3 ms·
If it's harmful for the user, it seems likely there's also going to be a "second-hand vape" danger. While I wouldn't want to ban them altogether, it might be wi
by mikeash 11y ago
If it's harmful for the user, it seems likely there's also going to be a "second-hand vape" danger. While I wouldn't want to ban them altogether, it might be wise to ban them in public indoor spaces. Maybe make it so any smoking ban is automatically a vaping ban.
- chc 11y agoIt seems about as reasonable to treat vaporizers this way as it does to treat laptops this way because sometimes they catch on fire and smoke. It sounds like this is one flavoring that was already known to be harmful. That seems pretty far short of establishing a likelihood that personal vaporizers, as a category, create harmful second-hand effects.
- anigbrowl 11y agoFor drying out loud, vaping outside is not such a burden. Vaping doesn't bother me but if you're in a no smoking area then people are probably also not going to want to be exposed to other airborne contaminants. How hard is it to be considerate of others?
- chc 11y agoI don't understand why you're berating me about where to vape. I do not vape anywhere. Just because somebody tries to evaluate vaping rationally doesn't mean they are trying to defend a secret vaping habit. As for being considerate — yes, obviously it's good to be considerate, but that's kind of a platitude until you get into the nitty-gritty details. We all do things that are inconsiderate in some ways. For example, if you eat meat in public, there are might be vegetarians around who find the sight and smell offensive, but I doubt you consider yourself inconsiderate for doing so. I'm not sure exactly where vaping falls in the "doing this in public makes you a jerk" spectrum, but I lean towards thinking it falls closer to wearing heavy perfume than to smoking (since its effects seem to be more similar to that).
- anigbrowl 11y agoI misunderstood your comment by reading it in an incorrect context. I'm sorry about that.
- logn 11y agoCan we also ban perfume and fragrances then? They're not healthy either. /s I'd just like to see a requirement that all products have a label which lists every ingredient, even if that label is only available online or by mailing the manufacturer. And "natural and artificial flavors" is not an ingredient. "Meets the flammability requirements of the California Bureau of Home Furnishings" is also not an ingredient.
- mikeash 11y agoI'd love comprehensive labeling requirements like this. It always makes me deeply suspicious whenever such requirements are opposed. See for example the recent controversy over labeling GMO food. The resistance against that was insane. However, labeling doesn't really help people exposed to second-hand whatnot. The smoker/vaper(/perfume-wearer) may find the ingredients to be acceptable, but what about all the people around them? And unfortunately, smokers are not the most considerate bunch.
- logn 11y agoI think if ingredients were disclosed that, first, harmful ingredients would be reduced or eliminated by the makers, and next the public could debate the issue of banning indoor e-cigs from a position of knowledge. If every product had to disclose this, then ideally you could recursively query for every component chemical. At that point, not only would banning e-cigs be discussed but also probably many building materials and cleaning products. And we'd be able to ban on a granular level, e.g., any product emitting more than 10 ppm diacetyl.
- simoncion 11y ago> ...and next the public could debate the issue of banning indoor e-cigs from a position of knowledge. I very much want to live in a world where the public debates issues from a position of knowledge, rather than positions of deliberate ignorance motivated by tribalistic passions. :(