3 ms·
>> if it's so massively parallel, why do I read your comment left to right one word at a time? For fun, I once had two friends speak to me simultaneously, one
by YeGoblynQueenne 11y ago
>> if it's so massively parallel, why do I read your comment left to right one word at a time?
For fun, I once had two friends speak to me simultaneously, one in each ear. We swapped places and did that to each other a few times. Result: nope, our language understanding unit is not parallel. You can either take in a wall of sound, OR focus to a string of words and understand its meaning. It might feel like you can almost do both at the same time and pick up two different threads of conversation at the same time, but it's always just beyond your reach. At best you can swap between threads quickly, if the conversations permit it (so forget it both/all conversations are rapid-fire and heavy with nuance etc).
I also note that our language generation units are not parallel. We can utter one syllable at a time. So maybe there's not much point in understanding multiple syllables at a time?
- DbauchdSloth 11y agoI am not so sure about this I suspect it is perhaps more of a learned skill. Professional DJs come to mind. To match two desperate musical tracks with differing tempo and align correctly requires following two musical tracks simultaneously. Initially it is very much as you say but over time you learn to hear them both separately and together without strain. My experience with twitch is another anecdotal counterpoint. After a lot of practice I now regularly listen to multiple audio streams at the same time and no longer hand any problem following up to three streams simultaneously these days, and it was impossible for me at first. Another issue is at what point does very fast attention switching become effectively multiprocessing? If we don't notice the context switching happening is still "happening"?
- drumdance 11y agoThis rings true to me. As a trained musician, I know that I hear music differently from most untrained people. I notice the bass line, or the way the melody inverts, or anticipate the end of a phrase. Several years ago Kathy Sierra wrote a great post about how app developers should try to educate users from the first time they use the product and "raise the resolution" on how they think about the problem the app is designed to solve. http://headrush.typepad.com/creating_passionate_users/2005/12/the_hires_user_.html http://headrush.typepad.com/creating_passionate_users/2005/1...
- YeGoblynQueenne 11y ago>> Another issue is at what point does very fast attention switching become effectively multiprocessing? If we don't notice the context switching happening is still "happening"? Well, OK, that's one big question. However, I can process music and language at the same time. I think I can process multiple pieces of music at the same time, for example I can follow a complex piece of classical music or jazz with multiple instruments playing at various signatures and so on (full disclosure: I'm a drummer). I can't quite do that with speech though. So maybe music and language are just different things and they're processed in different ways?
- kazinator 11y ago> our language understanding unit is not parallel Your experiment seems to rather point to the intuition that we don't have a plurality of these units which can operate independently, not that a single unit doesn't have a parallel architecture. The parallel talk is being superimposed into effectively a single input going into the same unit. That unit doesn't have the processing layer to unravel this superimposed input into two streams of speech.