3 ms·
If that's your definition of "drone" then have all RC aircraft have magically become "drones" since the media started using the word? What about kites? Model ro
by bigiain 11y ago
If that's your definition of "drone" then have all RC aircraft have magically become "drones" since the media started using the word? What about kites? Model rockets? Birthday balloons?Frisbees? Boomerangs?
I'm not saying you're right or wrong, but it's clear that right now there's no community consensus on the technical definition of "drone" anything more rigorous than the "I don't know what obscenity is, but know it when I see it" argument.
Does a "drone" need to be autonomous? Does it need to carry a camera? Does it need to be a multirotor? Is there a size limit? Is my 1.5oz CX10 a "drone"? My ~1kg GPS guided autonomous quadrotor? Where's the line? How about my 450g non-autonomous FPV one? Or my 320g one that doesn't even have a camera?
Was the heli pilot any more at-risk that if it's been a buzzard or a goose?
(Note: I think the guy was a jerk for being up at 7-800 feet with a chopper nearby, but nobody died - there's no suggestion that anybody even came close to dying. Is the situation and it's outcome any worse than it he'd been somewhat recklessly driving at 90mph on the highway rather than somewhat recklessly flying at 800 feet over it? If you do 90 in your car and hit someone, they hold you accountable. If you do 90 in your car and don't hit anyone else but happen to be observed by the police, they don't penalise you as though you just killed someone, they write you a ticket. Should this guy be treated any differently?)
- mikeash 11y agoRC aircraft have been "drones" since long before anybody in the media cared about the word. Probably the most common use of the word before the current quadcopter craze was in the phrase "target drone," which is typically a large remote-controlled aircraft that military pilots can shoot at for training. I think the word implies some kind of guidance, whether automatic or remote-piloted, so model rockets and such would not qualify. Kites aren't really aircraft. Does a "drone" need to be autonomous? I see no use, past or present, that implies autonomy. Camera? Again, no. Multirotor? Historically no, current media usage maybe. Size limit? Don't think so. A large hobby drone is definitely more of a risk than a buzzard or goose. Birds can dodge. They're not always successful, but the instinct for self-preservation usually gets them out of the way, at least for slow aircraft like a typical helicopter. Helicopters make a ton of noise too, which probably helps a lot. Going 90MPH on the highway is a pretty major offense in many places. Here in Virginia that's an automatic reckless driving misdemeanor charge that's likely to result in jail time. No, they don't punish you the same as they would if you actually kill somebody, but then there's no indication they'll punish this guy as if he killed somebody, so I have no idea why you'd mention that.