8 ms·
I'd rather a million Elmo-centric Sesame Street episodes than even one episode of Barney or Caillou. That said, every kid needs some old-school, Elmo-free Sesa
by bitwize 11y ago
I'd rather a million Elmo-centric Sesame Street episodes than even one episode of Barney or Caillou.
That said, every kid needs some old-school, Elmo-free Sesame Street and Mister Rogers. (No, "Daniel Tiger's Neighborhood" is not the same; it's insipid and dumb by comparison.)
Also, back in the day, Square One TV had a police-procedural parody called Mathnet that was still loads better than network TV's attempt at a mathematical-cop show for adults (Numb3rs).
It literally couldn't get any better for a kid than PBS in the 70s or 80s.
- specialist 11y agoThe Muppets and Sesame Street is children's programmable watchable by parents. Something families could watch together. Pure genius. Hunt's Elmo character broke that. As a parent, that's what ruined Sesame Street.
- JoshTriplett 11y ago> Also, back in the day, Square One TV had a police-procedural parody called Mathnet I remember that; it was awesome. Drenched in cheesiness, but it served its goal, and it did manage the "tainment" part of "edutainment".
- oddevan 11y agoThe story you're about to hear is a fib, but it's fact.
- soylentcola 11y agoDon't wanna be pedantic but I think the line was: "The story you're about to hear is a fib, but it's short. The names are made up but the problems are real." Honestly surprised I remember that gag since it's been ages since I watched that show but I did love those segments. It was like the Square One answer to 3-2-1 Contact's "Bloodhound Gang".
- JoshTriplett 11y agoI was also sad to see the Ghostwriter series (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ghostwriter_%28TV_series%29 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ghostwriter_%28TV_series%29) disappear.
- bitwize 11y agoI still use LJBAD as an "enable this for debugging" symbol on the off chance that someone else used DEBUG.
- oddevan 11y agoGo ahead an be pedantic; I looked up a video right after I made that comment and saw my error. :)
- McGlockenshire 11y agoOdd Squad feels like a spiritual successor of Mathnet. It's entertaining, educational, and clever enough for parents to watch and not want to gouge our eyes out.
- sogen 11y agoGreat show! Just watched it the other day, very entertaining and makes the viewer think by themselves.
- dkuntz2 11y agoMathNet was amazing, because I definitely watched it in some high school math classes.
- sputknick 11y agoWas that the show where they said "My name is Wednesday... it was a Tuesday?", might have been on right after 3-2-1 Contact? That show was awesome, now I'm going to have to find a few episodes for my kids! Thanks for the reminder.
- bitwize 11y ago"My partner is George Frankly; the boss is Thad Green. My name is Monday. I'm a mathematician." I think we're remembering the same show. Yes, do look it up; your kids will thank you.
- Falcon9 11y agoAt some point (according to Wikipedia, the start of the fourth season), Monday was replaced with a new girl, named Tuesday (naturally).
- mtreis86 11y agoDon't forget the nature programs. I watched Wild America exclusively as a toddler
- taeric 11y agoI am rather fond of Wild Kratts. It is a victory in the house if the kids pick that over Power Rangers.
- spdustin 11y agoMy two kids enjoyed "The Backyardigans", and with my own interest in musical expression, I found it mostly quite entertaining. Episodes about space, art, math, earth science, cultural beliefs... And a few clever spoofs of some grown-up faves. It was a fun show, and each episode had a genre-specific set of musical arrangements. Zydeco, country, folk... Very cleverly done. I have a soft spot for that show beyond its lack of Dora-level annoyance: my son is on the autism spectrum, and for some time, his only speech was echolalic. He was most fond of using phrases uttered by one of the Backyardigans, Austin, who himself didn't speak much. He always used the echoed speech in contextually appropriate ways - one time he saw snow falling outside, and said, "it's..it's..it's snowing," with the exact prosody of Austin's utterance of that line in "The Secret of Snow". That was very illuminating for me as the father of a developmentally delayed child. I didn't know how to predict his ability to function as he got older, or really his understanding of language at all...But that day, the sight of gently falling snow never seemed so amazing to me. When it was on, I often watched it with them; I didn't want to lob a bowling ball at my television, which Caillou made me consider doing. And don't even get me started on Kai-Lan...
- Domenic_S 11y ago> (No, "Daniel Tiger's Neighborhood" is not the same; it's insipid and dumb by comparison.) You might need to go rewatch some MRN. Fred Rogers is basically a saint, but MRN had plenty of insipidness of its own.
- bitwize 11y agoFred Rogers did something that the producers of DTN haven't; he drew strict boundary lines between realism and make-believe, opening each Neighborhood of Make Believe segment with "Let's pretend..." This emphasis on exposing fiction as not real tightened as the show went on: Picture-Picture would eventually lose its "magical" properties, and in one episode Fred actually walked off set and introduced the kids to the cameramen, boom operators, and so forth.
- Domenic_S 11y agoDTN kind of Inceptions this concept -- Daniel often has "lets pretend" events, where he says "let's make believe" and wags his ears while sparkles shine.
- KirinDave 11y ago> "Daniel Tiger's Neighborhood" is not the same; it's insipid and dumb by comparison.) Funny, because DTN is a award winning show with excellent writers and a body of research and consulting experts backing up their approach. It's only "insipid" if you try to analyze it as an adult. For kids, its engaging and important. Compare and contrast to other popular shows like Pororo that, while charming and well executed, really don't have nearly so much science behind them.
- JeremyNT 11y agoDaniel Tiger's Neighborhood is an astoundingly well envisioned show, and I'm really disappointed that the top comment here speaks ill of it. It expands upon the core of what Rogers was trying to teach and I find it to be a wonderfully fitting, modern successor. One of the joys I've experienced as a parent is in observing how well crafted and thoughtful DTN (and some other notable shows on PBS) have become, and how my daughter incorporates lessons learned from them in her daily life. Mr. Rogers' Neighborhood (and early Sesame Street) surely deserve massive amounts of praise, but they were not formed perfectly, from whole cloth, as perfect educational programs. As with any other field, our knowledge of child psychology and early development is continuing to evolve, and there are brilliant people doing amazing work in this area.
- bitwize 11y agoI don't think DTN is necessarily bad on its own merits at all. Certainly there is much worse: Dora, Barney, Caillou, to name three. But compared to its predecessor it pales, significantly.
- KirinDave 11y agoWhile I remember MRN fondly, it was as complete mess compared to what we have now. We need to accept that there was almost no actual rigor put into the creation of our kids shows, at their genesis. I remember them fondly and praise them regularly, but I try to keep this in mind. Modern kids shows are optimized for kids. Even Dora is specifically optimized for very young children. It appears insipid because it's repetitive to us. But to a child, it's carefully tuned.
- na85 11y agoThe Muppet Show needs to make a comeback. It was like SNL for kids.
- Jtsummers 11y agoThere's a new one, though I haven't watched it. I've heard very mixed reviews from other fans of the original and the 90s version.
- yitchelle 11y agoAs an adult, it is really tough appreciate shows that I have enjoyed as a child when a remake of it appears. Just don't seem to get the same sense of excitement when watching it.
- Yhippa 11y agoSpeaking of Mathnet they had another segment on there called Mathman. I got so into it when I was younger that I really rooted for Mathman to not lose to Glitch. They did a good job of gamifiying math for me: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_Yd3tA4wMPI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_Yd3tA4wMPI.
- jmcgough 11y agoMathnet and Mathman pretty much single-handedly made me and my siblings love math as chidlren :)
- alexandercrohde 11y agoHaha, forgot about Mathman, that show always freaked me out, that creepy tornado guy always kills him...
- trevyn 11y agoIt inspired me to actually write a version of Mathman for the Apple II...
- hitekker 11y ago> Mister Rogers For those who didn't grow up with Mister Rogers, I encourage you to watch this, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fKy7ljRr0AA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fKy7ljRr0AA, to get a sense of how effective he was as a speaker.
- mfoy_ 11y agoHe must be rolling in his grave with the way violence has waxed and mentionable, manageable feelings have waned. I haven't watched any cartoons recently but it seems the trend is toward rejection and denial of feelings rather than acceptance and understanding. He even brought up mental health (this being the late 60s) which is remarkable as there hasn't been much focus on mental health until very recently (and still not enough). I wish I had grown up with his show, I don't remember if we just didn't get it or if I just always missed it but it seems he had a good thing going on.
- sjm 11y agoI also thought it was incredibly surprising he even uttered the words "mental health" given how it was looked at back then. It comes across as brave and with much foresight. A very smart man indeed!
- namlem 11y agoActually cartoons have definitely moved towards acceptance and understanding of feelings in the past few years. Shows like Adventure Time, Steven Universe, and Gravity Falls come to mind.
- aczerepinski 11y agoPeg + Cat is a fairly intelligent PBS kids show. Lots of exposure to math & music concepts.
- pipermerriam 11y agoCannot recommend this enough. Strong female lead character. Entertaining enough for adults to watch. Math!
- Fuzzwah 11y ago3rded. I ctrl+f'd to see if anyone else had mentioned it. I often sing the "we solved the problem" song when I fix something at work. I'm pretty sure that my 2 year old daughter feeds off my enjoyment of the show; its the only show she'll start doing a little happy dance to when the opening jingle comes on.
- caf 11y agoand puns! I really like the whole drawn-on-graph-paper look, too.
- flashman 11y agoFairly intelligent except that every one of Peg's lines sounds like it's spoken in upper case.
- sogen 11y agotoo bad she starts screaming "oh no a problem!!" and panics Not a good role model. Same with Caillou, poor guy is too depressed...
- wdr1 11y ago> It literally couldn't get any better for a kid than PBS in the 70s or 80s. Well, except for, you know, books. I don't really buy any of this "need" stuff when it comes to TV (or that one form is significantly better than another). If you drop your kid in front of anything and they turn into a slackjaw zombie (as my son tends to do), that's bad. If you drop your kid in front of anything that you watch, engage, and use as a jumping off point for interaction, that's fine.
- gohrt 11y agoBy painting all of television with one brush, you underestimate the importance of a friendly face on a caring adult. https://www.google.com/?#q=mr+rogers+latchkey+kids https://www.google.com/?#q=mr+rogers+latchkey+kids
- deveac 11y ago>Well, except for, you know, books. Don't confuse file type with content :)
- WalterBright 11y ago> It literally couldn't get any better for a kid than PBS in the 70s or 80s. As a kid in the 60s, we spent most of our time unsupervised roaming the countryside. The 60s Superman comics were the best, and for TV we had Bugs Bunny on Saturday mornings. Chemistry sets weren't yet emasculated. Somehow we learned to read without SS :-)
- lmm 11y ago> Somehow we learned to read without SS :-) But statistically speaking less of you learned to read, and those that did learned to read less well. The effects of Sesame Street were studied very thoroughly.
- commenter1239 11y agomathnet taught me the fibonacci sequence.
- stevewillows 11y agoCaillou is brutal. I love George Shrinks though. It's simple adventures, but they created something that's actually interesting without being overly complex.
- bane 11y ago> It literally couldn't get any better for a kid than PBS in the 70s or 80s. Don't forget such gems as "The Electric Company", "3-2-1 Contact", "Reading Rainbow", "Mr. Wizard", "Bill Nye" and others. It seemed for a while that TV producers really wanted to pursue the mission of Television as an educational medium. I honestly don't know anything about the quality of today's material, but the material I grew up with was really well done on so many facets. It wasn't just about learning basic reading or arithmetic, but also about how to socialize well, diversity training, problem solving, emotional growth and more. It was multi-faceted and didn't pander to children or just spend 30 minutes entertaining them with vapid songs. I feel like there was a real earnest effort by very smart educators to use the medium to its fullest and I grew up enjoying those shows more than afternoon cartoons and other 30 minute commercials. By comparison Barney, Teletubbies, and those late 90s, early 2000s "educational shows" are pure garbage. I can still sit down as an adult and find enjoyment in classic Sesame Street. And I think that's part of the difference, the modern shows were basically entertainment and electronic babysitters for busy parents, SST, Mr. R and classic children's shows taught on multiple levels and parents weren't bored out of their minds to sit with their own kids and help reinforce the lessons. (Mathnet was one of my favorite segments of its parent show, It was funny and entertaining, but introduced basic math skills as well as critical thinking skills. It also introduced me to this kind of slightly archaic story-style which helped give me a life-long love of classic radio dramas and comedies) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7_eBFzNLsGk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7_eBFzNLsGk
- ramanamit1234 11y agoTV was the only dynamic medium back then. We have Youtube, apps now to get the job done. The investment in public tv for education is gone. Fortunately, PBS Newshour is still tops.