4 ms·
The share of women in computer science started falling at roughly the same moment when personal computers started showing up in U.S. homes in significant number
by jessaustin 11y ago
The share of women in computer science started falling at roughly the same moment when personal computers started showing up in U.S. homes in significant numbers... And these... were marketed almost entirely to men and boys.
Great, another travesty for which we have marketing to thank.
- DeusExMachina 11y agoThe hate towards marketing that is present on HN is almost comical at times. My experience is that, the more you study how marketing works, the more you realize marketing is about what people already want and try to appeal to that. Sure, big companies like Coca Cola have more sophisticated techniques to make their brands appealing, but still, if you look at Coca Cola's marketing, what they sell is "happiness", which is what people want, and they make the association to their beverage. From this point of view, there is no "travesty" to thank marketing for. The reality was that probably personal computers were more appealing to men, so it made more sense to spend marketing resources towards them. Why it was more appealing to them is a good question to ask, and it could be because of many reasons, including culture and society. But marketing probably didn't create that desire, it just used it.
- darkr 11y agoI think you've totally missed the point why people hate marketing. It's not because of a lack of understanding on it's mechanics. > From this point of view, there is no "travesty" to thank marketing for. The reality was that probably personal computers were more appealing to men, so it made more sense to spend marketing resources towards them. Why it was more appealing to them is a good question to ask, and it could be because of many reasons, including culture and society. But marketing probably didn't create that desire, it just used it. Marketing is absolutely about the manufacture of desire. Though above you make the connection between Coca-cola and the harmless association of this beverage to "happiness", this is over-simplifying things somewhat. The psychology of the brand, upon which modern consumer society is dependent, and which marketing ruthlessly exploits, is based around the construction of a self solely through conspicuous acts of consumption rather than through human experiences, relationships with friends and family, or other pursuits traditionally considered to be more laudable. Though arguably it is required in keeping the wheels of capitalism spinning (and by proxy food in our bellies); in reality, marketing is the process of co-opting, subverting, and ultimately extinguishing joy and the human experience.
- caskance 11y agoMarketing only manufactures desire if you interpret desire in the most narrow possible sense as desire for a specific product. What marketing actually does is make desires concrete and suggest to the audience how that desire can be fulfilled. If you look at one of the most famous examples of successful marketing, diamond marketing created demand for a specific product, but it was only able to do so because the emotional needs the marketers tied their products to were already there and not being adequately met.
- darkr 11y agoThe term desire works in a broader sense, as long as you differentiate between a need and a desire. A need (I guess I'm referring here mostly to needs in the context of those defined by Maslow's Hierarchy) is defined as something that is an absolute; an end state. There is a requirement of truth for something to be a need. A desire is defined as "a strong feeling of wanting to have something or wishing for something to happen". A desire is open to suggestion, to invention and misrepresentation. Taking your example of the diamond industry: The "needs" being targeted here are pretty much the solid base of the pyramid (sex & shelter, family/stability, love & intimacy). Does a tiny, expensive shiny rock from Sierra Leone provide those needs? No; obviously it is the symbolism of giving to/receiving from someone in the hope that they will provide those needs to you. Did humans manage to satisfy those needs before De Beers came along? I'm pretty sure they did. The desire for diamonds among the general populace was completely manufactured, whereas the aforementioned needs always existed, and (I strongly suspect) were always being filled before the normalisation of diamond rings as intentions of marriage. I suppose diamonds (at least in the context of use as jewellery), and the whole story of De Beers are a shining example of commodity fetishism.
- scotty79 11y ago> marketing is about what people already want and try to appeal to that. Like figuring out that people already want not to be talk about behind their backs and ostracized for their flaws, then telling them that they stink (vide halitosis) and appealing to that by selling them unnecessary or potentially harmful fluid to apply orally. Yes. Well done. Marketing created more than one stupid cultural habit. Why the hate?
- yourapostasy 11y agoThat sentiment might be jumping the gun. I was just a kid playing around with a DEC PDP-11 when the TRS-80/Apple ][/Commodore Amiga wave of personal computers hit homes (I wasn't exposed to the earlier, Homebrew Computer Club-era, MITS Altair/Apple I/Heathkit H8 wave of personal computers). I clearly recall IT staffing at the company where the PDP-11 came from heavily staffed by women. However, even the daughters of those women at that time who I got to meet, to the last one, had zero interest in anything having to do with computers. Except maybe for the occasional game that caught their fancy. Usually storyline-driven themes like On-Line Systems aka Sierra Entertainment titles and Pac-Man clones; they rejected all of the dungeon crawlers or shoot-up themes. I recall even as a youngster thinking at the time the displayed gender preferences very odd, as computers to me were neutral territory where neither gender had an obvious physical or social advantage at the outset. I am guessing that the early marketers likely observed the same emergent social behaviors, and decided to market to where the money was. Meeting hundreds of people in the industry, it is vanishingly rare to find a woman who bugged her parents as a young girl for an early-era home computer; that story is so common among men it is a pedestrian trope. I'd dearly like to know from marketers who were involved in that era to chime in on what kind of market research led them to tilt the early marketing towards men and boys.
- ghaff 11y agoMy memory of the BBS crowd in the 1980s was that it was something of a mix but definitely skewed male. As someone else said, that's probably the natural outgrown of interest in ham radio, phone phreaking, electronics kits, etc. All of which it's probably fair to say skewed male.
- yourapostasy 11y agoI experienced the same. Even the BBS' that deliberately were set up as social hangouts, which had the greatest ratio of women to men participants, still skewed about 70% male. I never saw it reach parity online, but interestingly, face-to-face parties brought out an evenly-mixed group as BBS users attended with spouses/girlfriends/boyfriends. I see the current generation computer users' behaviors addressing this imbalance in user population, though not the software development business that produces that utility (lots of hygienic factors adversely impact the majority of jobs in our business now, compared to the state of the business 2+ decades ago).
- rimantas 11y agoexcept that there were countries without such marketing, and the trend is still the same. I doubt that US marketing had any effect on USSR. And keep in mind, that in the USSR there was some push for the women to take "male" jobs and be proud about being e.g. miner or harvester driver.
- hasenj 11y agoThink about it. If you are a greedy capitalist, why oh why would you limit your market to half its potential?