3 ms·
I was just reading [1] about how Detroit's original decline was due, to a significant degree, to the mortgage industry: Through a system called Red-Lining in t
by hackuser 11y ago
I was just reading [1] about how Detroit's original decline was due, to a significant degree, to the mortgage industry:
Through a system called Red-Lining in the mid-20th century, which the federal government actively facilitated [2], banks refused to lend to any residents of neighborhoods with even a few residents who were of 'undesireable' races, including of course, blacks. This wasn't a conspiracy theory; it was all done in the open. Consequences:
1) Even for whites happy to integrate: A few black families move in, credit dries up, nobody can sell or improve their homes, and your housing values plummet.
2) And even worse for blacks: Imagine trying to buy a house without credit. Now imagine doing that coming from the rock-bottom financial circumstances imposed on most blacks in the mid-20th century.
3) Blacks who did obtain homes couldn't get home improvement loans, resulting in deterioration of their homes and a reputation among whites for not caring about their properties.
4) The effect on supply and demand: It forced a very large and growing number of black residents into a small, artificially limited number of rentals (they could only live in certain neighorhoods, remember), driving up rental rates and driving down the quality of their residences (landlords could fill their properties without doing maintenance). Even more perversely, even if someone would sell them a house, blacks had to pay more than whites for the same house - the black bidder had far fewer options. Again, remember the people in the worst financial circumstances were the ones facing these problems.
Back then bankers said the same thing: They are bad credit risks.
----
[1] The Origins of the Urban Crisis:Race and Inequality in Postwar Detroit by Thomas J. Sugrue: A prize-winning scholarly history. Highly recommended; it changed dramatically how I understood racial issues and urban development (http://press.princeton.edu/titles/10233.html http://press.princeton.edu/titles/10233.html)
[2] It was called 'red-lining' because the Federal Home Loan Association (I think I have the right agency) would literally draw red lines around these neighborhoods and identify them to banks as the worst possible credit risks.
- thesagan 11y agoIt was as if Detroit was hit by a perfect storm of boom-town, bust-town with all the sexy variables thrown in. What you described is a big part of it. And being mostly a one-industry town was another part, in an age of rapid globalization, and with strong unions making Detroit the more expensive place to produce. Moreover, the core of Detroit was sliced up by an extremely extensive network of freeways, and in patterns where you get a fairly intense breakup of neighborhoods when you compare to other northern cities of the time who were building expressways through theirs. Detroit's postwar suburbs came calling for all of those automobile-owning middle-classers back in the D. Also, most Detroit housing was quickly-built wooden construction, which are a lot more vulnerable to breaks in maintenance. While brick buildings can wait "on inventory" much longer, much of Detroit's wooden stock was expensive to maintain, and didn't last long waiting "on inventory" to be put into re-use. Michigan suffers dramatic freeze-thaw cycles, rain/snow/ice, and loose ground that can bust-up under-maintained buildings in no time. Another, a perhaps seminal event, at least for people living in city, were the 1967 riots (which you could connect to all that redlining that went on). All through the central city. That was the "last straw" for most everyone who could leave and wanted to leave. Many people I know personally remember as a kid moving out not long after '67. And the race riots seemed to have made race relations worse in the region, in my unsubstantiated opinion.
- hackuser 11y agoI think you'd find the book valuable; it has a lot to say about the riots. Race relations were bad before them: For example, blacks moving into previously all-white neighborhoods could face angry mobs who threw things through their windows and burnt things on their front lawns.
- thesagan 11y agoOh you bet! And I'll probably will need to read that book, as well. Sounds intriguing.