4 ms·
Because propaganda actually works. We're not trying to push down the actual terrorists; we're trying to win information war waged inside the minds of potential
by golergka 11y ago
Because propaganda actually works. We're not trying to push down the actual terrorists; we're trying to win information war waged inside the minds of potential future terrorists.
You would think that people aren't that stupid. I would think that too. But after witnessing the whole country (Russia) going down the rabbit hole of paranoid madness with just a couple of years of propaganda, I don't think that anymore.
- te_chris 11y agoNow you've done it, any second now you'll get a whole army of pro-russia trolls coming in accusing you of bias and having your eyes closed and what not. I didn't think that was a massive thing, until a girl I went to primary school with in NZ (who, it turns out, is ethnic Russian) jumped on me for daring to suggest that Russia's paid internet trolls are a bit of a joke. There was no reasoning, she just kept quoting zerohedge and RT links at me, ignoring anything I said. I just blocked her, but it was so weird to actually be confronted with the effects of this propoganda.
- pjc50 11y agoIs ZH part of the propaganda operation? I thought it was just a freelance conpiracy theorist running clickbait for the lunatic right. Come to think of it, maybe Trump is a Russian agent. It would explain a lot.
- Mikeb85 11y agoOn the flip side, its just as easy to write off dissenting opinions as 'propaganda'. Just curious, but what do you think the world's opinion of CNN is? Answer: not unbiased news...
- saiya-jin 11y agowait, anybody actually things about any US big media (cnbc, cnn, fox and whatnot) to be NOT biased and quite heavily? they are all under murdoch empire, no? generally, within boundaries of popular news sources, one should use a foreign source to get information for a given country. now finding which one is +-balanced for given country is a tricky thing, and probably not constant as time goes by
- jkestner 11y agoAll media is biased, etc. The important thing is to understand the bias when you're reading. To sibling: only Fox News is owned by Murdoch. You can google for who owns what instead of guessing. MSNBC is biased to the (American) left and CNN is biased to insipidness. All are biased to the establishment and to distract, sensationalism.
- jessaustin 11y agoFox has been kicking CNN etc.'s asses in a commercial sense for decades now. We'd be fools to think that hasn't affected the other networks' reporting. We'd also be fools to think that Fox and MSNBCSBCNC operate from different ends of a spectrum. It's all USA all the time, on both networks. For an alternative try RT or Al Jazeera.
- golergka 11y agoOf course all media is biased. It doesn't mean that it's equally biased.
- golergka 11y agoOh, I know some people who actually managed these guys. And a lot of SMM people who were involved in projects associated with pro-government political forces. Every one of them a nice guy who understands it all, but just needs cash in a harsh industry. At least, that's what they say.
- mapgrep 11y agoAnd clearly the best way to win the information war against an adversary who says we've traded away our values for comfort, riches, and decadence is to throw away the First Amendment because "propaganda works." Keep in mind, we're not just talking about accounts used by actual terrorists to coordinate actual attacks. We're talking about "pro-ISIS" Twitter accounts. How will we decide who is pro-ISIS? I propose a system of hearings, with the most important ones conducted by a senate committee. The most important question at these hearings will be "are you now or have ever been a sympathizer with Islamic State." If they "fail" the hearing we could put them in some kind of database used by employers and government hiring agents and so forth. A sort of blacklist, if you will. And anyone on the blacklist doesn't get to use corporate media platforms. It's not a First Amendment violation, you see, because it's VOLUNTARY. Just ask these guys: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hollywood_blacklist https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hollywood_blacklist
- meowface 11y agoCalling for mass murder isn't a valid case of free speech. And even if it were, Twitter can ban accounts for any reason.
- nkassis 11y ago"Calling for mass murder isn't a valid case of free speech." To be pedantic, yes it is, free speech isn't conditional on the message. Your second statement is true, 1st amendment applies only to the government ability to restrict speech.
- meowface 11y agoI should have said "isn't a valid case of legal free speech in the United States".
- arbitrage 11y agoThe first amendment applies to the government, not to private corporations.
- sschueller 11y agoThe US Gov. also sees it as a useful tool and now can use it against its own people: https://www.questia.com/library/journal/1P3-3695702701/apple-pie-propaganda-the-smith-mundt-act-before-and https://www.questia.com/library/journal/1P3-3695702701/apple...