn 11y agoNothing there surprises me -- some of it is just the kind of bitching soldiers do (like complaining that everyone has to stop what they're doing to look for a rifle, or complaining that NTC was hot, or that the 1SG is nuts and mean and yells a lot, or that you had to guard a broken down vehicle for 5 days... ). Some of it showed a lack of discipline in the unit (NCOs allowing Soldiers to wear baseball caps) -- but Bowe seems to feel like those relaxed NCOs were the "good guys" that got replaced. The Rolling Stone article tries to act like Bowe snapped under stress, which is not at all what he's saying in Serial. He'd only been in Afghanistan for 3 months, and the Serial podcast said that he hadn't seen any real action yet (Rolling Stone talks about combat he was in). The vast majority of his complaints are par for the course in the Army -- mass punishment and the constant feeling like the higher command is stringing you along. It's, like, what the Army's all about. As you gain in rank and your perspective widens, you end up being the person who makes some PFC spend 5 days guarding an MRAP, and you just shift your hatred to the next level up the chain. Bitching about the higher headquarters that is just one level above your visibility is what people do in the Army.
- alaskamiller 11y agoKid wants to be a hero, understandable, sometimes kids join the military having been groomed on cartoons and cereal then realize the military culture isn't like GI JOE. State of mind for him was to expose corruption, again, laudable. From his narrative he attributes previous deaths in his unit to said corruption. Life is at stake. So kid decides to trigger the most extensive exception in the active theater, attracting the immediate attention of his unit, area command, the air force, the navy, and the marines. Now the reveal is the narrative is kid quixote but the conclusion--after exploring the why--is going to hinge on the critical question: was it worth it? He survived. He has the stage he sought after. What was the message he needs to deliver? Spoiler: Probably not, Berghdal is still active duty in Texas.
- stvswn 11y agoNo, I think he was attributing potential future deaths to poor leadership -- at the time of his capture, only one soldier in his larger unit (battalion level) had died -- 1LT Brian Bradshaw. This wasn't in his platoon or company.
- jeremysmyth 11y agoSpoiler: Probably not, Berghdal is still active duty in Texas. One of the functions and outcomes of great investigative reporting is to find facts that aren't already visible. The first series of Serial apparently resulted in Syed being granted a new hearing—his post-conviction hearings were re-opened by the appeals court last month, and he will get a new day in court some time soon. There's a chance that the reporting in this new series of episodes might result in a similar change in outcome or circumstance.
- fapjacks 11y agoNah, that guy is a shitbag. You know, I had shit leadership during all of my tours, but you didn't see me walking off the FOB like a dick. It's the US Army... You are going to have shit leadership.
- Uhhrrr 11y agoAre you going to listen to the whole series?
- stevewillows 11y agoFor someone with some experience with 'shit leadership', your input would be interesting as the story unfolds.
- regnull 11y agoI was surprised that the journalists didn't drill into "terrible situation in his unit" claims. They just let it slide completely - and this is the key to the whole story. Why the situation was so bad? Also, I found his story full of WTFs - he's afraid to go back to his base after his escape, but then he decides to go and capture some bad guys (armed only with knife), but then he just surrenders to a bunch of taliban who somehow manage to locate him walking in the middle of the desert at night. I was really disappointed in this episode, they just left lots of BS unchallenged.
- DarkTree 11y agoI mean, but that's what the rest of the season is for right? This episode was merely a setup in order to describe the event/scenario, and we can only presume that the next episodes will dive more into detail to dissect the situation. The event already happened, we know what happened start to finish. It is precisely the details of 'why' that this season is after. And correct me if I'm wrong, but I am pretty sure it was daylight the next morning when they spotted him in the desert.
- regnull 11y agoI hope you are right - but to me it sounds like the "why" question is the key to the whole story, so they need to investigate it first. And they mentioned that in the next episode they will talk about the search efforts. As for the time of day he was captured - I might be wrong, but wasn't he walking it the dark looking for flashlights and listening to radio chatter just before that?
- cdcarter 11y agoYou're indeed wrong. Per the reported story, he got lost in the hills (didn't check his compass for two hours, which Koenig points out is a ... fairly rookie mistake), eventually made it out, but was in open desert by sunrise.
- cookiecaper 11y agoThis is Serial. They devote a full season to each issue and it's supposed to be something controversial that people can discuss and theorize about between episodes. Season 1 was about a murder in Baltimore, and whether the convicted person actually committed this murder or not (still an open question for listeners (not necessarily the justice system), by the way; there wasn't a big reveal of proof one way or the other at the end of the season). I would expect that Bergdahl's narrative will be examined more critically in subsequent episodes.
- stvswn 11y agoI was a platoon leader in the same era and same type of unit with similar experiences as Bergdahl's unit -- although I have no specific knowledge about his story beyond what I've read in the news. My perspective: he's lying like crazy to get an AWOL charge (intended to return) rather than a desertion charge. The first might be a dishonorable discharge, the latter prison time. There are several reasons his story doesn't add up -- the most glaring one is the assertion that this wacky plan was the only way he knew to get the attention of a general officer. All soldiers know about writing their congressman, and Bergdahl in particular seems to be pretty wordly and would have heard about this avenue. Writing your congressman would result in a huge shitstorm for the higher levels. It is a formal step that is taken seriously, believe me, I've had to write formal responses to congressional liason offices. Second, his emails to his parents (which are already public) hint at much more than loyalty for his fellow soldiers in the face of poor leadership. He had concerns about US policy, culture -- I'm not sure how talking to a general officer and blowing the whistle would have made him feel better. I'll add, as others had, it's possible that his chain of command failed in some regard -- and it's very likely that he was exposed to at least one really bad leader during his time, especially at the NCO level. I also can see how someone like him was an outcast in his unit. He was into ballet, he hung out with the Afghans more than he did his own unit -- etc. Infantry platoons aren't really models of tolerance and inclusion in some regards. It's a rough life in general. But -- and this is the important point -- there's an oath involved with military service, and it matters even in the case of bad experiences. This is really, really important when you go to sleep in the middle of a hostile desert and you trust that the person guarding you is doing his duty. I think those without military experience might be thinking that all of the veterans who react to this are just proud of the esprit de corps and have some sort of ethical blindspot -- like Nathan Jessup in "A Few Good Men." In truth, the idea of a soldier abandoning his unit like this is unforgivable because it's a matter of betraying a fundamental idea, which is that even if you personally hate the guts of one of your fellow soldiers, you risk your life for him because that's the only way you might all survive the deployment. I spent a lot of time deployed just hoping that I wouldn't mess up something important and get someone killed. The notion that there is any justification for deliberately abandoning your unit is tough to swallow. I'm going to see what his grievances were from his perspective and then make up my mind -- if he exposes a massacre of civilians, for instance, I might change my mind. I've read his emails to his parents and other articles, though, and it seems in general he thought the other soldiers were assholes, people called him bad names, and he thought that poor judgment was rewarded.