2 ms·
This is where the article goes wrong for me: > The commonality was that the primary motivations were moral. This means that the perpetrators of violence felt l
by wpietri 11y ago
This is where the article goes wrong for me:
> The commonality was that the primary motivations were moral. This means that the perpetrators of violence felt like what they are doing was morally right.
The first sentence is about motivation. The second is about justification.
As an example, I think back to when I was a little kid and fought with my younger brother. My motivations for hitting him would be things like feelings of anger, shame, or urge to establish dominance. My justification would be something like "he hit me first" or "he deserved it" or "he can't talk to me like that".
The motivation was primary, and something I didn't choose. (I did choose to indulge it, of course.) The justification was secondary and situational, constructed to avoid accountability (both internal and parental). Sometimes it was true and sometimes it wasn't, but it was always secondary. As an adult, the justification (and critical examination of it) is part of my gatekeeping of what motivations I indulge, but it's not the motivator.
I think this matters because fixing the claimed justification won't always change the behavior. This quote from a Jon Ronson article gets at why:
"I once interviewed a prison psychiatrist, James Gilligan, who told me that every murderer he treated was harbouring a central secret – which was that they felt humiliated. 'I have yet to see a serious act of violence that was not provoked by the experience of feeling shamed or humiliated, disrespected and ridiculed,' he said. His conclusion: 'All violence is an attempt to replace shame with self-esteem.'"