4 ms·
Many of these types of services seem to intentionally cap upload speeds to reduce their potential storage liability (since they're likely over-selling storage t
by Someone1234 11y ago
Many of these types of services seem to intentionally cap upload speeds to reduce their potential storage liability (since they're likely over-selling storage to be able to offer 1 TB for $12 with the level of redundancy, staffing costs, etc, needed).
I wonder if that is happening in this specific case? Although if it were the case the vendor should still be honest about it. Just saying they limit uploads to 2 Mbps is better than giving the run-around.
- scurvy 11y agoIt's definitely possible to offer that on a monthly basis if you model that each customer stays for 36-39 months. Also, I doubt that they are using replicated storage, but are using erasure coding instead. Also, they dedupe before upload, so more cost savings there.
- Sir_Substance 11y agoSpideroak doesn't and cannot dedupe, since everything you upload is encrypted by a key held only by you.
- daveguy 11y agoSpideroak can and does dedupe client side before uploading. It can't dedupe across multiple clients, but it does dedupe within the client. It also tracks syncs so that data synced between multiple client machines only has to be stored once (with appropriate redundancy).
- evoloution 11y agoThat explains why the data are visualized the way they are in the view menu :)
- Joona 11y agoDefinitely looks like it to me. Took me a good month to back up my (video) files with CrashPlan, as it was using some 10% of my upload. I think it would be a good selling point for a service like this to allow higher upload speeds.
- BillyParadise 11y agoA good upsell, yes. But initial seeding to "affordably priced" online services at full data rate can never be economically viable to the provider. Bandwidth is cheap(er) these days, but routers which can handle big bandwidth are still big bucks. Hold on, this is hacker news. VCs, this is a great idea! No, no of course it's not. Initial seeding is a competitive moat for the first mover. Moving a few hundred gigs to a new backup company just to save a few bucks? I don't think I could be bothered, because I KNOW how long it will take.
- jewel 11y agoPricing is falling rapidly for storage. Consider that S3 - IA is $15/mo for a TB, and backblaze B2 can offer 1 TB for $5/mo. I would assume both are making some profit at those price points, so $12/TB/mo should be workable if the service is doing their own hardware. Backup services especially have low operational requirements for their hardware and network connection, since once the files are uploaded they only need to be verified periodically.
- jcfrei 11y agoYup, I've noticed the same with Wuala. The uploads were pretty slow. I've heard similar complaints from people using OneDrive. I would be very willing to switch to a smaller competitor even if it meant paying more than I do at Dropbox. But from my experience Dropbox is the only provider capable of synchronizing large amounts of data 24/7.
- extesy 11y agoBackblaze client is uploading at the speed of several mb/s, very close to my connection upload speed limit.
- toomuchtodo 11y ago> reduce their potential storage liability Its to reduce their maximum bandwidth capacity required. I don't see it as a problem, considering their price points. They're selling you storage, not "slam 1TB of your data into our storage system in a day". If you're looking for that, ship a hard drive to Iron Mountain. EDIT: Even AWS limits how fast you can upload to S3, and built an appliance for you to rent and ship back and forth if you need to move data faster. That station wagon full of tape is still alive and well.
- toast0 11y ago> Its to reduce their maximum bandwidth capacity required. They should be looking to partner with someone who has bandwidth problems in the other direction. By combining a backup service's upload bandwidth and a streaming video service's download bandwidth into one AS, you can get a more balanced stream, and qualify for free peering.
- toomuchtodo 11y agoYeah, agreed. The problem is, you're limited to partners in the same DC as you (unless you're going to bite the bullet and start using fiber loops between datacenters to accomplish this). Backblaze (for example only) is only in one DC in Northern California if I recall, which limits them to whomever is in that datacenter. A great model would be to parter with CDNs; they pour content out to eyeball networks, but you could run a distributed network of your storage system across all of their POPs.
- wernercd 11y agoIf I have buy a 1TB plan to hold 999GB of data and it takes months to push that data up... That ZOMG WHAT A DEAL! of a plan is kinda worthless... "Slam" is a bit of a loaded word, since... if they are selling 1TB of storage, shouldn't we get 1TB of storage? That's the same crap that ISP's tried to pull with UNLIMITED INTERNET!!! (as long as you stay under 30gb per month)
- toomuchtodo 11y ago
- lakeeffect 11y agoThe thing that is silly about that is related to cost of acquisition and retention of customers. If a company is able to get more data quicker they are more valuable to the customer and will most like be used and retained by the customer. If organizations are offering storage as a solution while at the same time trying to minimize the costs of that solution, by minimizing the utilization of that storage; they are exchanging fixed costs associated with storage (that should be easily built into pricing) for large variable costs related to customer acquisition, retention, and branding.
- newscracker 11y ago> Many of these types of services seem to intentionally cap upload speeds to reduce their potential storage liability (since they're likely over-selling storage to be able to offer 1 TB for $12 with the level of redundancy, staffing costs, etc, needed). SpiderOak is definitely overselling the 1TB as well as another one that pops up once in a while called as the "unlimited" plan for $149 a year. This is clear from the disproportional pricing structure - $79 a year for 30GB that jumps to $129 a year for 1TB and then to $279 a year for 5TB - which entices users to go for the higher amounts because they appear to be great deals. What people with residential broadband connections may not realize is that a) uploading even 1TB of data will take a long time and b) SpiderOak cannot, and does not, provide any minimum guarantees on the upload or download speeds (assuming everything else in between SpiderOak and the user looks fine).