3 ms·
I don't think this is a good analogy at all. The article is more akin to walking outside in December and stating "here's why December is too cold for my liking"
by sanderjd 11y ago
I don't think this is a good analogy at all. The article is more akin to walking outside in December and stating "here's why December is too cold for my liking". The article is just a series of observations on the author's subjective opinion about a language, along with reasoning on how that opinion was formed. It should be read as "why Go is not good (in my opinion)".
This is a major problem that I struggle with: saying "I think" and "in my opinion" gets old really fast and makes everything you say sound waffle-y, but if you don't say things like that, some people will interpret your statements as if you are claiming to state objective fact.
My sense is that such a diminishingly small amount of the things people discuss is actual fact that I can usually prepend "I believe" to any sentence I read. I am pleasantly surprised when I find that this rule fails to work for something, but that doesn't usually happen on the internet.
- jshen 11y agoI agree, but then people can't complain much when other people, like the Go team, have different opinions and make different decisions than they would. We should encourage experimentation rather than discourage it. No one is forcing anyone to use Go, and there are plenty of languages that have generics, are immutable by default, etc, etc.
- sanderjd 11y ago> We should encourage experimentation rather than discourage it. I made this point already, but to reiterate more succinctly: we should definitely do that, and we should definitely also write about our thoughts on how we think those experiments are going, which is exactly what the OP is doing.
- jshen 11y agoSure, but don't be surprised when people have different opinions and aren't convinced by anecdotes. Reading the comments here you can find tons of people that are shocked, SHOCKED, that not everyone agrees with them on generics, immutability, etc. I think it's important that we remember that these are all opinions with no empirical data to support them, on either side.