3 ms·
Is that true? I had a circle of friends 10-15 years back who worked in maintenance for Qantas, and I heard about cleanups and repairs from birdstrike often enou
by bigiain 11y ago
Is that true? I had a circle of friends 10-15 years back who worked in maintenance for Qantas, and I heard about cleanups and repairs from birdstrike often enough to remember it.
I have an uninformed opinion that collisions are not spectacularly uncommon, nor spectacularly serious. I wonder if the magnitude of risk increase we're talking about (by allowing drone operation under current rules, which this incident was not...) exceeds, say, allowing smokers (with their increased risk of coronary problems) to be commercial pilots?
- jacquesm 11y agoBirds hit planes all the time, usually no harm comes of it but there was a nice video (which of course I can't find) where you see a jet on take-off ingesting a single bird and having one hell of an accident. It all depends on what gets hit, how fast the plane is going and at what powerlevel the engines are operating. A bird is a pretty soft item compared to a drone though.
- mikeash 11y agoI'd speculate that airliners hit more birds and suffer from it less compared to small aircraft. I could be way off, but my reasoning is that it's harder for a bird to dodge an airliner since it's moving faster, and the airliner presents much more frontal area. The airliner has much more weight margin for reinforcement, and much more motivation to avoid fatal crashes. (We're vastly less risk tolerant with airliners than small planes; airliners are the safest mode of transportation out there, where small planes are one of the more dangerous.) In any case, I'd guess that the increased risk is quite small at the moment. The question is what it will look like in 10-20 years as this stuff gets more popular and technology continues to drive the price down. How this stuff is handled today will set the stage.
- bigiain 11y agoCuriously, my old airliner maintenance friends used to refer to general aviation and small planes as "bug smashers". It seems little Cessnas (et al) spend _way_ more time "down where the insects are" (and presumably most of the birds), while you can do mach 0.9 for 12 hours at 37,000+ feet without needing to wash the bugs off the windscreen afterwards... (I know a few hours doing ~100kmh at around 1 meter altitude certainly smashes more than a few bugs: https://www.flickr.com/photos/bigiain/115614482/ https://www.flickr.com/photos/bigiain/115614482/ )
- mikeash 11y agoI fly gliders, and one of the post-flight rituals is washing all the bugs off the wings. The flight computers even have bug compensation built in. Smashed bugs degrade the performance of the wing, so there's typically a "bug percentage" setting you can use to de-rate the flight computer's glide estimates as your flight goes on. Some gliders even have wipers you can run along the wing in flight to clean them.