6 ms·
Yet we don't see them falling out of the sky and killing people at rates that comment would suggest. A flock of geese dropped an airliner into the Hudson, but
by bigiain 11y ago
Yet we don't see them falling out of the sky and killing people at rates that comment would suggest.
A flock of geese dropped an airliner into the Hudson, but we still all buy plane tickets when it suits us, because we acknowledge that while there are risks and immensely tragic consequences - the balance of probabilities makes you seem like a crazy-person if you say you're afraid of flying.
- jacquesm 11y agoHelicopters are pretty safe (well, not quite as safe as airliners but not bad, just stay away from the really small ones). But rotorstrikes with metal/plastic composites change the equation in a fairly bad manner. Especially a tail rotor would be pretty easy to break with a 3 pound drone and losing the tail rotor on a helicopter makes your day suddenly much more interesting. Has there been a controlled test where someone flew a drone purposefully into the rotor of a helicopter?
- bigiain 11y ago"Has there been a controlled test where someone flew a drone purposefully into the rotor of a helicopter?" I'd be curious to know that. (It reminds me of the apocryphal chicken cannon story http://www.snopes.com/science/cannon.asp http://www.snopes.com/science/cannon.asp) A few things to keep in mind though. The incident here was at "700-800 feet", the chance of the heli doing Vmax at that height is pretty small (although in this ase it was described as a police heli chasing a car, so _maybe_ it was getting along a a fair clip?). A quadcopter owner in general is pretty motivated to _not_ have his expensive toy smashed up by aviation traffic, in much the same way as birds probably try pretty hard to dodge planes/helis. I think too many people are miscalculating the risks and consequences of "drones" - and it mostly bugs me because they're toys I enjoy playing with (which make me somewhat likely to be doing that miscalculating wrong as well, in the opposite direction…) I also enjoy riding motorcycles, and theres a fairli locally-famous quote here from one of the very senior motor vehicle bureaucrats saying "If motorcycles were invented today, we'd have banned them immediately." In retrospect that would have been "wrong" - motorcycles are "dangerous", sure, but about the same order of magnitude of dangerous as high school football or horse riding - activities which we as society deem "a bit dangerous but perfectly acceptable". And while I know neither you nor I have a dog in the US public opinion fight, I find the hysterical handwringing over the dangers of hobby drone immensely hypocritical from a country where 2/3rds of the elected politicians are deeply in bed with the NRA, and there's an entire industry profiting largely from locking young black men up for use and sale of pot... When the "drone" accident rate approaches within say three orders of magnitude of, say, the drink driving accident rate or even the falling-off-ladders rate, perhaps the media hysteria and the calls from non-participating parties to "ban it all immediately and lock everybody up!" just make people look ignorant and spiteful. (And Jacques, not sure why I'm currently engaging in "robust discussion" on at least two threads in HN with you right now - know that I respect you greatly, while disagreeing occasionally...)
- jacquesm 11y agoThe canon story is hilarious :) I've seen drones flying here that were lifting DSLRs, 8 motors, very powerful and quite heavy. A thing like that would do serious damage just by falling out of the sky, let alone on impact with a fast moving leading edge. Agreed that the drone risk is oversold. But what bugs me is that these morons that do this spoil drones as a useful and recreational thing for everybody else. It won't be long and 'drone operator' and 'irresponsible asshole' will be synonymous. It would be really nice if with every drone sold there would be a simple booklet stating the rules for the location the drone is sold into and some kind of mechanism that requires you to read that document before you can operate the drone.
- bigiain 11y agoAnd, as an uncontrolled anec-data point. I've intentionally flown one of my ~1lb drones into myself while wearing no more protective gear than a long sleeved tshirt "for science" (ie:just to see how bad it'd be if I got it wrong and hit someone else). It hurts a bit, but I wasn't "injured"... (I've not has the courage/foolishness to try it with a larger quad, or even with that little one with carbon fibre props instead of plastic ones...)
- jacquesm 11y agoIt's all about the relative speeds. You're standing still, 1 pound is not a whole lot and likely your drone wasn't going all that fast. But if it had hit you in the face it might have been a different ending. Ditto for a helicopter. Hit it against the front glass panels or the canopy, no big deal. Catch the outer end of the tailrotor and you'll probably crash it.
- mikeash 11y agoWe don't see them falling out of the sky at a high rate because collisions are uncommon, not because collisions are harmless. And the fact that collisions are rare is not an argument for increasing the risk.
- bigiain 11y agoIs that true? I had a circle of friends 10-15 years back who worked in maintenance for Qantas, and I heard about cleanups and repairs from birdstrike often enough to remember it. I have an uninformed opinion that collisions are not spectacularly uncommon, nor spectacularly serious. I wonder if the magnitude of risk increase we're talking about (by allowing drone operation under current rules, which this incident was not...) exceeds, say, allowing smokers (with their increased risk of coronary problems) to be commercial pilots?
- jacquesm 11y agoBirds hit planes all the time, usually no harm comes of it but there was a nice video (which of course I can't find) where you see a jet on take-off ingesting a single bird and having one hell of an accident. It all depends on what gets hit, how fast the plane is going and at what powerlevel the engines are operating. A bird is a pretty soft item compared to a drone though.
- mikeash 11y agoI'd speculate that airliners hit more birds and suffer from it less compared to small aircraft. I could be way off, but my reasoning is that it's harder for a bird to dodge an airliner since it's moving faster, and the airliner presents much more frontal area. The airliner has much more weight margin for reinforcement, and much more motivation to avoid fatal crashes. (We're vastly less risk tolerant with airliners than small planes; airliners are the safest mode of transportation out there, where small planes are one of the more dangerous.) In any case, I'd guess that the increased risk is quite small at the moment. The question is what it will look like in 10-20 years as this stuff gets more popular and technology continues to drive the price down. How this stuff is handled today will set the stage.