5 ms·
What's the two-word summary of why I'd want to use this app over one of the other content blockers?
by mikeash 11y ago
What's the two-word summary of why I'd want to use this app over one of the other content blockers?
- pistoriusp 11y ago"It's free!"
- mikeash 11y agoThat's certainly an item in the "pro" column, but there are lots of other free ones out there.
- pistoriusp 11y agoIf someone were to gain some traction in this space I would prefer it to be a credible organisation. I long thought that this should be driven by a foundation , rather than a private enterprise, but I wanted the additional benefit of delegating the profits to a particular donation. The hooks are implemented by Apple and the data is crowd sourced. I don't see any reason why anyone should profit in this space.
- s73v3r 11y ago"I don't see any reason why anyone should profit in this space." Because there's still work in putting it together and maintaining it? And because profiting from doing this means they're less likely to take money from an ad company?
- s73v3r 11y agoIf it were anything other than Mozilla, wouldn't that be a Con? Because then it'd be more likely that the maintainer would take money to let ads by.
- pistoriusp 11y agoWell... One of the best selling paid versions, Crystal, is going to allow companies to pay for "acceptable ads." Personally, I think the people who paid for blockers were ripped off, there's nothing special or difficult in building a content blocker: 1. The majority of the value, the blocking list, it readily available and actively maintained. 2. Performance and integration into iOS is provided by Apple, you simply produce a format that Apple approves. So what are you paying for? Marketing, packaging, and giving a 3rd party control?
- s73v3r 11y agoSo why should anyone make a content blocker, unless they're someone with a mission to do so, like Mozilla or the EFF?
- pistoriusp 11y agoI get the feeling that you have some deep seated capitalistic ideals. Do you do anything that you can't make money from? I can think of a few reasons to make a content blocker: 1. Improve privacy for users on the Internet. 2. Decrease cost and speed for people who pay for data, or have bad connections. 3. Challenge revenue streams of large corporations. 4. Fame. 5. Improve strangers lives.
- s73v3r 11y agoThose are good reasons. But I don't see anything about why one shouldn't be paid for it.
- masukomi 11y agocan't do a two word, but you don't have to worry about maintainer accepting $$ to allow certain ads through, as has happened with at least one other iOS content blocker
- newscracker 11y agoAgain, can't sum up in two words, but can sum it up in two points. This would be better because: * It's by Mozilla, and it's more likely (probability wise) to be maintained and kept up-to-date than those that happen to be a single person's hobby project. * I believe that big players in the web like Mozilla and EFF (eff.org) really fight for us, the common people. :) The more these things become popular, especially from bigger names, the better the chances of the whole ad-tracker-privacy ecosystem to improve for our good.
- mikeash 11y agoThe "two word" thing is a joke, but your two points are pretty good. The combination of "maintained by decently large organization" and "non-evil" is probably unique in this space.
- profeta 11y agowhat about besides "known household name"? any technical merit? anything you know you do better than the alternative, for a fact? and in the process of fairness, any other blocker doing anything better that you plan to add to yours?
- newscracker 11y agoTechnical merit? I don't really know. This is based on the open source tracker list from Disconnect (disconnect.me). FWIW, I was never into paying for an ad-blocker on iOS since that comes with its pitfalls. I have tried a couple of other free ones, and I did like Adblock Fast [1], the one I was using until Focus by Firefox and the one I still have. It's open source and is available for Chrome (not iOS), Opera (not iOS) and Safari (iOS 9). I'd suggest reading through the GitHub page to see some stats as well as the philosophy (of not making money or compromising it with acceptable ads). [2] [1]: https://itunes.apple.com/us/app/adblock-fast/id1032930802 https://itunes.apple.com/us/app/adblock-fast/id1032930802 [2]: https://github.com/rocketshipapps/adblockfast https://github.com/rocketshipapps/adblockfast
- profeta 11y ago
- saucetenuto 11y agoHow about: "Reliable curation"
- davidgerard 11y ago"credible nonprofit"
- mikeash 11y agoUpvote for rising to my absurd challenge and making a decent argument too.