2 ms·
> The "immoral" practices author accuses the Intel are developing favoring compiler and offering low prices and better deals to OEMs. The immoral practices are
by TazeTSchnitzel 11y ago
> The "immoral" practices author accuses the Intel are developing favoring compiler and offering low prices and better deals to OEMs.
The immoral practices are literally bribing OEMs with money, active sabotage in code generation, and selling products below cost.
This isn't merely a "favoring compiler" and "low prices".
> Now, about compilers: Intel have never pretended that Intel compiler is supposed to work just as good with Intel as with other compiler manufacturers. It says so even in the marketing benchmark picture provided with the post.
Of course it's not guaranteed to work super well on AMD chips. But Intel deliberately wrote their compiler to produce code that would behave awfully on AMD processors. The code the Intel compiler generated would usually work fine on AMD (try it!), but it specifically included a check for Intel processors to ensure it didn't.
Also, Intel didn't warn their customers of this. There's a disclaimer that it's not optimised for other vendors' chips, sure, but that's not the same. Of course their compiler wouldn't be quite as efficient for AMD chips (it might not include AMD-only instructions), but they didn't warn customers that the compiler would deliberately only work on Intel chips. Customers who didn't inspect the output of the compiler would have no idea that Intel was sabotaging their application's performance.
> However, author completely glosses over the fact that AMD reverse-engineered Intel's product and released it's clone.
Originally, yes. So did several other companies. So? Clean-room reverse engineering is fine, in fact it's necessary for competition. Companies should not have complete monopolies on a good idea.
AMD's later designs were original, anyway.
- washadjeffmad 11y agoThe compilers sppecifically chose the slowest code paths for non-Intel chips, even when you chose to compile with those features for AMD when using Intel hardware. You can still download those versions to check the results. Also, price fixing was just one tactic used. Intel created exclusive contracts by threatening smaller chip makers with supporting their competitors if they shared technology with AMD, then later removed their products from their chipsets. Intel wasn't just trying to hurt AMD, they were systemmatically grooming a weakened marketplace that they could more easily dominate.
- spronkey 11y agoIntel brings such conflicting emotion for me. On the one hand, this sort of behaviour is appalling. But on the other hand, their quality control, validation, longetivity at the front is awe-inspiring.