11 ms·
That wouldn't work. Your assumption is that these retail companies are storing full credit card information in some large database somewhere, that is not the c
by Someone1234 11y ago
That wouldn't work.
Your assumption is that these retail companies are storing full credit card information in some large database somewhere, that is not the case at all. Most large retailers only store the full credit card information for seconds while they process the transaction, when the transaction is complete it is discarded.
What the criminals are targeting is the card terminals themselves. Meaning when you swipe your card, as the transaction is being conducted they take a copy of the information and re-transmit it to a host somewhere they control (or to a C&C machine on that network, which they then exfiltrate somehow).
Plus even if you could get your "gotcha" credit cards into the criminal's hands, the chance of law enforcement buying one back is tiny, since the stolen batch is mixed with other cards, and only then a small sub-set is sold (since they verify if the card is still active, and meets other conditions).
My point is, it just won't work with the situation we're dealing with today. Chip & Pin may help reduce retail card theft as it is harder to reproduce a physical card to later use, and internet transactions should require the CSC which a brick and mortar store won't record (even momentarily).
- vcarl 11y agoSwiper skimming might be an issue as well, but didn't some of the largest breaches include stored credit card data? Washington Post says credit and debit card information was included in the Target breach. https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/economy/target-says-70-million-customers-were-hit-by-dec-data-breach-more-than-first-reported/2014/01/10/0ada1026-79fe-11e3-8963-b4b654bcc9b2_story.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/economy/target-says-...
- Someone1234 11y agoI said nothing about swiper skimming. What I said was: > What the criminals are targeting is the card terminals themselves. Meaning when you swipe your card, as the transaction is being conducted they take a copy of the information and re-transmit it to a host somewhere they control (or to a C&C machine on that network, which they then exfiltrate somehow). Which is accurate: > The apparent credit and debit card breach uncovered last week at Home Depot was aided in part by a new variant of the malicious software program that stole card account data from cash registers at Target last December, according to sources close to the investigation. So malware was intercepting the raw CC information inside the card terminal on its way to the payment processor upstream. This allowed them to remotely infect every single Target store in the country, and steal information without setting foot there. http://krebsonsecurity.com/2014/09/home-depot-hit-by-same-malware-as-target/ http://krebsonsecurity.com/2014/09/home-depot-hit-by-same-ma...
- vcarl 11y agoAh, the distinction being that it wasn't stolen in a single bulk breach or via a device placed between the card and the scanner. Fair enough.
- jlgaddis 11y agoYep, lots of these point-of-sale machines are (still!) running XP Embedded which is, AIUI, pretty heavily targeted. Apparently -- but not surprisingly -- they aren't updated all that much so they're pretty susceptible to being compromised.
- robotcookies 11y agoYes, for point-of-sale exploits, this would not work. But certainly there are companies that store CC information. Every time I go to Amazon, I don't re-input my cc info. They must be storing it somewhere? As for buying it back, see my comment about LE not needing to make such purchases for this to work. And if the CC companies know about the fake numbers, the process of verifying that the number works, would itself, inform of the breach.
- bkeroack 11y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tokenization_(data_security) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tokenization_(data_security)
- hobs 11y agoNot downvoting, but the number of corporations storing credit card information would terrify you. Seen it at former jobs as a dba, helped to change that at some, and its among the top ten list of things to check when I start at new one.
- Someone1234 11y agoIf they got caught doing that, both VISA and Mastercard will essentially ban them. At least if it is an insecure as you make it sound and they haven't met PCI DSS. So instead of storing known gotcha cards in these databases, a likely better solution would be to discontinue the use of these databases. Most major retailers don't store credit card numbers. The full information never leaves the terminal, and is discarded when the transaction is complete. PS - Thanks for "Not downvoting" but why would you anyway? Nothing I said contradicts anything you've said. I said large retailers aren't storing CC information. Are you claiming they do? If so, name names.
- S_A_P 11y agoAgreed, the downvote should be used for content you find inappropriate or adds nothing to the discussion. A dissenting opinion that is on topic should not be downvoted.
- oldmanjay 11y agoDownvoting to signal disagreement is allowed, and you can't stop it in practical terms anyway, so accepting that it is a thing is pretty useful.
- hibikir 11y agoWhile I do not want to name names, I have worked for a very large retailer that everyone in the US would know that stored credit card information for quite a long time. They are large enough to do large chunks of their credit card processing themselves, instead of having a third party processor. They even have their own set of cards that they process themselves. It might have changed in the last few years though. Either way, they did take PCI DSS seriously, and passed audits: dual control requirements for keys and all that. Still, accounting could print reports with many credit card numbers, although it was all logged and relatively well tracked. I have not worked in a lot of big retailers though, but I have seen others that featured searching for a missing receipt by credit cards number, or refunds to the original CC way past the window where a processor can just reverse a charge. There's also online retailers, that definitely remember your credit card number. So I suspect there are plenty of retailers that at least have historically kept CC numbers, whether being PCI compliant or not is another matter entirely.
- reitanqild 11y agoCould very well work, only you would need cooperation with one or more major payment processors/card issuers. The way it would work is that shops are given hobeypot cards and asked to use them weekly for dummy payments. The moment one of these cards show up anywhere else than the shop it was sent to you can expect the shop has been hacked. It is not failsafe and you will have to wait until a batch with this card is stolen before this tells you where.
- gherkin0 11y ago> Most large retailers only store the full credit card information for seconds while they process the transaction, when the transaction is complete it is discarded. Couldn't work around that by having some device that attaches to a randomly selected POS terminal, and then executes a series of dummy transactions using thousands of "canary cards" that were assigned to the store? They could perhaps set this up with the credit cards companies so any use of the canary cards are automatically flagged when they're used outside of the store that was issued them.
- ilyanep 11y ago>Plus even if you could get your "gotcha" credit cards into the criminal's hands, the chance of law enforcement buying one back is tiny, since the stolen batch is mixed with other cards, and only then a small sub-set is sold (since they verify if the card is still active, and meets other conditions). You wouldn't need law enforcement to buy it. You just need the bank to watch for a transaction on any of these cards that's not from the merchant it was assigned to.