3 ms·
I wonder how western mentality can bend morality rules to always favor the underdog. The "immoral" practices author accuses the Intel are developing favoring c
by golergka 11y ago
I wonder how western mentality can bend morality rules to always favor the underdog.
The "immoral" practices author accuses the Intel are developing favoring compiler and offering low prices and better deals to OEMs. Let me tell you something: when you give someone one billion dollars, you don't hold them on "ransom"; they're upholding an end of the deal that they voluntarily agreed to. And to lose money, to offer better prices, to get bigger market share is not something even remotely immoral.
Now, about compilers: Intel have never pretended that Intel compiler is supposed to work just as good with Intel as with other compiler manufacturers. It says so even in the marketing benchmark picture provided with the post. It was individual developer's decision: whether he wanted to get equal performance on different platforms, or whether he preferred to sacrifice performance on AMD in order to get more on Intel. Microsoft, Borland, gcc, LLVM and other compilers exist; if a developer choses Intel compiler instead, it's his decision to make his software to run slower on AMD. How is offering such an option immoral?
However, author completely glosses over the fact that AMD reverse-engineered Intel's product and released it's clone. To me, this actually seems like something not only immoral, but quite possibly, illegal, and definitely something worse than Intel's deeds. But of course, since AMD is smaller, it doesn't have to adhere to the same moral standard.
- blowski 11y ago> And to lose money, to offer better prices, to get bigger market share is not something even remotely immoral. I won't go into morality, but it can be illegal if it's considered predatory pricing. If a company has an inferior product but uses its power and dominance of the market to prevent another company with a better product from being able to compete, then laws preventing this from happening are not about favouring the underdog but encouraging innovation.
- bainsfather 11y agoAs regards selling at a loss: if you do this with the aim of destroying or damaging your competition, so that in the future you may enjoy greater profits e.g. due to having a monopoly, then it is bad for society - the word immoral is not unreasonable. There exist laws that try to prevent this type of behaviour, because of the public harm it causes.
- ikurei 11y ago> How is offering such an option immoral? Not an expert, but if Intel were intentially crippling the performance of its compiler for AMD CPUs, i'd say that'd be inmoral. That's unfair competition. If it's just that they didn't spend any time testing and optimizing for the competition's compiler, then... I'm not sure what to think of it, but I doubt i'd come out on the inmoral side of the argument. EDIT: s/disloyal competition/unfair competition/g.
- golergka 11y agoHow is that unfair competition? They could do something even worse. They could just release a compiler which would actually NOT WORK on AMD processors, at all. Compare it to modern mobile development. To develop to iOS, I MUST use xcode — no one has to use Intel compiler to run on Intel's x86. And said xcode doesn't compile to similar ARM chips for Android at all!
- TazeTSchnitzel 11y agoIt wasn't just AMD, Intel was crippling performance on any non-Intel CPU. All x86 CPUs have an instruction, CPUID, that allows you to check for the presence of various features and instruction sets (MMX, x86-64, SSE, etc.). The standard way to generate backwards-compatible code which uses newer instructions is to check the flag, and run the version with the new feature if the flag is there, otherwise use older instructions. Intel, though, would not only check if the CPU supported a feature, but also if the CPU was made by Intel. Essentially, Intel's compiler would generate code like "if Intel, run fast, if not Intel, run slowly."
- TazeTSchnitzel 11y ago> The "immoral" practices author accuses the Intel are developing favoring compiler and offering low prices and better deals to OEMs. The immoral practices are literally bribing OEMs with money, active sabotage in code generation, and selling products below cost. This isn't merely a "favoring compiler" and "low prices". > Now, about compilers: Intel have never pretended that Intel compiler is supposed to work just as good with Intel as with other compiler manufacturers. It says so even in the marketing benchmark picture provided with the post. Of course it's not guaranteed to work super well on AMD chips. But Intel deliberately wrote their compiler to produce code that would behave awfully on AMD processors. The code the Intel compiler generated would usually work fine on AMD (try it!), but it specifically included a check for Intel processors to ensure it didn't. Also, Intel didn't warn their customers of this. There's a disclaimer that it's not optimised for other vendors' chips, sure, but that's not the same. Of course their compiler wouldn't be quite as efficient for AMD chips (it might not include AMD-only instructions), but they didn't warn customers that the compiler would deliberately only work on Intel chips. Customers who didn't inspect the output of the compiler would have no idea that Intel was sabotaging their application's performance. > However, author completely glosses over the fact that AMD reverse-engineered Intel's product and released it's clone. Originally, yes. So did several other companies. So? Clean-room reverse engineering is fine, in fact it's necessary for competition. Companies should not have complete monopolies on a good idea. AMD's later designs were original, anyway.
- washadjeffmad 11y agoThe compilers sppecifically chose the slowest code paths for non-Intel chips, even when you chose to compile with those features for AMD when using Intel hardware. You can still download those versions to check the results. Also, price fixing was just one tactic used. Intel created exclusive contracts by threatening smaller chip makers with supporting their competitors if they shared technology with AMD, then later removed their products from their chipsets. Intel wasn't just trying to hurt AMD, they were systemmatically grooming a weakened marketplace that they could more easily dominate.
- spronkey 11y ago
- dmm 11y ago> However, author completely glosses over the fact that AMD reverse-engineered Intel's product and released it's clone This isn't true. Intel sold AMD a license and shared technical details. From wikipedia: "In February 1982, AMD signed a contract with Intel, becoming a licensed second-source manufacturer of 8086 and 8088 processors." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AMD#IBM_PC_and_the_x86_architecture https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AMD#IBM_PC_and_the_x86_archite...
- creshal 11y ago> However, author completely glosses over the fact that AMD reverse-engineered Intel's product and released it's clone. AMD was chosen by Intel and IBM as second source for 8088 processors, and entered a decade-long patent sharing agreement. How shockingly immoral, indeed. > quite possibly, illegal Intel tried to sue them when the agreement ran out. The courts deemed it otherwise – clean room reimplementations are neither illegal nor particularly immoral.
- mwcampbell 11y ago> I wonder how western mentality can bend morality rules to always favor the underdog. Why shouldn't morality favor the underdog? The winner already has a natural advantage. Do we really want to make that permanent?