4 ms·
> I question the need to preserve a language if it inhibits the positive spread of information. It's possible to believe that a unified language is useful and
by dpark 11y ago
> I question the need to preserve a language if it inhibits the positive spread of information.
It's possible to believe that a unified language is useful and still mourn the loss of other languages. I think it would be useful for society if we had a single common language. I still think it's sad that so many indigenous languages are dead and dying. I'm sad for the same reason I'm sad when some rain forest species goes extinct. It doesn't affect me in any meaningful way, but it's still a loss to us all. We can't get it back.
I think the ongoing efforts to preserve (in recordings) the languages likely to go extinct is valuable and useful.
- danieltillett 11y agoActually unlike a dead species we can get back dead languages. As long you record the language in enough detail before its death then any human can learn to speak it.
- dpark 11y agoThis is thankfully something of a possibility now, if well recorded via audio. Previous languages recorded only in writing cannot be fully reconstructed. Even with audio there is probably some loss of subtlety that would only be learned through conversation with native speakers, but it can probably be pretty close.
- danieltillett 11y agoWith enough recordings it should be possible to get close and no living language is static anyway so any error is likely to be less than natural drift.