2 ms·
I can't speak for JGroups (definitely going to check that out tonight), but spread and Vsync/ISIS both struck me as perfect examples of the meme of poor quality
by monocasa 11y ago
I can't speak for JGroups (definitely going to check that out tonight), but spread and Vsync/ISIS both struck me as perfect examples of the meme of poor quality academic code.
Spread is an #ifdef soup containing scary stuff like "#ifndef _REENTRANT" in their hello world examples. Additionally it has a weird not quite BSD licence that doesn't look compatible with the GPL. It also makes you send them either an ssh key to checkout from subversion, or send them email/name/company info just to get the download link working.
Vsync/ISIS is a single 50KLOC C# file that spawns upwards of a dozen threads on init.
IMHO there's room for someone with more of a software engineering background to come in and clean them up (assuming that this person/group knows enough about distributed systems to clear things up without introducing more problems).
- yid 11y ago> spread and Vsync/ISIS both struck me as perfect examples of the meme of poor quality academic code. I was about to say that academic code is almost always poor quality, but that should never, ever apply to distributed systems code. If there's one thing we should see from academic distributed systems research, it's principled, well-constructed, solidly tested libraries, rather than wannabe commercial databases written by graduate students.
- pron 11y agoOf the three, JGroups is the only one I have used. It is definitely not academic, and it serves as the infrastructure for JBoss Infinispan.